Supreme Court of India2000
(2000) 6 Supreme Court Cases 204
Transfer of criminal case is warranted where a fair and impartial trial is not possible in the original court due to local prejudice, hostile atmosphere, or threat to the accused.
transferfair-trialarticle-21S.430-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1991
(1992) 1 SCC 225
The right to speedy trial is judged by a balancing test, without a fixed outer limit.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 10 SCC 489
A claim of juvenility can be raised at any stage of proceedings.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1965
AIR 1966 SC 119; 1966 SCR (1) 134
A confessional FIR by the accused is wholly inadmissible except for the discovery portion (now S.23 BSA).
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
AIR 2013 SC 633
A Judicial Magistrate cannot discharge an accused in a case triable by the Sessions Court; it must commit the case to the Sessions Court and may only refuse to take cognizance after examining the material on record.
cognizancecommittalsessions-triablemagistrate-discharge
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1973
AIR 1973 Supreme Court 2145
In a criminal appeal, the appellate court can reappraise evidence independently but should not disturb findings of fact unless they are perverse, based on no evidence, or result in miscarriage of justice.
appealrevisionevidence-reappreciationS.415-BNSSappellate-powerssem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 9 SCC 460
Revision corrects patent errors of law and propriety; it is not a second appeal.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2013
(2013) 6 SCC 770
Courts have a mandatory duty to apply their mind to compensation under S.357 CrPC in every criminal case and to record reasons for awarding or refusing it
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2020
AIR 2020 SC 1308; AIROnline 2020 SC 17
S.144 CrPC cannot be used to suppress legitimate expression; orders must state material facts and be proportionate, and internet suspension cannot be indefinite
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1952
AIR 1952 Supreme Court 75
A law providing for trial by special courts without intelligible differentia between persons tried by special courts and ordinary courts violates Art.14. The State cannot deny a citizen the right to trial by established courts without reasonable classification.
special-courtsarticle-14classificationequal-protectionfair-trial
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2014
(2014) 8 SCC 273
For offences punishable with up to seven years, arrest must be shown to be necessary under S.41(1)(b) CrPC (now S.35(1)(b) BNSS), with reasons recorded.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2000
(2000) 5 SCC 488
Under the Juvenile Justice Act, 1986, the age of the person is determined when he is brought before the competent authority; the date of the commission of the offence is irrelevant.
juvenile-justiceage-determinationcompetent-authorityJJ-Act-1986
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1970
AIR 1970 Supreme Court 1228
Distinction between 'public order' and 'law and order': public order is the widest ripple in a pond (community-wide impact); mere law and order is the ripple closest to the pebble (individual impact).
public-orderlaw-and-orderdistinctionpreventive-powerssem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2017
(2017) 15 SCC 55
Parole and furlough are different; neither may be refused arbitrarily.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 Supreme Court 884
Preventive detention and orders under S.144 CrPC (now S.163 BNSS) are valid even without prior hearing; the nature of preventive action requires swiftness. However, such orders must be reasonable, temporary, proportionate, and subject to judicial review.
preventive-powersS.163-BNSSpublic-ordernatural-justiceArt-19
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2001
(2001) 7 Supreme Court Cases 401
Summons issued under S.61 CrPC (now S.64 BNSS) for appearance of accused must be served in the manner prescribed; substituted service is permissible only after due diligence in personal service.
summonsservice-of-processS.64-BNSSsubstituted-servicesem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2007
(2007) 4 SCC 415
In appeals against acquittal, the appellate court may review all evidence but must respect the double presumption of innocence.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2007
AIR 2008 SC 530
'Unable to maintain herself' does not mean destitute; the test is whether the wife can maintain herself as she was used to in her husband's home
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
(2005) 7 Supreme Court Cases 467
A Magistrate takes cognizance of an offence and not of an offender. Cognizance is taken at the point when the Magistrate applies mind to the allegations in a complaint/police report and decides to proceed.
cognizancemagistrate-powersS.228-BNSStaking-cognizancesem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1997
AIR 1997 Supreme Court 610
Eleven mandatory requirements for lawful arrest laid down to prevent custodial violence. Non-compliance renders arrest illegal and entitles compensation.
