Constitutional Law I case briefs

66 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Constitutional Law I notes.

66 briefs in Constitutional Law I
Supreme Court of India1950

A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras

AIR 1950 Supreme Court 27

Procedure established by law in Art.21 means any enacted law; fairness or reasonableness is not required. (Overruled by Maneka Gandhi, 1978.)

art-21procedure-established-by-lawpreventive-detentionpositivismoverruled
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1982

A.K. Roy v Union of India

AIR 1982 Supreme Court 710

Preventive detention under the National Security Act is constitutional, including exclusion of legal representation before Advisory Boards, but Art.22(5) requires detention grounds to be furnished with sufficient particularity and promptness to enable effective representation.

preventive-detentionarticle-22national-security-actadvisory-boardprocedural-safeguards
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1976

ADM Jabalpur v Shivkant Shukla

AIR 1976 Supreme Court 1207

Per Khanna J (dissenting, now accepted as correct): the rule of law exists prior to and independent of the Constitution; it cannot be suspended even during Emergency.

administrative-lawrule-of-lawemergencyhabeas-corpussem-3
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2001

AIIMS Students' Union v AIIMS

AIR 2002 Supreme Court 3262

Fundamental Duties under Art.51A, while not directly enforceable, can be used by courts as an interpretive aid to test the reasonableness of restrictions on fundamental rights; excessive institutional reservation in admissions violates Art.14.

fundamental-dutiesarticle-51ainstitutional-reservationarticle-14interpretive-aid
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1981

Ajay Hasia v. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi

AIR 1981 Supreme Court 487

Government control test for determining 'State' under Art.12: financial, administrative, and functional control makes a body 'State' regardless of formal autonomy.

administrative-lawart-12stategovernment-control-testinstrumentality
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1952

Anwar Ali Sarkar v. State of West Bengal

AIR 1952 Supreme Court 75

A law providing for trial by special courts without intelligible differentia between persons tried by special courts and ordinary courts violates Art.14. The State cannot deny a citizen the right to trial by established courts without reasonable classification.

special-courtsarticle-14classificationequal-protectionfair-trial
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1989

B.R. Singh v. Union of India

(1989) 4 Supreme Court Cases 710

Strike is not raised to the status of a fundamental right, but is recognized as an important weapon in the armoury of workers for redressing grievances; the right to form a union, by contrast, IS a fundamental right under Art.19(1)(c).

strikelegitimate-weaponarticle-19trade-unionrule-32reinstatement
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1960

Babulal Parate v State of Bombay

AIR 1960 Supreme Court 51

Parliament's power under Article 3 to form new states or alter boundaries does not require a special majority under Art.368; such laws are passed by simple majority and are not 'amendments' to the Constitution.

article-3article-4article-368reorganisation-of-statessimple-majority
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1961

Babulal Parate v. State of Maharashtra

AIR 1961 Supreme Court 884

Preventive detention and orders under S.144 CrPC (now S.163 BNSS) are valid even without prior hearing; the nature of preventive action requires swiftness. However, such orders must be reasonable, temporary, proportionate, and subject to judicial review.

preventive-powersS.163-BNSSpublic-ordernatural-justiceArt-19
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1984

Bandhua Mukti Morcha v. Union of India

(1984) 3 Supreme Court Cases 161

Bonded labour violates Arts.21 and 23; State has positive obligation to identify, release, and rehabilitate bonded labourers.

landmarkbonded-labourArt-21Art-23PILpositive-obligation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1955

Bhikaji Narain Dhakras and Ors. v State of Madhya Pradesh

AIR 1955 Supreme Court 781

A pre-Constitution law that is inconsistent with fundamental rights becomes void only 'to the extent of the inconsistency' under Article 13(1); it is not wiped out permanently, and if the fundamental right is later amended to remove the inconsistency, the law revives without re-enactment. This is the 'doctrine of eclipse.'

article-13doctrine-of-eclipsepre-constitution-lawrevival-of-law
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1951

Chiranjit Lal Chowdhuri v. Union of India

AIR 1951 Supreme Court 41

A statute may validly single out one enterprise for special treatment (nationalisation/takeover) if there is an intelligible differentia with a rational nexus to the object sought. Classification need not be abstract; it can be a "class of one" if circumstances justify.

article-14classificationclass-of-onenationalisationintelligible-differentia
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1961

Daryao v. State of Uttar Pradesh

AIR 1961 Supreme Court 1457

The principle of res judicata applies to writ proceedings. A writ petition dismissed on merits by the High Court under Article 226 bars a subsequent petition before the Supreme Court under Article 32 on the same grounds.

