Supreme Court of India1989
AIR 1989 Supreme Court 1239
Where a contract contains a clause specifying that disputes shall be subject to the jurisdiction of a particular court, and more than one court would otherwise have jurisdiction under Section 20 CPC based on the facts, such an exclusive jurisdiction clause is valid and binding on the parties, provided the chosen court is one that would, in any event, have jurisdiction under the general law; parties cannot, however, confer jurisdiction on a court that would otherwise have none.
jurisdiction-clauseexclusive-jurisdictionouster-clausesection-20-cpc
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2007
Civil Appeal Nos. 5097-5099 of 2004
A judgment, decree or order obtained by playing fraud on the court is a nullity and non est, and can be challenged in any court at any time
limitation-actsection-17fraudconcealmentdiscoveryfresh-limitation
Read case brief →House of Lords (UK)1975
[1975] Appeal Cases 396
At interlocutory stage, the court should not resolve contested questions of fact or law; it need only satisfy itself there is a serious question to be tried, then consider balance of convenience. Widely adopted in Indian courts alongside the Dalpat Kumar test.
CPCtemporary-injunctioninterlocutoryserious-questionbalance-of-convenienceUK-authority
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1979
AIR 1979 SC 1047; (1979) 4 SCC 389
Review may be exercised on new and important matter, an error apparent on the face of the record or an analogous ground, but not on the ground that the decision was erroneous on merits
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1964
AIR 1964 SC 993; 1964 SCR (5) 946
Where the Code deals with a matter and exhausts the court's powers on it, inherent power under S.151 cannot be invoked to cut across those provisions.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2019
(2020) 2 SCC 394
A counter-claim may be filed after the written statement with the court's leave, but not after the framing of issues.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2009
(2009) 2 Supreme Court Cases 656
Costs in civil litigation are governed by Sections 35 and 35A CPC (compensatory costs then capped at Rs 3,000); a court cannot use inherent power to levy costs contrary to the Code. Heavy costs payable to Legal Services bodies or non-party charities should be avoided.
CPCcostssection-35costs-follow-eventreasons-mandatoryno-costs-order
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2013
(2013) 4 SCC 333; AIR 2013 SC 1712
S.10 CPC applies only when the entire subject matter of the two suits is the same; it does not apply merely because some issues are common
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2013
(2013) 4 Supreme Court Cases 465
The right to a fair hearing includes the right to cross-examine witnesses whose statements are relied upon against a party; where a party is denied a genuine opportunity to test evidence through cross-examination, and that evidence is nonetheless relied upon to the party's detriment, the resulting decision is vitiated for breach of natural justice and the principles of a fair hearing.
fair-hearingcross-examinationnatural-justiceright-to-be-heard
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1970
AIR 1970 SC 406; (1970) 1 SCR 435; (1969) 2 SCC 201
Not every interlocutory order is a 'case decided' under S.115 CPC; revision lies only where the order adjudicates a right or obligation of the parties.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1999
AIR 1999 SC 3381; (1999) 8 SCC 396
A court need not pronounce judgment against a defendant who has not filed a written statement merely because of the default; where facts need proof it should require proof, and every judgment must give reasons
CPCwritten-statementorder-VIII-rule-1time-limitdirectorymandatory30-day90-day
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1966
AIR 1966 Supreme Court 735
Relief should ordinarily be founded on the pleadings, but where a plea not expressly taken is covered by an issue by implication, the parties knew it was being tried and led evidence on it, the court may decide on it; the test is substance, not form.
CPCamendment-of-pleadingsorder-VI-rule-17new-cause-of-actionlimitationjustice-oriented
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
(2005) 1 Supreme Court Cases 787; AIR 2005 Supreme Court 626
A defendant against whom an ex parte decree is passed has two concurrent remedies: an application under Order IX Rule 13 to set aside the decree, and an appeal under Section 96(2). Both can be pursued simultaneously but the same grounds cannot be urged in both.
