Labour Law case briefs

29 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Labour Law notes.

29 briefs in Labour Law
Supreme Court of India1970

Agra Electric Supply Co. Ltd. v Sri Alladin and Ors.

AIR 1970 Supreme Court 512

Standing orders certified under the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act become part of the statutory conditions of service and are binding once certified; an employer's proposed changes to standing orders require the certifying officer's approval following the prescribed procedure, and cannot be enforced unilaterally by the employer as a fait accompli.

standing-orderscertification-procedurecertifying-officermodification
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1985

Balmer Lawrie Workers' Union v Balmer Lawrie and Co. Ltd.

AIR 1985 Supreme Court 311

Trade union recognition and the determination of which union represents workers in collective bargaining must be based on objective criteria, such as membership strength verified through a fair process, not on the employer's unilateral preference.

trade-union-recognitioncollective-bargainingmembership-verification
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1964

Bombay Union of Journalists v State of Bombay

AIR 1964 Supreme Court 1617

The appropriate government's power to make a reference of an industrial dispute for adjudication involves a subjective satisfaction as to the existence of an industrial dispute, but this satisfaction must be based on relevant material and not be exercised arbitrarily; the government can decline reference where no genuine industrial dispute is shown to exist.

reference-powerappropriate-governmentsubjective-satisfactionindustrial-dispute
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

Central Provinces Transport Services Ltd. v Raghunath Gopal Patwardhan

AIR 1957 Supreme Court 104

A dispute concerning the termination or dismissal of a single individual employee, not sponsored or supported by a union or a substantial number of workmen, generally does not qualify as an 'industrial dispute' under Section 2(k) of the Industrial Disputes Act, unless it acquires a collective character through union or workmen support.

industrial-disputeindividual-disputesection-2kcollective-character
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1972

Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. v Ludh Budh Singh

AIR 1972 Supreme Court 1031

A domestic disciplinary inquiry, held by the employer before an order of dismissal, must be conducted fairly; where the domestic inquiry is found to be defective or invalid (for want of natural justice), the tribunal adjudicating the resulting industrial dispute can permit the employer to adduce fresh evidence to justify the dismissal before the tribunal itself, giving the employer a further opportunity to establish misconduct despite the flawed inquiry.

domestic-inquirydefective-inquiryfresh-evidence-before-tribunalnatural-justice
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

Hariprasad Shivshankar Shukla v A.D. Divelkar

AIR 1957 Supreme Court 121

The closure of an undertaking by an employer is distinct from 'retrenchment' under Section 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act; termination of services consequent upon a bona fide closure of business does not amount to retrenchment, and workmen so terminated are not entitled to retrenchment compensation under Section 25F merely by virtue of that provision, though this position was later altered by statutory amendment.

retrenchmentsection-2-ooclosure-of-businessstatutory-amendment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

Hind Construction and Engineering Co. Ltd. v Their Workmen

AIR 1965 Supreme Court 917

Workers who absent themselves from duty under the mistaken but bona fide belief that a declared holiday entitled them to be absent, and who did not intend to strike or act in defiance of the employer, cannot be treated as having gone on an illegal strike; dismissal for such absence, disproportionate to the actual conduct involved, is not sustainable, and reinstatement is the appropriate remedy.

bona-fide-absenceillegal-strikeproportionality-of-punishmentreinstatement
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2002

Jaipur Zila Sahakari Bhoomi Vikas Bank Ltd. v Ram Gopal Sharma

AIR 2002 Supreme Court 643

Under Section 33(2)(b) of the Industrial Disputes Act, where an employer dismisses a workman for misconduct during the pendency of proceedings and applies to the tribunal for approval, the tribunal's approval must be sought and obtained; if the tribunal does not approve the action, the dismissal remains inoperative, and mere passage of time or delay in seeking approval does not validate an otherwise unapproved dismissal.

section-33-2-bapproval-of-dismissalpendency-of-proceedingsmisconduct
Read case brief
Calcutta High Court1968

