Law of Torts case briefs

62 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Law of Torts notes.

62 briefs in Law of Torts
House of Lords (UK)1992

Alcock v. Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police

[1992] 1 Appeal Cases 310

Recovery for secondary victims requires genuine direct perception of the event or its immediate aftermath; witnessing through mediated broadcast generally does not satisfy this requirement.

nervous-shocksecondary-victimproximityhillsborough
Read case brief
Court of King's Bench (England)1722

Armory v. Delamirie

(1722) 1 Str 505

A finder or lawful temporary possessor holds a superior possessory right against all but the true owner, and wrongful refusal to return or account for goods held is actionable.

conversionfinder-rightspossessiondetinue
Read case brief
Queen's Bench (1703), reversed by House of Lords (1704)1703

Ashby v. White

(1703) 2 Ld Raym 938 (Queen's Bench); reversed on appeal (1704) House of Lords

Ubi jus ibi remedium: where there is a right, there must be a remedy for its violation, even without proof of actual pecuniary damage.

ubi-jus-ibi-remediumright-and-remedyequitynatural-justiceinjuria-sine-damno
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division (England)1978

Bernstein v. Skyviews and General Ltd.

[1978] Queen's Bench 479

Landowner airspace rights extend only to the height reasonably necessary for the ordinary use and enjoyment of the land, not to an unlimited vertical extent.

trespass-to-landairspaceaviation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1985

Bhim Singh v. State of J&K

AIR 1986 Supreme Court 494

Deliberate, improperly motivated unlawful detention warrants exemplary damages beyond ordinary compensatory damages, given the serious character of this abuse of power.

false-imprisonmentexemplary-damagesmala-fide-detentionarticle-21
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1828

Bird v. Holbrook

(1828) 4 Bing 628

A plaintiff's own wrongful conduct (trespass) does not automatically excuse a defendant's independently excessive, disproportionate response, such as a concealed spring gun without warning.

plaintiff-the-wrongdoertrespassexcessive-responsespring-gun
Read case brief
Queen's Bench (England)1845

Bird v. Jones

(1845) 7 Queen's Bench 742

False imprisonment requires total restraint within a bounded area; a partial obstruction leaving a genuine alternative means of movement does not satisfy this requirement.

false-imprisonmenttotal-restraintpersonal-liberty
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1856

Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Co.

(1856) 11 Exchequer 781

Negligence is the omission to do something a reasonable person would do, or doing something a prudent, reasonable person would not do.

negligencereasonable-personstandard-of-care
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division (England)1957

Bolam v. Friern Hospital Management Committee

[1957] 1 Weekly Law Reports 582

A professional is not negligent if their conduct accords with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible, competent body of professional opinion, even if other equally competent professionals might have adopted a different approach.

negligenceprofessional-standardmedical-negligencebolam-test
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1951

Bolton v. Stone

[1951] Appeal Cases 850

A reasonable person calibrates precautions according to the genuine probability and magnitude of a risk, weighed against the burden of further precautions; negligence does not require guarding against every conceivable, however remote, risk.

negligencerisk-utility-balancingstandard-of-care
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1895

Bradford Corporation v. Pickles

[1895] Appeal Cases 587

Where an act is otherwise lawful, the actor's malicious motive for performing it does not convert the act into an actionable tort.

malicemotivelawful-actgeneral-principles
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1972

British Railways Board v Herrington

[1972] Appeal Cases 877

An occupier owes a duty of 'common humanity' even to trespassers; the old rule of no duty to trespassers (Addie v Dumbreck) was departed from.

tort-lawoccupiers-liabilitytrespassersduty-of-carecommon-humanity
Read case brief
Court of King's Bench (England)1809

Butterfield v. Forrester

(1809) 11 East 60

Contributory negligence by the plaintiff operated as a complete bar to recovery, regardless of the relative degree of fault.

contributory-negligenceall-or-nothing-rulehistorical
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1990

Caparo Industries plc v. Dickman

[1990] 2 Appeal Cases 605

A three-stage test governs duty of care in novel situations: foreseeability of harm, sufficient proximity between the parties, and whether imposing a duty is fair, just, and reasonable.

negligenceduty-of-carecaparo-testproximity
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1704

Cole v. Turner

(1704) 6 Mod Rep 149

The least touching of another, without lawful justification or consent, constitutes battery, regardless of the degree of force or presence of actual injury.

batterybodily-integrityunwanted-contact
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1999

Colgate Palmolive (India) Ltd. v. Hindustan Lever Ltd.