arrestcustodial-violencearticle-21guidelinesrightsS.47-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1991
(1991) 4 SCC 406; AIR 1991 SC 2176
The arrest of a judicial officer must follow special safeguards that protect the independence of the judiciary.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
(1994) 2 SCC 220
Where the prosecution rests on circumstantial evidence, the circumstances must be conclusively established and consistent only with the guilt of the accused. The rape and murder of a young girl by a security guard, being brutal and pre-planned, fell in the rarest-of-rare category and the death sentence was confirmed.
circumstantial-evidencedeath-sentencerarest-of-rarerapemurdersection-302section-376
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 10 SCC 303
Quashing on settlement under the High Court's inherent power is distinct from compounding, and is not available for heinous offences.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1984
AIR 1984 Supreme Court 237
The court has a duty to inquire into the age of the accused suo motu if there is any indication of juvenility. It is not merely the right of the accused but the obligation of the court.
juvenile-justiceage-inquirycourt-dutysuo-motusem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1978
(1978) 1 SCC 240; AIR 1978 SC 429
Bail is a matter of judicial discretion to be exercised with regard to personal liberty under Art.21 and the stated factors.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1980
(1980) 2 SCC 565; AIR 1980 SC 1632
The power to grant anticipatory bail is wide and must not be read down by restrictions not found in the statute.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1955
AIR 1955 Supreme Court 196
Defective investigation does not automatically vitiate trial. Investigation and trial are distinct stages; irregularity in investigation does not per se invalidate proceedings unless material prejudice is shown.
investigationdefecttrialprejudiceirregularitysem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1988
AIR 1988 SC 2127; (1988) 4 SCC 551; 1988 SCR Supl. (2) 571
Compensation to the victim under S.357 CrPC must be reasonable, fixed on the facts and the accused's capacity to pay; it is a measure of responding to crime
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2000
(2001) 1 SCC 169
A criminal court cannot review its own final order; inherent powers cannot override S.362 CrPC (now S.403 BNSS).
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2021
Suo Motu Writ Petition (Crl.) No. 2 of 2020, decided 16 April 2021
A summary trial under S.143 NI Act may be converted to a summons trial only for recorded reasons.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
Suo Motu Writ Petition (Crl.) No. 122 of 2011
A prohibitory order cannot be enforced by force against a peaceful, sleeping assembly without warning and reasonable time to disperse
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2007
AIR 2008 SC 251; (2007) 12 SCC 1
Non-bailable warrants should be issued only after summons and bailable warrants fail, unless the offence is heinous and evasion or tampering is likely; inherent power may quash proceedings that abuse process
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2014
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 18 of 2013
Courts trying S.138 NI Act complaints must follow practical directions for summary trial and speedy disposal
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1972
AIR 1972 SC 1295
The Probation of Offenders Act applies unless expressly excluded, and youth weighs strongly in favour of probation.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1972
AIR 1972 Supreme Court 1295
S.6 POA mandates that no person under 21 shall be imprisoned without first considering probation. Court must call for probation officer's report and record reasons before sentencing under-21 offender.
probationunder-21S.6-POAmandatorysentencingsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2013
(2013) 11 SCC 193
A juvenile convicted in an adult trial must receive the dispositional benefit of the juvenile justice law.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
AIR 1994 Supreme Court 1349
Arrest must be justified; right to inform friend/relative and right to consult lawyer apply. Personal liberty demands restraint in exercise of arrest power.
arrestpersonal-libertyrightsarticle-21article-22sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1965
AIR 1966 SC 657; 1966 SCR (2) 406
Members of a legislature have no immunity from criminal arrest or valid preventive detention.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1999
(1999) 7 Supreme Court Cases 510
The S.138 NI Act offence has five components: drawing of the cheque, its presentation to the bank, its return unpaid, the notice of demand, and the drawer's failure to pay within 15 days of receiving the notice. A court within whose jurisdiction any one of these occurred can try the case (ss.178, 179 CrPC 1973). A notice returned unclaimed can be deemed served.