Jay Engineering Works Ltd. v State of West Bengal

AIR 1968 Calcutta 407

A 'gherao' (physical surrounding and confinement of management personnel by workers) is not a legitimate form of protest or trade union activity protected by law; it amounts to wrongful confinement and unlawful restraint, and is not covered by the immunities granted to trade unions for peaceful and lawful industrial action.

gheraowrongful-confinementtrade-union-immunityunlawful-protest
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1960

Management of Kairbetta Estate v Rajamanickam

AIR 1960 Supreme Court 893

A 'lockout' under Section 2(l) of the Industrial Disputes Act is the employer's counterpart to a strike by workmen, namely the closing of a place of employment, suspension of work, or refusal to continue employing workers, undertaken to compel the workers to accept the employer's terms; a lockout that is not a genuine response to an industrial dispute, or is punitive/retaliatory rather than a bona fide part of collective bargaining pressure, may be treated as illegal.

lockoutsection-2-lemployer-counterpart-to-strikebona-fide
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1970

Management of Safdarjung Hospital v Kuldip Singh Sethi

AIR 1970 Supreme Court 1407

An establishment carrying on activities of a philanthropic, charitable, or purely medical/educational nature, without a profit-making or commercial motive, does not constitute an 'industry' under Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act, since the systematic activity must be analogous to trade or business to qualify.

definition-of-industrysection-2jcharitable-institutionhospital
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1995

Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation v Krishna Kant

(1995) 5 Supreme Court Cases 75

Where a dispute involves rights and obligations created purely under the general law of contract or common law, and does not involve rights specifically created under the Industrial Disputes Act, a civil court may retain jurisdiction; but where the dispute concerns rights and obligations that are created by, or find their source in, the Industrial Disputes Act or the underlying industrial relations framework (such as disputes over termination, standing orders, or related matters), the civil court's jurisdiction is ordinarily excluded, and the matter must go through the industrial adjudication machinery.

civil-court-jurisdictionexclusionindustrial-adjudicationstanding-orders
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1968

Robert D'Souza v Executive Engineer, Southern Railway (cited in labour law casebooks alongside Tata Iron and Steel disciplinary matters)

AIR 1968 Supreme Court 843

Where an employee is dismissed without a proper inquiry, and reinstatement is directed, the question of back wages for the intervening period is a matter of discretion for the tribunal, to be exercised having regard to the circumstances, including whether the workman was gainfully employed elsewhere during the period, and is not an automatic entitlement flowing mechanically from a finding of illegal termination.

reinstatementback-wagesdiscretion-of-tribunalillegal-termination
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1976

Rohtas Industries Ltd. v Rohtas Industries Staff Union

AIR 1976 Supreme Court 425

An award made by an arbitrator under Section 10A of the Industrial Disputes Act stands on the same footing as an award made by a tribunal referred by the government, and questions of jurisdictional error in such private arbitration awards can be examined by courts on grounds similar to judicial review of tribunal awards, including whether the arbitrator exceeded the reference.

voluntary-arbitrationsection-10aarbitration-awardjudicial-review
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1970

State of Uttar Pradesh v Om Prakash Gupta

AIR 1970 Supreme Court 679

In a disciplinary inquiry against an employee, the principles of natural justice require that the employee be given a fair opportunity to know the charges against him, to lead evidence in his defence, and to cross-examine witnesses relied upon by the employer; a disciplinary finding reached in violation of these safeguards is vitiated and cannot sustain a punishment of dismissal or removal.

disciplinary-proceedingsnatural-justicefair-opportunitycross-examination
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1980

Surendra Kumar Verma & Ors. v. Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court

(1980) 4 Supreme Court Cases 443; 1981 AIR 422; 1981 SCR (1) 789

Where a retrenchment is struck down as invalid under S.25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, the ordinary relief is reinstatement with full back wages -- \"it is as if that [termination] order had never been passed\" -- subject to a limited discretion where reinstatement is impossible or wholly inequitable. Separately, under the amended S.25B(2)(a)(ii) ID Act, a workman who has actually worked 240 days within the preceding 12 months is deemed to be in continuous service for one year, even if not actually employed for a full year.