CPCres-judicatasection-11writ-petitionarticle-32article-226constitutional-remedyfinality
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1974

E.P. Royappa v State of Tamil Nadu

AIR 1974 Supreme Court 555

Article 14 is not confined to the classical 'reasonable classification' test; equality is antithetic to arbitrariness, and any state action that is arbitrary must necessarily involve a negation of equality.

article-14arbitrarinessnew-doctrine-of-equalityreasonable-classification
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1979

Excel Wear v. Union of India

(1979) 1 Supreme Court Cases 292

Section 25-O of the ID Act (prior government permission for closure) was struck down as an unreasonable restriction violating Art.19(1)(g); the right to carry on business includes the right to close it, and the State cannot force indefinite operation of a genuinely unviable business.

closureprior-permissionArt-19-1-gunconstitutionalstruck-down
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1981

Fertilizer Corporation Kamgar Union (Regd.), Sindri v Union of India

AIR 1981 Supreme Court 344

Art.32 is a remedy for enforcement of fundamental rights, not a general instrument for judicial review of every managerial/commercial decision; courts will not interfere with bona fide business decisions of public undertakings absent a demonstrable rights violation.

article-32locus-standimanagerial-decisionsjudicial-reviewpublic-sector
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1981

Francis Coralie Mullin v Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi

AIR 1981 Supreme Court 746

The right to life under Article 21 is not confined to mere animal existence; it includes the right to live with human dignity and all that goes along with it, and extends even to detenus under preventive detention laws.

article-21right-to-lifehuman-dignitydetenu-rightsexpansive-interpretation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1967

I.C. Golak Nath and Others v State of Punjab

AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1643

Parliament has no power to abridge or take away any of the fundamental rights in Part III through the amending power under Article 368; a constitutional amendment is 'law' within Article 13(2). (Overruled by Kesavananda Bharati, 1973.)

article-368article-13fundamental-rightsconstitutional-amendmentoverruled
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1951

In Re Delhi Laws Act

AIR 1951 Supreme Court 332

The legislature cannot delegate its essential legislative function; it must lay down legislative policy and guidelines while delegating only ancillary or subordinate functions

delegated-legislationexcessive-delegationlegislative-policyseparation-of-powers
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Presidential Reference under Article 143)1960

In Re: The Berubari Union and Exchange of Enclaves

AIR 1960 Supreme Court 845

The Preamble is not a part of the Constitution and is not enforceable in a court of law, though it can be used as an aid to interpretation when the language of a provision is ambiguous; cession of Indian territory to a foreign state requires a constitutional amendment under Article 368, not merely ordinary legislation.

preamblearticle-143cession-of-territoryarticle-368presidential-reference
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Five-Judge Constitution Bench)2018

Indian Young Lawyers Association and Ors. v State of Kerala and Ors. (Sabarimala Temple case)

(2019) 11 Supreme Court Cases 1

The exclusion of women in the 10 to 50 age group from entering the Sabarimala temple violates Articles 14, 15, 17, 19, 21, and 25(1); the practice is not an essential religious practice protected under Article 25, and a public place of worship cannot exclude women based on physiological characteristics.

article-25essential-religious-practicegender-equalitysabarimalafreedom-of-religion
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Nine-Judge Bench)1992

Indra Sawhney and Ors. v Union of India and Ors. (Mandal Commission case)

AIR 1993 Supreme Court 477

Reservations for socially and educationally backward classes under Article 16(4) cannot exceed 50 percent; the 'creamy layer' among backward classes must be excluded; caste can be a valid criterion but not the sole criterion for identifying backward classes.

article-16-4mandal-commissioncreamy-layer50-percent-ceilingreservation-in-promotion
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Nine-Judge Bench)2007

IR Coelho v State of Tamil Nadu

(2007) 2 Supreme Court Cases 1

Laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 are subject to judicial review if they violate the basic structure of the Constitution.