CPCex-parte-decreeorder-IX-rule-13section-96setting-asidesufficient-causeappeal
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1984
(1984) 2 SCC 627
Notice under S.80 CPC is a mandatory precondition to a suit against the Government.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2001
(2001) 3 Supreme Court Cases 1
Objections to the admissibility of documents or evidence raised during trial should ordinarily not stall the trial's progress; the trial court should provisionally allow the document to be marked, noting the objection, and decide on the admissibility question at the final judgment stage, along with the rest of the case, in order to avoid piecemeal appeals and unnecessary delay in the trial process.
admissibility-of-documentsmark-subject-to-objectionprocedural-efficiencypiecemeal-appeals
Read case brief →Allahabad High Court1936
AIR 1937 All 176; 167 Ind Cas 683
Under S.66 CPC (repealed in 1988), no suit lay against a certified auction purchaser on the ground that the purchase was made on behalf of the plaintiff or his predecessor, even for a share; a claim based on title independent of the auction purchase was not barred
CPCsection-66benamiauction-purchasecertified-purchaser
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1987
(1987) 2 Supreme Court Cases 107; AIR 1987 Supreme Court 1353
Courts should adopt a liberal approach toward condonation of delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act. Substantial justice should be preferred over technicality. Refusing condonation for a short delay without substantial reason defeats the purpose of the right of appeal.
limitation-actsection-5condonation-of-delaysufficient-causeliberal-approachsubstantial-justice
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
Civil Appeal No. 2461 of 2008
S.14 of the Limitation Act applies to an application under S.34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 and is construed liberally
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2020
(2020) 7 SCC 366
Under O.VII R.11 the court reads only the plaint and its documents, and must reject a plaint that is barred on its face or discloses no real cause of action.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1992
AIR 1993 Supreme Court 276; (1992) 1 Supreme Court Cases 719
Three conditions must be satisfied for grant of temporary injunction under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2: (1) prima facie case, (2) balance of convenience in favour of the applicant, and (3) irreparable injury if injunction is not granted. All three must coexist.
CPCtemporary-injunctionorder-XXXIXprima-facie-casebalance-of-convenienceirreparable-injurythree-conditions
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
(1994) 6 SCC 585; AIR 1995 SC 75
S.8 of the Limitation Act caps the extension under S.6 or S.7 at three years from cessation of the disability, but does not take away an ordinary period that is still running
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 Supreme Court 1457
The principle of res judicata applies to writ proceedings. A writ petition dismissed on merits by the High Court under Article 226 bars a subsequent petition before the Supreme Court under Article 32 on the same grounds.
CPCres-judicatasection-11writ-petitionarticle-32article-226constitutional-remedyfinality
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
(1994) 4 SCC 99; AIR 1994 SC 1901; [1994] 1 SCR 530
A determination that does not conclusively adjudicate the rights of the parties is not a decree under S.2(2) CPC and is not appealable under S.96
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1968
AIR 1969 Supreme Court 78
Laid down the seven principles governing when a civil court's jurisdiction is excluded by a special statute providing its own machinery for adjudication of disputes arising under it; exclusion of civil court jurisdiction is not to be readily inferred, and where a statute is found to be ultra vires, or a remedy provided under it is not adequate, or fundamental procedural requirements have not been complied with, civil court jurisdiction is not excluded despite an apparently exclusionary provision.
exclusion-of-civil-court-jurisdictionbar-of-suitseven-principlesspecial-statute
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1962
AIR 1962 SC 1886; 1963 SCR (2) 499
O.XXXII R.7 applies only to an agreement or compromise affecting the rights in issue in a pending suit, made with a party to the suit; it does not cover mere procedural steps
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2013
(2013) 12 SCC 649
S.5 is applied liberally, but a casual approach or long unexplained delay cannot be condoned.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2020
AIR 2020 SC 3670; Civil Appeal No. 2904 of 2020
A returned plaint presented in the proper court starts a fresh suit, tried from the beginning.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2004
(2004) 3 Supreme Court Cases 688
In a suit for infringement of trademark or copyright, the plaintiff can institute the suit at a place where it carries on business, under Section 62 of the Copyright Act (and analogous provisions), even if the defendant's infringing acts occurred elsewhere, since these special statutory provisions provide an additional forum beyond the ordinary place-of-suing rules under Section 20 CPC.