jurisdictioncheque-dishonourS.138-NI-Actdeemed-servicesummons-casesterritorial-jurisdictionsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
(1994) 3 Supreme Court Cases 569
Even in special anti-terrorism legislation, basic fair trial safeguards cannot be eliminated. Accused must have right to legal representation, cross-examination, knowledge of charges, speedy trial, and protection against self-incrimination.
fair-trialTADAterrorismarticle-21special-legislationsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1980
AIR 1980 SC 854; (1980) 3 SCC 120; (1980) 2 SCR 1037
A plea of guilty induced by a promise of leniency cannot support a conviction.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1989
AIR 1989 Supreme Court 653
President's power to grant pardon under Art. 72 is of the widest amplitude. The President can examine the case on merits independent of judicial findings.
pardonarticle-72presidential-powermercydeath-penaltysem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1996
AIRONLINE 1996 SC 1175
Police cannot investigate a non-cognizable offence without the order of a Magistrate; an investigation and report made without it are illegal.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1980
(1981) 1 SCC 627
Free legal aid is part of Article 21 from the first production before a Magistrate.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2011
(2011) 2 SCC 703
S.300(1) CrPC (now S.337(1) BNSS) bars a second trial on the same facts even for a different offence.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2014
(2014) 2 Supreme Court Cases 1
Registration of FIR is mandatory under S.154 CrPC (now S.173 BNSS) when information discloses a cognizable offence. Preliminary inquiry (max 7 days) permissible only where cognizability is unclear.
FIRmandatory-registrationcognizablepolice-dutyS.173-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 8 Supreme Court Cases 730; [2012] 7 SCR 469
A person who has been declared a \"proclaimed offender\" under S.82 CrPC (now S.84 BNSS) — i.e. who is absconding or concealing himself to avoid execution of a warrant — is, as a rule, not entitled to anticipatory bail under S.438 CrPC (now S.482 BNSS).
anticipatory-bailsection-438-crpcsection-482-bnssproclaimed-offendersection-82-crpcabsconder
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2020
AIR 2020 SC 5245; Criminal Appeal No. 699 of 2020
The right to default bail is availed of by applying, and a later charge sheet cannot defeat it.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1954
AIR 1954 SC 300
Search and seizure under a warrant is not testimonial compulsion under Article 20(3).
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1983
AIR 1983 Supreme Court 957
Five categories of rarest-of-rare cases enumerated: manner of commission (extreme brutality), motive (total depravity), anti-social nature, magnitude of crime, personality of victim.
death-penaltyrarest-of-rarecategoriessentencingsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1970
AIR 1971 Supreme Court 2486
An order under S.144 CrPC (now S.163 BNSS) is subject to judicial review. The affected person can challenge it under S.133 CrPC or under Art.226/Art.32. The order must disclose material facts demonstrating urgency; a blanket order without application of mind is bad in law.
S.163-BNSSpreventive-ordersjudicial-reviewpublic-orderArt-19sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2010
(2010) 10 SCC 130
An error in the charge is fatal only if the accused was in fact misled and a failure of justice resulted; knowledge of the real charge can be inferred from the defence.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2018
(2019) 2 SCC 752
A victim may appeal against acquittal as of right, without leave.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1978
AIR 1978 Supreme Court 597
Art.21 requires that procedure established by law be fair, just, and reasonable; not arbitrary, fanciful, or oppressive. Art.14, 19, and 21 are interconnected (the 'golden triangle').
constitutional-lawarticle-21fair-procedurepersonal-libertygolden-triangle
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1979
(1979) 4 Supreme Court Cases 167
Transfer of criminal case can be ordered under S.407 CrPC (now S.430 BNSS) where a reasonable apprehension exists that a fair trial is not possible due to hostile atmosphere, political influence, or media prejudice. The convenience of the accused and ends of justice are paramount considerations.