(1999) 7 Supreme Court Cases 1

Genuine, substantiated comparative claims constitute permissible competitive marketing; false, misleading, or improperly disparaging claims cross into actionable unfair trade practice.

unfair-trade-practicecomparative-advertisingconsumer-protection
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1949

Davies v. Swan Motor Co.

[1949] 2 King's Bench 291

Courts weigh both the relative causal potency and the relative blameworthiness of each party's conduct in determining the appropriate proportionate reduction for contributory negligence.

contributory-negligencecomparative-faultapportionment
Read case brief
House of Lords1889

Derry v Peek

(1889) 14 Appeal Cases 337

Fraud requires knowledge of falsehood or recklessness; honest belief in truth, even if unreasonable, negates fraud.

fraudmisrepresentationhonest-beliefmens-reaprospectus
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1932

Donoghue v. Stevenson

[1932] Appeal Cases 562

A duty of care is owed to persons who are so closely and directly affected by one's act that one ought reasonably to have them in contemplation (the 'neighbour principle').

negligenceduty-of-careneighbour-principlesnail-in-bottletort-law
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1765

Entick v. Carrington

(1765) 19 St Tr 1029

Even state officials require positive legal authority to justify entering private property; unauthorised entry, regardless of claimed governmental purpose, constitutes trespass absent genuine lawful justification.

trespass-to-landexecutive-powerconstitutional-limits
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1841

Fouldes v. Willoughby

(1841) 8 M&W 540

Conversion requires a genuine denial of, or serious exclusion from, the owner's rights; mere interference with one specific mode of dealing, leaving underlying ownership and recovery intact, does not suffice.

conversiontrespass-to-goodsmovable-property
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1410

Gloucester Grammar School Case

(1410) YB 11 Hen IV, f. 47, pl. 21

Damage resulting from lawful competition, absent violation of any legal right, is damnum sine injuria and not actionable.

damnum-sine-injuriacompetitionelements-of-tort
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1933

Hall v. Brooklands Auto Racing Club

[1933] 1 King's Bench 205

Spectators at inherently risky sporting events are taken to consent to the ordinary, inherent risks of the sport, provided it is conducted in the ordinary and proper manner.

volenti-non-fit-injuriaconsentsporting-eventsdefences
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1869

Hammersmith Railway Co. v. Brand

(1869) LR 4 House of Lords 171

Statutory authorisation for a general activity does not provide blanket immunity for every aspect of how that activity is conducted, particularly regarding matters within the defendant's genuine discretion.

statutory-authoritydefencesrailwayconditional-authority
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1975

Horrocks v. Lowe

[1975] Appeal Cases 135

Malice defeating qualified privilege requires knowledge of falsity, reckless indifference to truth, or a predominant improper motive unconnected to the duty or interest the privilege protects.

defamationqualified-privilegemalice
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1866

Indermaur v Dames

(1866) LR 1 CP 274

An occupier owes a duty to an invitee to use reasonable care to prevent damage from unusual dangers which the occupier knows or ought to know about.

tort-lawoccupiers-liabilityinviteeduty-of-careunusual-danger
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1996

Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action v. Union of India

(1996) 3 Supreme Court Cases 212

Polluting enterprises engaged in inherently hazardous activity must fund the complete, actual cost of remediation, without limitation to a lesser capped compensation measure, and without escape through traditional strict liability exceptions.

polluter-paysabsolute-liabilityremediation-costhazardous-waste
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1995

Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha

(1995) 6 Supreme Court Cases 651

Medical services generally constitute 'service' under the Consumer Protection Act where rendered for consideration, though entirely free medical services generally fall outside its scope given the absence of consideration.

medical-negligenceconsumer-protection-actservice-definition
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2005

Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab

(2005) 6 Supreme Court Cases 1

A mere error of judgment, without more, does not constitute negligence; the standard is reasonable care and skill expected of a reasonably competent practitioner, not guaranteed success.

medical-negligencebolam-standardcriminal-negligence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

Kasturi Lal Ralia Ram Jain v. State of Uttar Pradesh

AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1039

State NOT liable for torts committed in exercise of sovereign functions (police custody of seized property); sovereign immunity survives for core governmental acts.

administrative-lawstate-liabilitysovereign-immunitypolicesovereign-functioncriticized
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)2001

Lister v. Hesley Hall Ltd.