place-of-suingspecial-forumcopyright-actsection-62additional-forum
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1985
(1986) 1 SCC 100
Under Explanation VI to S.11, bona fide litigation about a public right binds all persons interested in it.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2000
(2000) 3 SCC 54; AIR 2000 SC 1221
"Sufficient cause" in O.IX R.13 is an elastic expression to be construed liberally to do complete justice.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1974
(1974) 2 Supreme Court Cases 393; 1974 AIR 1126; 1974 SCR (3) 882
An appeal lies only against a decree or an appealable order, never against a bare finding -- contrasted with a civil suit, which needs no authority of law and is maintainable as of inherent right unless a statute bars it. A party cannot amend a memorandum of appeal to raise a new challenge after an unexplained, multi-year delay with no application to condone it.
CPCappeal-vs-suitright-to-sueappealable-orderamendment-of-appealres-judicata
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1984
AIR 1984 SC 1004; (1984) 3 SCC 46; 1984 SCR (3) 229
A notice under S.80 CPC given by a person who dies before suit enures for his legal representatives; S.80 is procedural and must be construed to advance justice
CPCdecreesection-2-2formal-expressionadjudicationconclusive-determination
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1995
(1995) 5 Supreme Court Cases 545
Grant of an interlocutory injunction is discretionary and depends on (i) a prima facie case, (ii) balance of convenience and (iii) irreparable injury. The court weighs the plaintiff's need for protection against the defendant's corresponding need, and may protect the defendant by requiring an undertaking from the plaintiff. A negative covenant operative during the term of a contract may be enforced by injunction (S.42 Specific Relief Act).
CPCtemporary-injunctionorder-XXXIXbalance-of-conveniencerelative-hardshipstatus-quo
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
(2007) 1 SCC 546
In second appeal, concurrent findings of fact cannot be disturbed without a substantial question of law.
Read case brief →Andhra Pradesh High Court2003
2004 (4) ALD 282; 2004 (5) ALT 348
Under O.XXXV R.5 CPC a tenant cannot file an interpleader suit to compel his landlord to litigate with persons who do not claim through the landlord
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1997
(1997) 6 SCC 660
The evidence of a partisan eyewitness may be acted on if the witness's presence is established and the account is corroborated. An acquittal may be reversed where that corroboration makes the prosecution case credible. Non-examination of a witness does not, by itself, warrant an adverse inference.
eyewitnesspartisan-witnesscorroborationacquittal-reversedTADAmurder
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
(2005) 7 SCC 791
A suit for immovable property lies where the property is situated; an agreement cannot confer jurisdiction on another court.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
(2008) 8 SCC 671; 2008 AIR SCW 6500
In a dispute about demarcation and encroachment, it is appropriate to appoint a Local Commissioner under O.XXVI R.9
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
2006 INSC 305
A second appeal lies only on a substantial question of law, which must be properly identified and decided.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1974
AIR 1974 SC 480; (1974) 3 SCR 31
Where a special law is a complete code, the general provisions of the Limitation Act are excluded by necessary implication.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2016
(2017) 1 SCC 568
Leave to defend a summary suit depends on the strength of the defence and may be unconditional, conditional or refused.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1974
(1974) 2 SCC 151; AIR 1974 SC 749
Res judicata applies between co-defendants where there was a conflict of interest, its decision was necessary for the plaintiff's relief, and it was finally decided.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1998
AIR 1998 SC 1952; 1998 (3) SCALE 441
In a summary suit under O.XXXVII CPC, the 'trial' barred by S.10 begins only after leave to defend is granted
section-10-cpcsub-judicedirectly-and-substantially-in-issuestay-of-suit
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2015
(2015) 10 SCC 161
Special forum provisions do not permit suing at a distant branch where no part of the cause of action arose.