Ninth-Schedulebasic-structurejudicial-reviewfundamental-rightsland-reforms
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1980

Jolly George Verghese v. Bank of Cochin

AIR 1980 Supreme Court 470

Civil imprisonment for non-payment of a decree debt must be reconciled with Article 21 and Article 11 of the ICCPR. Mere inability to pay is not dishonest avoidance; arrest is permissible only where the judgment-debtor has the means to pay but wilfully refuses or has acted in bad faith.

CPCexecutioncivil-imprisonmentarrestarticle-21ICCPRsection-51order-XXI
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2003

Justice K. Ranganath Mishra v Union of India

(2003) 7 Supreme Court Cases 133

Fundamental Duties under Art.51A remain non-justiciable and cannot be directly enforced against citizens through judicial compulsion, but the state can promote awareness and compliance through education and policy.

fundamental-dutiesarticle-51anon-justiciablepromotion-of-duties
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1970

K.A. Abbas v. Union of India

AIR 1971 Supreme Court 481

Pre-censorship of films is constitutionally valid as a reasonable restriction under Art.19(2). The classification system must be guided by standards that are not vague and must provide procedural safeguards against arbitrary exercise.

article-19reasonable-restrictionscensorshipconstitutional-lawsem-5
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1953

Kalawati and Anr. v State of Himachal Pradesh

AIR 1953 Supreme Court 131

Art.20(2) double jeopardy protection applies only where the person has been both 'prosecuted AND punished' for the same offence; a mere prior acquittal does not trigger the bar, and an appeal against an acquittal is a continuation of the same prosecution, not a fresh one.

article-20-2double-jeopardyprosecuted-and-punishedacquittal
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (13-judge bench)1973

Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala

AIR 1973 Supreme Court 1461

Parliament's amending power under Article 368 cannot alter the basic structure of the Constitution.

basic-structure-doctrineconstitutional-amendmentsarticle-368ninth-schedulefundamental-rights
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1951

Keshavan Madhava Menon v State of Bombay

AIR 1951 Supreme Court 128

Article 13(1) operates only prospectively; it renders pre-Constitution laws inconsistent with fundamental rights void only from the date the Constitution commenced (26 January 1950), and does not affect proceedings, rights, or liabilities that had already accrued before that date.

article-13prospective-operationpre-constitution-lawvested-rights
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2017

KS Puttaswamy v. Union of India

(2017) 10 Supreme Court Cases 1

Right to privacy is a fundamental right under Art.21; any interference must satisfy triple test of legality, legitimate aim, and proportionality

IT-lawprivacyArt-21fundamental-rightdata-protectionPuttaswamylandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Seven-judge bench)1997

L. Chandra Kumar v Union of India

AIR 1997 Supreme Court 1125; (1997) 3 Supreme Court Cases 261

Power of judicial review under Art. 226/227 is a basic feature of the Constitution; tribunal orders are subject to High Court review; tribunals cannot exclude HC jurisdiction.

ADRtribunalsjudicial-reviewbasic-structureArt-226landmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1995

L.I.C. of India & Anr. v Consumer Education and Research Centre & Ors.

(1995) 5 Supreme Court Cases 482

An LIC insurance policy's eligibility conditions are state action with a public element, and must themselves satisfy Article 14; a clause limiting a term-insurance plan's benefit to persons in government, quasi-government, or 'reputed commercial firm' employment is discriminatory and severable from the rest of the policy's otherwise-valid conditions.

constitutional-lawarticle-14state-actionlicinsuranceseverabilitypublic-duty
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2006

M. Nagaraj and Ors. v Union of India and Ors.

(2006) 8 Supreme Court Cases 212

Constitutional amendments enabling reservation in promotions for SC/ST (77th, 81st, 82nd, 85th Amendments) are valid, but the state must satisfy three conditions: (a) backwardness of the class, (b) inadequate representation, and (c) no adverse effect on overall administrative efficiency.

article-16-4areservation-in-promotionquantifiable-dataadministrative-efficiency
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1988

M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (Ganga Pollution Case)

AIR 1988 Supreme Court 1037

Courts can retain continuing jurisdiction (continuing mandamus) over environmental matters requiring sustained monitoring and successive orders, rather than a single conclusive judgment.

environmental-lawcontinuing-mandamusriver-pollutionarticle-21ganga
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2014

Madras Bar Association v Union of India

(2014) 10 Supreme Court Cases 1

Tribunals must have judicial members with qualifications comparable to HC judges for deciding questions of law; technical members cannot decide pure legal questions alone