transferfair-trialS.430-BNSSpolitical-influencesem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2017
(2018) 1 SCC 560; AIR 2017 SC 4594
Cheque dishonour cases are normally tried summarily, and conversion to a summons trial needs recorded reasons.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2001
(2001) 4 SCC 350; AIR 2001 SC 1490
Whether acts form the same transaction is a question of fact decided by proximity of time and place, continuity of action and community of purpose or design.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1985
AIR 1985 Supreme Court 945
A divorced Muslim woman is entitled to maintenance under S.125 CrPC (now S.144 BNSS) even after the iddat period if she is unable to maintain herself; the secular provision of maintenance applies to all women irrespective of religion.
maintenancesection-125-crpcmuslim-lawuniform-civil-codedivorced-muslim-woman
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 9 SCC 408
A conviction cannot stand where the accused was denied the effective assistance of counsel at the trial. A criminal appellate court may set aside the conviction and order a retrial under s.386 CrPC, with a direction that legal aid be provided and the retrial concluded expeditiously.
fair-triallegal-aidright-to-counselretrialsection-386art-21death-sentence
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2010
(2011) 1 SCC 284
Double jeopardy requires identity of the offence; overlapping facts are not enough.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1978
AIR 1978 Supreme Court 1594
Bail amount must be reasonable. Personal bond without surety suffices for indigent accused. Bail must not become a privilege of the wealthy.
bailpersonal-bondpovertyarticle-14article-21sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1976
(1976) 3 SCC 684
Negotiated pleas of guilt that defeat minimum sentences are contrary to the public interest.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1969
AIR 1970 Supreme Court 446
In proceedings for maintenance under S.125 CrPC (now S.144 BNSS), the standard of proof is preponderance of probability, not proof beyond reasonable doubt. The wife need not prove neglect or refusal conclusively: a prima facie case suffices for the Magistrate to pass an order.
maintenanceS.144-BNSSstandard-of-proofwife-children-parentssem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1978
AIR 1978 Supreme Court 1025
Art.20(3) protection against self-incrimination operates during police interrogation. A person is not bound to answer questions tending to expose them to criminal charge.
self-incriminationarticle-20-3police-interrogationinvestigationright-to-silence
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
(2008) 16 SCC 417
Reverse burdens apply only after the prosecution strictly proves the foundational facts.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2017
(2017) 9 Supreme Court Cases 641
Inherent powers under S.482 (now S.528 BNSS) can be exercised to quash even non-compoundable offences if the dispute is essentially private and parties have settled.
quashingsettlementnon-compoundableinherent-powersS.528-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1974
AIR 1974 Supreme Court 348
Art. 20(3) protects against testimonial compulsion, not against search and seizure of physical evidence. Seizure of documents from accused does not violate self-incrimination privilege.
self-incriminationarticle-20-3search-seizureevidencesem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2024
2024 INSC 414
The grounds of arrest must be furnished to the arrested person in writing; failure invalidates the arrest and remand.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
(2006) 8 Supreme Court Cases 1
Seven directives for police reform: State Security Commission, fixed DGP tenure, fixed SHO tenure, separation of investigation from law and order, Police Establishment Board, Police Complaints Authority, National Security Commission.
police-reformseven-directivesgovernancearticle-21sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
(2005) 3 Supreme Court Cases 551
The relevant date for determining whether an accused is a juvenile is the date of commission of the offence, not the date of apprehension or trial.
juvenile-justiceage-determinationdate-of-commissionJJ-Actsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1993
(1993) Supp 1 Supreme Court Cases 529
Contempt of court must be distinguished from fair criticism. Contempt jurisdiction exists to protect administration of justice, not the personal dignity of judges. Scandalizing the court as a whole by imputing motives or bias undermines public confidence and constitutes criminal contempt.
contemptadministration-of-justicefair-criticismArt-19sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2023
2023 INSC 1008
Limited transit anticipatory bail for an FIR in another State may be granted in exceptional cases.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2015
(2015) 6 Supreme Court Cases 287
Before a Magistrate takes cognizance on a private complaint, he must apply judicial mind and may direct preliminary inquiry to verify the truthfulness of allegations. Courts must prevent abuse of criminal process through frivolous complaints.
complaintcognizanceabuse-of-processpreliminary-inquiryS.223-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 Supreme Court 1589
Jurisdiction of a court depends on the nature and gravity of the offence. The power of a Magistrate to try an offence is limited by the sentence he can impose. If the offence warrants punishment beyond his powers, the case must be committed to the Court of Session.