Read case brief →Andhra Pradesh High Court1965
AIR 1965 AP 179
A stakeholder may interplead for the portion of the subject matter he admits holding.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1980
AIR 1980 Supreme Court 470
Civil imprisonment for non-payment of a decree debt must be reconciled with Article 21 and Article 11 of the ICCPR. Mere inability to pay is not dishonest avoidance; arrest is permissible only where the judgment-debtor has the means to pay but wilfully refuses or has acted in bad faith.
CPCexecutioncivil-imprisonmentarrestarticle-21ICCPRsection-51order-XXI
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1955
AIR 1955 SC 376; (1955) 1 SCR 1369
A written transfer of a debt that is the subject of a pending suit is not an assignment in writing of the later decree under O.XXI r.16 CPC; but the transferee claims under the decree-holder and may apply for execution under S.146 CPC.
CPCexecutionorder-XXI-rule-16section-146actionable-claimsection-130assignment
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2011
(2011) 11 SCC 275
S.151 CPC recognises, and does not confer, inherent power; it may be used to reopen evidence in a fit case.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
AIR 2005 SC 2441; (2005) 4 SCC 480
The 90-day limit in the proviso to O.VIII R.1 CPC is directory; time may be extended in exceptional cases for recorded reasons
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
Civil Appeal No. 3471 of 2006 (Supreme Court of India, decided 11 August 2006)
S.100A bars a Letters Patent appeal from a Single Judge deciding an appeal.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 Supreme Court 1077; 1961 SCR (3) 792
Where members of a joint Hindu family voluntarily refer a partition to Panchas (out-of-court arbitrators) and accept and act upon the divisions actually made, those divisions bind the parties even if the reference is later revoked as to the remaining, undivided properties; and documents merely recording a partition already acted upon do not require registration.
CPChindu-lawpartitionarbitration-out-of-courtpanchasregistrationsection-17-registration-actsection-32-arbitration-act
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 SC 790; 1961 SCR (3) 769
A compromise on behalf of a minor without leave under O.XXXII R.7 is voidable only at the instance of the minor; it is not a nullity
Read case brief →High Court1977
AIR 1977 (NOC) 42
Where an advocate fails to appear without informing the client, and the client had no knowledge of the non-appearance, the advocate's default may constitute 'sufficient cause' for the client's absence, entitling the client to setting aside of ex parte decree.
CPCex-parte-decreeorder-IX-rule-13sufficient-causeadvocate-defaultnon-appearance
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1951
AIR 1952 SC 47; 1952 SCR 179
A claim is not to be dismissed for clumsy pleading where its substance is clear and no prejudice is caused; the parties plead facts and the court applies the law. Contribution between co-mortgagors is governed by S.82 and S.92 TPA (rateable by value).
CPCpleadingssubstance-over-formorder-VITPA-s82contributionsubrogation
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 SC 1236
An acknowledgment must relate to a subsisting liability, indicate the jural relationship between the parties and be intended, expressly or impliedly, to admit it
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1954
AIR 1954 SC 340
Lack of inherent jurisdiction makes a decree void; defects of territorial or pecuniary jurisdiction do not, unless there is prejudice.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1981
AIR 1980 SC 1754; (1980) 4 SCC 255; 1981 SCR (1) 594
A High Court in second appeal may re-appreciate evidence where the courts below ignored the weight of the circumstances on record.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1987
(1987) 3 SCC 265; AIR 1987 SC 1395
O.VIII R.6A(1) limits the accrual of the cause of action, not the date of filing the counter-claim.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1995
(1995) 6 Supreme Court Cases 88
An affidavit filed in support of an application or as evidence in proceedings must comply with the requirements of Order XIX CPC and be based on facts within the deponent's personal knowledge, or clearly identify the source of information and belief where the statement is not based on personal knowledge; an affidavit that fails to distinguish between knowledge and belief, or is otherwise vague, is of diminished evidentiary value and can be disregarded by the court.