ADRtribunalsNCLTjudicial-independencecomposition
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1978

Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India

AIR 1978 Supreme Court 597

Art.21 requires that procedure established by law be fair, just, and reasonable; not arbitrary, fanciful, or oppressive. Art.14, 19, and 21 are interconnected (the 'golden triangle').

constitutional-lawarticle-21fair-procedurepersonal-libertygolden-triangle
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1953

Maqbool Hussain v State of Bombay

AIR 1953 Supreme Court 325

Proceedings before a Sea Customs authority, resulting in confiscation of goods, do not amount to a 'prosecution' before a 'court or judicial tribunal' for Art.20(2); therefore, a subsequent criminal prosecution for the same conduct does not violate double jeopardy protection.

article-20-2double-jeopardycourt-or-judicial-tribunalsea-customs-actconfiscation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2004

Mardia Chemicals Ltd v. Union of India

(2004) 4 Supreme Court Cases 311

SARFAESI Act is constitutionally valid; but 75% pre-deposit requirement for DRT appeal struck down as making remedy illusory

SARFAESIconstitutional-validitypre-depositS17DRTfundamental-rights
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1987

MC Mehta v. Union of India (Oleum Gas Leak)

AIR 1987 Supreme Court 1086

An enterprise engaged in inherently dangerous activity is absolutely liable for harm caused, with no exceptions (no act of God, no third-party defence, no consent). Compensation must be proportionate to the magnitude and financial capacity of the enterprise.

absolute-liabilityoleum-gasshriram-industrieshazardous-activityart-21compensation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1980

Minerva Mills Ltd. and Ors. v Union of India and Ors.

AIR 1980 Supreme Court 1789

Clauses 4 and 5 of Article 368, inserted by the 42nd Amendment (which sought to place constitutional amendments beyond judicial review and grant Parliament unlimited amending power), were struck down as violative of the basic structure doctrine; limited amending power itself is a basic feature of the Constitution.

basic-structurearticle-368judicial-review42nd-amendmentharmony-fr-dpsp
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1978

Nandini Satpathy v. P.L. Dani

AIR 1978 Supreme Court 1025

Art.20(3) protection against self-incrimination operates during police interrogation. A person is not bound to answer questions tending to expose them to criminal charge.

self-incriminationarticle-20-3police-interrogationinvestigationright-to-silence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1985

Olga Tellis v. Bombay Municipal Corporation

AIR 1986 Supreme Court 180

Right to livelihood is part of Art.21; pavement dwellers cannot be evicted without notice and hearing; Rule of Law extends to the most vulnerable.

art-21right-to-livelihoodpavement-dwellersnatural-justicePILrule-of-law
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Seven-Judge Bench)2002

Pradeep Kumar Biswas and Ors. v Indian Institute of Chemical Biology and Ors.

(2002) 5 Supreme Court Cases 111

The determinative factor in deciding whether a body is 'State' under Article 12 is whether it is financially, functionally, and administratively dominated by, or under the deep and pervasive control of, the government; the Ajay Hasia factors are indicative pointers, not a rigid checklist.

article-12deep-and-pervasive-controlinstrumentality-of-statecsirseven-judge-bench
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1970

R.C. Cooper v. Union of India

AIR 1970 Supreme Court 564

Deprivation of property requires fair compensation and the law must not be arbitrary; property rights cannot be illusory

propertycompensationbank-nationalisationfundamental-rights
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1967

Rajasthan State Electricity Board v Mohan Lal and Ors.

AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1857

The expression 'State' under Article 12 extends to include statutory corporations invested with powers to make binding rules with the force of law, functioning as an instrumentality of government.

article-12definition-of-statestatutory-corporationinstrumentality-of-state
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1955

Ram Jawaya Kapur v. State of Punjab

AIR 1955 Supreme Court 549

The executive of a State may carry out a trade or business such as printing and publishing textbooks without specific legislation, provided it is within the scope of its executive powers and does not infringe fundamental rights.

administrative-lawseparation-of-powersexecutive-powerwelfare-state
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1950

Romesh Thappar v. State of Madras

AIR 1950 Supreme Court 124

Art.32 is itself a fundamental right; the SC cannot refuse a writ petition where a fundamental right is infringed. Freedom of press is part of Art.19(1)(a).