retrenchmentsection-25Freinstatementback-wagescontinuous-servicesection-25Bindustrial-disputes-act
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1972

Tata Iron and Steel Co. Ltd. v Workmen

AIR 1972 Supreme Court 1917

Notice under Section 9A of the Industrial Disputes Act is mandatory for any change in rest days; failure to give such notice makes the change ineffective.

industrial-disputessection-9arest-dayslock-outnotice-of-change
Read case brief
Bombay High Court (Federal Court on appeal)1949

Western India Automobile Association v Industrial Tribunal, Bombay

AIR 1949 Bombay 141

An industrial tribunal, in adjudicating an industrial dispute, has the power to create new rights and obligations between employer and workmen going beyond the strict terms of the existing contract, since industrial adjudication is not confined to enforcing existing legal rights but extends to settling disputes in a manner that promotes industrial peace.

industrial-adjudicationtribunal-powerscreation-of-new-rightsindustrial-peace
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1963

Western India Match Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen

1964 AIR 472; 1964 SCR (3) 560; Civil Appeal Nos. 300-301 of 1963

Whether two establishments (here, a factory and its sales office) form a single unit of industrial production, for purposes of extending a benefit like a production bonus scheme, turns on functional integrality, interdependence, and community of financial control and management -- tests that cannot be applied mechanically. Separately, whether staff (inspectors, salesmen) are \"workmen\" turns on the actual nature of their work, not their designation.

labour-lawunit-of-industryworkman-definitionproduction-bonusfunctional-integrality
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1984

Workmen of Hindustan Lever Ltd. v Hindustan Lever Ltd.

AIR 1984 Supreme Court 516

A settlement or award reached in the course of conciliation or adjudication must be interpreted in light of its object and the surrounding circumstances at the time it was made; awards and settlements affecting terms of employment are to be construed in favour of preserving industrial harmony and giving effect to the substance of what the parties intended, rather than a rigid literal reading that defeats that purpose.

interpretation-of-awardsettlementindustrial-harmonyconciliation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1973

Workmen of M/s. Firestone Tyre and Rubber Co. of India (P) Ltd. v. Management (and connected appeals)

1973 AIR 1227; 1973 SCR (3) 587; (1973) 1 SCC 813; Civil Appeal No. 1461 of 1972 (lead)

Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (inserted by the 1971 Amendment, effective 15 December 1971) -- which empowers a Labour Court or Tribunal to set aside an unjustified discharge/dismissal and order reinstatement or a lesser punishment, re-appraising the evidence itself -- applies only to industrial disputes referred for adjudication on or after 15 December 1971; it has no retrospective application to references made before that date, even if still pending.

section-11Aindustrial-disputes-actretrospective-operationtribunal-powerreappraisal-of-evidence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

Workmen of Motipur Sugar Factory v. Motipur Sugar Factory

AIR 1965 SC 1803

Where there has been no domestic enquiry, or the enquiry is irregular or invalid, the Industrial Tribunal may itself examine whether the discharge was justified on the merits. The employer then does not have the benefit that a proper domestic enquiry would have given, and must prove the misconduct before the Tribunal.

industrial-tribunaldomestic-enquirydischargego-slowmeritsburden-of-proof
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1964

Workmen of Subong Tea Estate v Outgoing Management of Subong Tea Estate

AIR 1964 Supreme Court 903

Retrenchment under Section 2(oo) of the Industrial Disputes Act does not include termination of service by way of transfer of the undertaking, or termination resulting from non-renewal of a contract of employment on its expiry, or termination due to continued ill-health of the workman, since these are expressly excluded from the definition of retrenchment.

retrenchmentsection-2-ooexclusionstransfer-of-undertaking
Read case brief