affidavitorder-19-cpcpersonal-knowledgebeliefevidentiary-value
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1962
AIR 1962 SC 527; 1962 SCR Supl. (1) 450
S.151 CPC supplements the Code where it is silent but cannot be exercised in conflict with its provisions.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2011
AIR 2011 SC 3221; (2011) 13 SCC 174
'Sufficient means' in O.XXXIII R.1 means the ability in the ordinary course to raise money by lawful means, including pension and help from family
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1970
AIR 1971 SC 2355; (1970) 3 SCR 830
A decision on a pure question of law relating to jurisdiction, or contrary to statute, is not res judicata.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1988
AIR 1989 SC 162; (1988) 4 SCC 619; 1988 SCR Supl. (3) 333
A defendant whose defence has been struck out may still cross-examine the plaintiff's witnesses to show the falsity or weakness of the plaintiff's case, but may not present his own case
CPCwritten-statementevasive-denialspecific-denialorder-VIII-rule-5admissiondeemed-admitted
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
(1994) 4 SCC 225; JT 1994 (3) 654
Ex parte injunctions are exceptional and must be granted only on the stated considerations.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2010
(2010) 7 SCC 417; AIR 2010 SC 3109
The plaintiff as dominus litis cannot be compelled to sue a person against whom he seeks no relief, subject to O.I R.10(2), which permits adding only necessary or proper parties
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1998
(1998) 7 Supreme Court Cases 123
Length of delay is a factor but not determinative in condonation applications under S.5 Limitation Act. Even a long delay may be condoned if the cause is genuine and bona fide throughout the entire period.
limitation-actsection-5condonationlength-of-delaysufficient-causegenuine-cause
Read case brief →Madras High Court1956
AIR 1957 Mad 745
A bank, as debtor of its depositor, may file an interpleader suit about rival claims to a deposit.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2004
(2005) 2 SCC 256; AIR 2005 SC 242
S.10 CPC applies only to suits in civil courts of concurrent jurisdiction where the whole subject matter is identical; the test is whether the earlier decision would operate as res judicata in the later suit
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
(2006) 6 Supreme Court Cases 207
Territorial jurisdiction of a court to try an offence, or of a civil court to entertain a suit, must be determined based on where the cause of action, in whole or in part, actually arose; a court cannot assume jurisdiction merely because a party resides within its territorial limits, absent a genuine connection between the cause of action and that territory.
territorial-jurisdictioncause-of-actionforum-selection
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 SC 218; 1961 SCR (1) 884
Inherent powers under S.151 CPC are procedural and cannot be used to affect the substantive rights of parties.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2009
AIR 2009 SC 1593; (2009) 11 SCC 127
Where property in a family dispute must be protected, management should be given to a receiver or administrator who is an officer of the court, not to one of the contesting parties
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1991
(1991) 4 SCC 270
Against a corporation, the suit lies at the subordinate office where the cause of action arose, not at the principal office.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
2005 INSC 387
A plaint is rejected as time-barred only when the bar is clear on its own averments.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 3 SCC 563
Unexplained bureaucratic delay is not sufficient cause; the law of limitation binds the government like everyone else.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1970
AIR 1970 Supreme Court 1525
Under S.15 of the Limitation Act, the time during which execution of a decree is stayed by injunction or order is excluded in computing limitation for an execution application. An execution application must first be within the period under Art.182 of the Limitation Act 1908; S.48 CPC (then 12 years) operated as a further outer bar.
CPCexecutiondecree-enforcementexpeditiousorder-XXIjudgment-debtor
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
2006 INSC 280
A former minor who wants a deed set aside must sue within the period running from majority; limitation is not displaced.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1975
AIR 1975 Supreme Court 2238
Where a right or obligation is created exclusively by the Industrial Disputes Act, and that Act provides a specific remedy through its own adjudicatory machinery, a civil suit to enforce that right is barred, and the aggrieved party must proceed through the industrial dispute resolution machinery; but where the right sought to be enforced exists independently of the Act, a civil suit remains maintainable.
bar-of-suitindustrial-disputes-actcivil-court-jurisdictionexclusive-remedy
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1994
(1994) 5 SCC 547
An injunction under s.41(j) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, is a personal right and will not be granted to a person who has no personal interest in the property. A trespasser, or a person claiming only under an agreement of sale, cannot resist the true owner or obtain a declaration that a concluded land-acquisition award is void.