administrative-lawwritsart-32press-freedomguaranteed-remedy
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1994

S.R. Bommai v Union of India

(1994) 3 Supreme Court Cases 1

Presidential proclamation under Article 356 is subject to judicial review; secularism is a basic feature of the Constitution; floor test is the proper method to determine majority.

constitutional-lawarticle-356secularismbasic-structurepresidents-rulejudicial-review
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

Selvi and Ors. v State of Karnataka

(2010) 7 Supreme Court Cases 263

Involuntary administration of polygraph, narco-analysis, and brain electrical activation profile tests violates Art.20(3) (protection against self-incrimination) and Art.21 (personal liberty and mental privacy); such tests can only be conducted with free, informed, and voluntary consent.

article-20-3self-incriminationnarco-analysispolygraphmental-privacyarticle-21
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2015

Shreya Singhal v. Union of India

(2015) 5 Supreme Court Cases 1

S.66A IT Act unconstitutional (vague, overbroad, violates Art.19(1)(a)); S.79 intermediary liability triggered only by court order or government notification, not private complaint.

IT-lawS66AArt-19freedom-of-speechintermediary-liabilitylandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1992

St. Stephen's College v University of Delhi

(1992) 1 Supreme Court Cases 558

A minority educational institution under Art.30(1) has the right to prefer students of its own community in admissions, up to a reasonable percentage (fixed at 50 percent), provided admission is based on merit and the institution's autonomy is exercised without arbitrariness.

article-30minority-institutionsadmission-autonomyreservation-cap
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1976

State of Kerala v. NM Thomas

(1976) 2 Supreme Court Cases 310

Reasonable classification bearing nexus to legislative object does not violate Article 14; differential treatment of banking companies is constitutionally valid

Art-14reasonable-classificationbanking-regulationdifferential-treatment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1951

State of Madras v Champakam Dorairajan

AIR 1951 Supreme Court 226

Directive Principles cannot override or take precedence over Fundamental Rights where the two conflict; a caste-based reservation policy not backed by a specific constitutional provision violates Art.29(2). This led directly to the First Constitutional Amendment.

directive-principlesfundamental-rightsarticle-29caste-reservationfirst-amendment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1954

State of West Bengal v Subodh Gopal Bose

AIR 1954 Supreme Court 92

Right to property is a right in rem: available against the whole world; every person has a duty not to interfere with the owner's property

right-in-rempropertyArt-31fundamental-rightsduty
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1991

Subhash Kumar v. State of Bihar

AIR 1991 Supreme Court 420

The right to life under Article 21 includes the right to enjoyment of pollution-free water and air.

environmental-lawarticle-21right-to-clean-environment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1978

Sunil Batra v. Delhi Administration

AIR 1978 SC 1675

Section 30(2) of the Prisons Act does not authorise solitary confinement of a prisoner under sentence of death; it only requires that such a prisoner be kept in a cell apart from other prisoners. Section 56, which permits bar fetters, is not unconstitutional, provided it is used with the safeguards of Arts. 14 and 21.

prisons-actsection-30solitary-confinementsection-56bar-fettersart-21art-14death-sentence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2003

T.K. Rangarajan v. State of Tamil Nadu

(2003) 6 Supreme Court Cases 581

There is no fundamental right to strike under the Indian Constitution; government employees especially have no moral or equitable justification for strikes

landmarkno-fundamental-right-to-strikegovernment-employeesmass-dismissalArt-19
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Eleven-Judge Bench)2002

T.M.A. Pai Foundation and Ors. v State of Karnataka and Ors.

(2002) 8 Supreme Court Cases 481

Private unaided educational institutions, including minority institutions, have a right under Arts.19(1)(g) and 30 to establish and administer institutions, including autonomy over admissions and fee structures, subject to reasonable regulation to ensure merit-based admission and prevent commercialisation.

article-19-1-garticle-30minority-institutionsright-to-educationautonomy
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1993

Unni Krishnan, J.P. and Ors. v State of Andhra Pradesh and Ors.

(1993) 1 Supreme Court Cases 645

The right to education up to the age of fourteen is a fundamental right flowing from Art.21, read with Art.45 (Directive Principle); beyond that age, the right is subject to the state's economic capacity. This directly led to the insertion of Art.21A by the 86th Amendment.

right-to-educationarticle-21article-45article-21aharmonious-construction
Read case brief