jurisdictionmagistrate-powerssentence-limitationcommitmentS.21-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1960
AIR 1960 Supreme Court 866
Three categories where High Court should quash criminal proceedings: no legal evidence, evidence manifestly inadequate, allegations do not constitute offence in law.
quashinginherent-powersearly-authorityS.528-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1951
AIR 1951 Supreme Court 207
Taking cognizance under S.190 CrPC (now S.228 BNSS) means the Magistrate takes judicial notice of the commission of an offence. It does not require a formal order or express pronouncement: the act of applying mind to the complaint/report and deciding to proceed constitutes taking cognizance.
cognizanceS.228-BNSSmagistrate-powerstaking-cognizancejudicial-noticesem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1962
AIR 1963 SC 822
Evidence obtained in an illegal search is admissible if relevant, but is scrutinised with care.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2021
AIR 2021 SC 569; AIROnline 2020 SC 915
Comprehensive guidelines for maintenance proceedings: overlapping claims must be adjusted, income affidavit mandatory, interim maintenance within specified time, children's needs assessed separately.
maintenanceguidelinesincome-affidavitinterimS.144-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1966
AIR 1966 Supreme Court 740
A preventive-detention order resting even partly on a ground outside the scope of the authorising rule is invalid; the court may review whether the detaining authority misapprehended the limits of its own power, though not the sufficiency of its satisfaction.
preventive-detentionhabeas-corpusarticle-32article-359defence-of-india-rulessem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1997
(1997) 2 Supreme Court Cases 642
Nine problems identified in Indian prisons including overcrowding, delayed trials, torture, neglect of health, and lack of legal aid. Directed states to address prison conditions.
prison-reformprisoners-rightsarticle-21nine-problemsconditionssem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1965
AIR 1965 Supreme Court 444
Court must consider the Probation of Offenders Act before imposing imprisonment. Failure to consider is an error of law. The younger the offender and less serious the offence, the stronger the case for probation.
probationsentencingfirst-offenderPOA-1958mandatory-considerationsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1983
(1983) 4 SCC 141; AIR 1983 SC 1086
Compensation may be awarded under Art.32 for unlawful detention in violation of Art.21.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1954
AIR 1954 SC 375
Departmental proceedings are not prosecution under Article 20(2) and do not bar a criminal trial.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
(2008) 2 Supreme Court Cases 409
Where police refuse to register an FIR, the aggrieved person should approach the Magistrate under S.156(3) CrPC (now S.175(3) BNSS) rather than the High Court under Art.226. The Magistrate can direct police to register FIR and investigate, and can monitor the investigation.
complaintFIRS.175-BNSSmagistrate-powerspolice-investigationsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2013
(2013) 7 Supreme Court Cases 705
Age of 18 as juvenility threshold is based on scientific understanding of adolescent brain development and UNCRC; not arbitrary under Art. 14.
juvenile-justiceage-thresholdbrain-developmentarticle-14UNCRCsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2018
(2018) 4 Supreme Court Cases 433
The JJ Act 2015 mandates that no juvenile shall be kept in a jail or police lockup at any stage. Child-friendly approach must permeate all interactions with juveniles in conflict with law. Compliance with institutional care standards is mandatory, not aspirational.
juvenile-justiceprotectioninstitutional-carechild-friendlyJJ-Act-2015sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 1 SCC 40; AIR 2012 SC 830
Pre-trial detention is not punishment; the gravity of the charge alone does not justify refusing bail once custody is no longer necessary.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1976
AIR 1976 SC 2386; 1977 SCR (1) 229
After conviction the accused must be heard on sentence under S.235(2) CrPC; failure to do so requires remand on sentence
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2022
Miscellaneous Application No. 1849 of 2021 in SLP (Crl.) No. 5191 of 2021
Bail is the rule and jail the exception; courts and police must comply with S.41 and S.41A CrPC, decide bail promptly and implement the undertrial release provision
bailgraded-systemarrestarticle-21guidelinesS.479-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
AIR 2005 SC 1809; (2005) 3 SCC 636
A woman whose marriage is void because the man's earlier marriage subsisted is not a 'wife' entitled to maintenance under S.125 CrPC
maintenanceS.144-BNSSMuslim-womanseculardivorced-wifesem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2014
(2014) 3 Supreme Court Cases 1
Inordinate delay in disposal of mercy petition violates Art. 21 and constitutes ground for commutation of death sentence to life imprisonment.