injunctionspecific-reliefsection-41jpersonal-interestland-acquisitiontrespasser
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2022
(2022) 9 SCR 280; Civil Appeal No. 1609 of 2022
Supervisory jurisdiction under Art.227 does not permit re-appreciation of evidence as in an appeal.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1990
AIR 1991 SC 221; (1991) 1 SCC 48
Notice to the defendants before leave under S.92 CPC is advisable but not mandatory.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2007
AIR 2007 SC 2698; (2007) 5 SCC 698
Where an indigent plaintiff fails, O.XXXIII R.11 requires the court to order the plaintiff or co-plaintiff to pay the court fee; the defendant cannot be directed to pay
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
(2009) 1 SCC 376; AIR 2009 SC 930
Pension and gratuity remain exempt from attachment under S.60(1)(g) even after being converted into fixed deposits.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1981
AIR 1981 SC 1400; (1981) 2 SCC 788; 1981 SCR (3) 509
A party should not suffer for the default of his advocate when he himself has done all he could.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2021
(2021) 6 SCC 418
Execution must be completed speedily; third-party objections are to be decided within execution itself, ordinarily within 6 months.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
AIR 1961 SC 1206
A scheme framed in a S.92 CPC suit may provide for its own modification on application; such a modification for the trust's administration needs no fresh S.92 suit, but must not affect the private rights of persons who were not parties.
CPCsection-92public-trustschememodification
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1973
1973 ALLMR Online 375 (SC)
Limitation runs strictly under the Act; the doctrine of lis pendens does not suspend it.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
(2008) 14 Supreme Court Cases 364
Post-trial amendment of pleadings was refused where the party's failure to include the ground earlier was due to lack of due diligence, not impossibility. The 2002 proviso to Order VI Rule 17 (no amendment after commencement of trial except due diligence) was applied strictly.
CPCamendmentorder-VI-rule-17post-trialdue-diligence2002-proviso
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2014
Civil Appeal No. 6862 of 2014
An order dismissing a counter-claim is a decree, and the remedy is an appeal.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2003
2003 Supp (4) SCR 543; AIRONLINE 2003 SC 537
A decree or order obtained by fraud on the court or by suppression of material facts is vitiated.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1957
AIR 1957 Supreme Court 444
The power of a court to summon and compel the attendance of a witness must be exercised judiciously; a witness cannot be repeatedly harassed by successive summons issued without due regard to genuine difficulty or hardship, and courts must balance the need to secure evidence against the legitimate interests and convenience of witnesses.
summoning-of-witnessesjudicious-exercisewitness-convenience
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1992
(1992) 2 SCC 524
A 'necessary party' is one without whom no effective order or decree can be made in a suit, whereas a 'proper party' is one whose presence, though not indispensable, enables the court to more effectually and completely adjudicate on the matter; a suit cannot fail merely for non-joinder of a proper party, and courts should exercise their discretion under Order I Rule 10 to add parties rather than dismiss proceedings on technical grounds of misjoinder or non-joinder.
necessary-partyproper-partyorder-1-rule-10non-joindermisjoinder
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2019
AIR 2019 SC 3827
A person who has perfected title by adverse possession can sue as plaintiff under Article 65 of the Limitation Act; adverse possession is a sword as well as a shield
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1958
AIR 1958 SC 886; 1959 SCR 1111
Courts have discretionary power under Order I Rule 10 CPC to add a party to a suit where that party's presence is necessary to effectually and completely adjudicate upon the questions involved, particularly in matters affecting status (such as a declaration of marriage), even though the applicant may not be a party in the strict sense to the original cause of action.
order-1-rule-10necessary-partyproper-partyaddition-of-partiesdeclaration-of-status
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2020
AIROnline 2020 SC 731; Civil Appeal Nos. 3007-3008 of 2020
'Prescribed period' in S.4 of the Limitation Act means the period of limitation, not the further period within which delay may be condoned
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1971
AIR 1971 Supreme Court 1865
Mere production and marking of a document as an exhibit during trial does not by itself amount to proof of the truth of its contents; unless the document is proved in accordance with the law of evidence, such as through examination of the person who authored it or otherwise establishing its authenticity and truth, it cannot be relied upon as substantive evidence of the facts it contains.
proof-of-documentsmarking-of-exhibitsdistinction-between-production-and-proof
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2003
(2003) 1 SCC 557
An O.VII R.11 application is decided on the averments in the plaint alone; the written statement is irrelevant.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
AIR 2005 Supreme Court 3353; (2005) 6 Supreme Court Cases 344
S.89 CPC is constitutionally valid; directed framing of mediation rules for civil courts; courts must actively explore ADR in suitable cases
ADRsection-89CPCconstitutional-validitymediation-ruleslandmark
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1955
AIR 1955 Supreme Court 425
Procedural law is the handmaid of justice, not its mistress. Technical breaches of procedure should not defeat substantive rights unless they cause real prejudice.
CPCprocedural-lawhandmaid-of-justiceex-partenatural-justiceprocedure-not-rigid
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2011
(2012) 1 Supreme Court Cases 455
Costs under S.35 CPC are subject to the conditions and limitations prescribed by the rules; a court cannot award so-called actual costs beyond the scale in the rules, even if the parties agree in principle to litigation expenses. Actual realistic costs must be provided for by amending the rules. Where costs do not follow the event, S.35(2) requires reasons.
CPCcompensatory-costssection-35Afalse-claimknowledge-of-falsity
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1974
AIR 1974 SC 1764; (1975) 3 SCC 351; 1975 (1) SCR 57
Natural justice requires that minors have an opportunity to contest proceedings through their guardians; substantial compliance with fair play is enough
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2001
(2001) 3 SCC 179; 2001 INSC 80
The first appeal is a full rehearing requiring reasons; a second appeal lies only on a properly framed substantial question of law.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1960
AIR 1960 SC 941
Res judicata operates between stages of the same proceeding, but an unappealed interlocutory order can be challenged in appeal from the final decision.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1996
decided 1996-01-30 (reporter citation not confirmed)
A rule that treats married daughters differently from sons without reason violates equality.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2019
AIR 2019 SC 2691; (2019) 12 SCC 210
In commercial suits, the 120-day limit for filing a written statement is mandatory and cannot be extended under S.151 CPC
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2003
(2003) 6 SCC 659; AIR 2003 SC 2434
The 1999 amendment to S.115 applies to pending revision applications, as there is no vested right in a procedural remedy of revision.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1988
decided 1988-04-26 (reporter citation not confirmed)
An ex parte decree must rest on legal evidence; affidavits are evidence only when the court so orders.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2004
(2004) 3 SCC 137
The plaint is read as a whole and on its own averments; there is no partial rejection under O.VII R.11.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1975
Review Petition No. 62A of 1974
Review lies only for an error apparent, not to re-argue a decided case.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1951
AIR 1951 Supreme Court 177
A court may grant relief on an alternative case not specifically pleaded or prayed for, where that alternative case was itself admitted and put forward by the defendant's own written statement — so no surprise or prejudice results. The rule against granting relief outside the pleadings is a fair-notice rule, not a rigid jurisdictional bar.
CPCpleadingsrelief-beyond-pleadingsdefendant-admissionorder-VII
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
(2006) 12 SCC 119
Notice under S.80(1) CPC is a condition precedent to a suit against the Government; S.80(2) is the only exception, and leave to sue without notice must precede the suit and rest on urgency of relief, not merits. Whether the objection is waived depends on the facts.