death-penaltymercy-petitiondelaycommutationarticle-21S.472-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1986
AIR 1986 Supreme Court 1773
No child shall be kept in jail or police lockup. Separate homes with education and rehabilitation must be provided for juvenile offenders.
juvenile-justicechildrenarticle-21institutional-caresem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1987
AIR 1987 Supreme Court 877
PP must exercise independent judgment in seeking withdrawal. It must not be mechanical rubber-stamping of executive directions. Court must be satisfied withdrawal serves public interest.
prosecutionwithdrawalS.321independencepublic-interestsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2020
(2020) 2 SCC 787
Only offences carrying a minimum of seven years are heinous under the JJ Act.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
AIR 1995 SC 980; (1995) 2 SCC 76
A Magistrate recording a confession must make a searching enquiry about custody and treatment, give time for reflection free of police influence, and assure the accused he will not be remanded to police custody if he declines
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2011
(2011) 1 Supreme Court Cases 694
Anticipatory bail under S.438 CrPC protects personal liberty against false or motivated prosecution; the Constitution Bench's Sibbia reasoning (that normally the operation of an anticipatory-bail order is NOT to be limited in time) must be followed, and smaller-bench decisions imposing a fixed duration followed by compulsory surrender are per incuriam. (The Court's further 'no restrictive conditions at all' position was later qualified by the Constitution Bench in Sushila Aggarwal (2020) — flag this when citing for the conditions point.)
anticipatory-bailsection-438personal-libertysem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1993
1993 Supp (2) SCC 547 (as in the existing file)
Police cannot refuse to record an FIR on the ground of territorial jurisdiction.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1960
AIR 1961 SC 578
Same offence means an offence with the same ingredients, not merely one arising from the same facts.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1965
AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1251
Section 94(1) CrPC (compelling production of documents), on its true construction, does not apply to an accused person — reading it to cover an accused would conflict with the protection against self-incrimination under Article 20(3).
self-incriminationarticle-20-3section-94-crpcproduction-of-documentssem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1992
1992 Supp (1) Supreme Court Cases 335
Seven categories enumerated where High Court may quash FIR/criminal proceedings under S.482 CrPC (now S.528 BNSS) to prevent abuse of process.
quashinginherent-powersS.528-BNSSFIRabuse-of-processsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2017
(2017) 12 Supreme Court Cases 127
Under IPC provisions using \"and shall also be liable to fine,\" a sentencing court cannot substitute a fine alone for the mandatory term of imprisonment — both are required, and an appellate court's power under S.386 CrPC to alter a sentence does not extend to replacing a lawfully-imposed custodial sentence with fine alone.
sentencingsection-386-crpcfine-vs-imprisonmentproportionalitysem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1992
AIR 1992 SC 2100; (1992) 3 SCC 700; 1992 SCR (3) 480
S.235(2) CrPC is mandatory, but a same-day sentence is not vitiated where the accused had a real opportunity and no prejudice is shown
judgmentreasoningS.354-CrPCS.392-BNSSpoints-for-determinationsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1999
(1999) 6 SCC 172
Breach of the mandatory S.50 NDPS safeguard makes a conviction resting only on the recovery unsafe.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1977
AIR 1977 SC 2447; (1977) 4 SCC 308
The basic rule is bail, not jail, subject to the risk of flight, obstruction of justice or repeated offences.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1964
AIR 1964 Supreme Court 221
An illegality in investigation (here, an inquiry by a Sub-Inspector without the Magistrate's permission required by s.5A of the Prevention of Corruption Act 1947) does not by itself vitiate the trial or the conviction; the conviction stands unless the accused shows that the illegality caused prejudice or a miscarriage of justice.
investigationillegal-investigationprejudices5A-PCA-1947H-N-Rishbudsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2000
(1999) 6 SCC 120; AIR 2000 SC 164; 1999 Supp (4) SCR 239
Before the 2005 amendment, a court could not dispose of a criminal case or appeal by a bargain on sentence.
plea-bargainingcompoundingS.313-BNSSS.320-CrPCsettlementsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2014
(2014) 8 Supreme Court Cases 390
JJ Act 2000's uniform 18-year threshold for juvenility is constitutionally valid. Legislature has prerogative to fix age of criminal responsibility based on scientific evidence and international obligations.
juvenile-justiceage-thresholdconstitutional-validitynirbhayaarticle-14sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1980
AIR 1980 Supreme Court 1579
Prisoners retain fundamental rights under Art. 21. Rights do not stop at prison gates. Torture, bar fetters, and inhuman conditions are prohibited.
prisoners-rightsarticle-21prison-reformtorturedignitysem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2013
AIRONLINE 2013 SC 381
In a warrant case instituted on a complaint, a charge must rest on evidence taken under S.244 CrPC, with the accused's right to cross-examine, not on statements recorded before cognizance.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1979
AIR 1980 SC 52; (1979) 4 SCC 274; 1980 SCR (1) 323
At the stage of framing charge, the Magistrate need only see whether the materials prima facie disclose the offence; a discharge on a contestable view of the facts is wrong
warrant-casemagistrate-trialS.259-BNSSproceduresem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1954
AIR 1954 SC 194; 1954 SCR 330
A judgment is the final decision pronounced or delivered in open court; a judgment signed but delivered after a judge's death is no judgment
judgmentreasoningspeaking-orderS.392-BNSSfair-trialsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2020
AIR 2020 SC 831; SLP (Crl) Nos. 7281-7282 of 2017
Anticipatory bail is ordinarily not time-bound and may last till the end of the trial.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1970
AIR 1970 SC 1566
A cryptic telephone message that does not disclose a cognizable offence is not an FIR.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1983
(1983) 1 SCC 194; AIR 1983 SC 747
A plea of guilty obtained through plea bargaining cannot be used to enhance the sentence; the remedy is retrial.
plea-bargainingguilty-pleaS.313-BNSSvoluntary-pleafair-trialsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1958
AIR 1959 SC 375
Administrative confiscation and penalty proceedings are not prosecution under Article 20(2).
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1972
(1972) 3 SCC 393; AIR 1973 SC 501
Unexplained delay in lodging the FIR deprives it of spontaneity and creates a danger of embellishment.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1999
(1999) 8 Supreme Court Cases 686
The jurisdiction of a criminal court to entertain and try an offence depends on whether any part of the cause of action arose within its territorial limits. For offences involving transactions at multiple locations, jurisdiction lies where any essential ingredient of the offence occurred.
jurisdictionterritorialcause-of-actionmulti-location-offenceS.211-BNSSsem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1979
AIR 1979 SC 366; (1979) 3 SCC 4; 1979 SCR (2) 229
At the stage of discharge, the Judge weighs the material only to see if a prima facie case or grave suspicion exists; mere suspicion where two views are possible justifies discharge.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2003
(2003) 6 Supreme Court Cases 195
Investigation, inquiry, and trial are distinct stages of criminal proceedings. Investigation is conducted by police, inquiry by Magistrate, and trial by the competent court. The right to a fair investigation is part of Art.21, and investigation must be completed within reasonable time.
investigationinquirytrialdistinctionS.2-BNSSArt-21sem-5
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1980
AIR 1980 SC 962; 1980 SCR (2) 380
An order framing a charge is interlocutory, but it must follow a judicial application of mind to whether a prima facie case is made out.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1956
AIR 1956 SC 116; 1955 SCR (2) 1140
An omission or error in the charge vitiates a trial only if it causes prejudice amounting to a failure of justice.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2004
(2004) 4 Supreme Court Cases 158
Fair trial under Art. 21 includes protection of witnesses. A trial where witnesses are intimidated into turning hostile is not fair.
fair-trialwitness-protectionarticle-21Best-Bakerysem-5
Read case brief →