CPCsection-80noticesuits-against-governmentleavewaiver
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1996
(1996) 3 SCC 132
The State is bound by limitation, but some latitude is allowed for delay caused by its impersonal machinery.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1964
AIR 1964 Supreme Court 1006
The Limitation Act does not as such apply to writ petitions under Art.226, but the period of limitation for a civil suit for the same relief is ordinarily a reasonable standard for judging delay; delay beyond that period will almost always be unreasonable. High Courts can order refund of tax collected without authority of law.
limitation-actarticle-65government-suitspossession12-year-periodno-special-treatment
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2005
(2005) 3 SCC 752
There is no separate law of limitation for the State, but some latitude may be shown for delay in its decision-making.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1977
AIR 1978 SC 1608; (1978) 1 SCC 68; (1978) 1 SCR 746
A S.80 notice is meant to alert the State to negotiate a just settlement or explain why it resists the claim
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1977
AIR 1977 SC 1680; (1977) 2 SCC 806; 1977 SCR (3) 428
A plea that might and ought to have been raised in an earlier writ petition is barred in a later suit by constructive res judicata.
CPCconstructive-res-judicatasection-11explanation-IVwrit-petitionarticle-311might-and-ought
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1964
AIR 1964 Supreme Court 358
Where a statute prescribes a particular manner or mode for doing an act (such as recording a confession or statement before a specified authority), that act must be done in that manner alone, and no other; a magistrate empowered to record a statement in a particular way cannot delegate that function or record it through an unauthorised alternative procedure.
mode-prescribed-by-statutedelegationexclusive-proceduremagistrate-powers
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
(2008) 2 SCC 326; AIR 2008 SC 1006
A defendant who had notice of the proceedings, and suppresses that fact, cannot have an ex parte order set aside for defective service.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1974
(1974) 2 SCC 695
A suit under S.92 CPC must be a representative suit to vindicate public rights, not a personal right.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1977
(1977) 4 Supreme Court Cases 467
A plaint that is manifestly vexatious and does not disclose a real cause of action must be rejected at the threshold. Courts should not allow process to be abused as a weapon of harassment through frivolous litigation.
CPCrejection-of-plaintorder-VII-rule-11vexatious-plaintabuse-of-processcause-of-action
Read case brief →Madras High Court1954
AIR 1955 Mad 430
A receiver is appointed only on five principles: judicial discretion, strong prima facie case, real danger, no disturbance of de facto possession save for fraud or force or property in medio, and clean conduct
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1967
AIR 1967 SC 935
An acknowledgment must admit a subsisting liability; describing a past transaction is not enough.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2001
AIR 2001 SC 2277; (2001) 5 SCC 22
'Person' in Order XXXIII CPC includes a juristic person such as a public limited company
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2012
(2012) 8 SCC 148
Additional evidence in appeal is an exception, allowed only on the grounds in O.XLI R.27 with recorded reasons.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
AIROnline 2006 SC 524; Civil Appeal No. 4811 of 2000
A ward must sue to set aside a transfer made by his guardian within three years of attaining majority (Article 60(a), Limitation Act)
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2000
(2000) 7 Supreme Court Cases 120
An admission made by a party, whether in pleadings or otherwise, if clear and unambiguous, can form the basis for a court to pass a decree, including summary judgment, without requiring a full trial on that admitted aspect; the object of allowing decrees based on admissions is to avoid unnecessary and protracted trials on matters no longer genuinely in dispute.
admissionsorder-12-rule-6judgment-on-admissionssummary-decree
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1964
AIR 1964 SC 1099
General provisions of the Limitation Act on computing time apply to special laws unless excluded.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2008
(2008) 4 SCC 115
S.92 CPC is for vindicating public rights in a public trust, and leave is a condition precedent.
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2010
(2010) 8 Supreme Court Cases 1
A civil court has no power, under the CPC, any substantive law or S.151, to direct a plaintiff to file an undertaking to pay a specified sum as damages to the defendant if the suit fails. The Court also observed that costs should follow the event, non-levy of costs should be supported by reasons, and the costs provisions (Ss.35, 35A, 35B) need realistic revision.
CPCcostssection-35actual-costsrealistic-costsnominal-costs-deprecated
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1990
1990 Supp SCC 727
An appellate court will not interfere with a trial court's discretion on an interlocutory injunction unless it was exercised arbitrarily, capriciously or perversely, or settled principles were ignored
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2006
decided 2006-03-08 (reporter citation not confirmed)
Courts can punish a witness who deliberately subverts the trial by false and shifting testimony.
Read case brief →