[2001] UKHL 22

The relevant test for vicarious liability asks whether the employee's wrongful conduct was so closely connected to their employment that it would be fair and just to hold the employer vicariously liable (the 'close connection' test).

vicarious-liabilityclose-connection-testcourse-of-employment
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1969

London Artists Ltd. v. Littler

[1969] 2 Queen's Bench 375

The subject matter of fair comment must genuinely involve a matter the public has a legitimate interest in commenting upon.

defamationfair-commentpublic-interest
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1994

Lucknow Development Authority v M.K. Gupta

(1994) 1 Supreme Court Cases 243

Statutory authorities providing housing are providers of 'services' under consumer protection law; deficiency in service by a development authority is actionable before consumer forums.

tort-lawconsumer-protectiondeficiency-of-servicehousingdevelopment-authority
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1987

MC Mehta v. Union of India (Oleum Gas Leak)

AIR 1987 Supreme Court 1086

An enterprise engaged in inherently dangerous activity is absolutely liable for harm caused, with no exceptions (no act of God, no third-party defence, no consent). Compensation must be proportionate to the magnitude and financial capacity of the enterprise.

absolute-liabilityoleum-gasshriram-industrieshazardous-activityart-21compensation
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1983

McLoughlin v. O'Brian

[1983] 1 Appeal Cases 410

Secondary victims must establish close ties of love and affection with the primary victim, close physical and temporal proximity to the event or its immediate aftermath, and direct perception through their own senses.

nervous-shocksecondary-victimproximitynegligence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1994

N. Nagendra Rao & Co. v. State of Andhra Pradesh

AIR 1994 Supreme Court 2663

Sovereign immunity confined to 'primary and inalienable' functions only (defense, foreign affairs); State liable for negligent storage of seized goods. Substantially narrows Kasturi Lal.

administrative-lawstate-liabilitysovereign-immunitynarrowingwelfare-state
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1876

Nichols v. Marsland

(1876) 2 Exchequer D 1

An act of God requires a genuinely extraordinary natural event, of a character no reasonable foresight could have anticipated or guarded against.

act-of-godvis-majorstrict-liabilitydefences
Read case brief
Court of Crown Cases (England)1840

R v. St George

(1840) 9 C&P 483

Creating a reasonable apprehension of imminent harm through pointing a loaded firearm at another constitutes assault, even without the threatened force actually being carried out.

assaultapprehensionimminence
Read case brief
Allahabad High Court1978

Radhey Shyam v. Gur Prasad Serma

AIR 1978 Allahabad 86

Established common law nuisance principles, including the reasonableness assessment, apply to determine liability for noise interference in the Indian context.

private-nuisancenoisereasonablenessindian-application
Read case brief
Madras High Court1984

Ramanuja Mudali v. M. Gangan

AIR 1984 Madras 103

The defensive response must remain proportionate to the actual threat faced; excessive force exceeding what was genuinely necessary is not justified as private defence.

private-defenceproportionalitydefences
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1921

Re Polemis and Furness, Withy and Co. Ltd.

[1921] 3 King's Bench 560

A defendant is liable for all damage that is a direct consequence of their negligent act, regardless of whether that specific damage was foreseeable.

negligenceremoteness-of-damagedirect-consequence-test
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1947

Read v. J. Lyons and Co. Ltd.

[1947] Appeal Cases 156

The Rylands v Fletcher rule requires an actual escape of the dangerous thing to a place outside the defendant's occupation or control; injury occurring within the defendant's premises does not satisfy this essential requirement.

strict-liabilityrylands-v-fletcherescape-requirement
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1964

Rookes v. Barnard

[1964] Appeal Cases 1129

Exemplary damages should be confined to specific categories: conduct calculated to profit the defendant beyond mere compensation, statutorily authorised awards, or oppressive, arbitrary, or unconstitutional conduct by government servants.

exemplary-damagespunitive-damagesremedies
Read case brief
House of Lords1868

Rylands v Fletcher

(1868) LR 3 House of Lords 330

A person who brings on his land something likely to do mischief if it escapes is strictly liable for all damage caused by its escape, regardless of fault.

strict-liabilitynon-natural-useescapeabsolute-liabilityfoundational
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1966

Sitaram Motilal Kalal v Santanuprasad

AIR 1966 Supreme Court 1697

Master is vicariously liable even when servant commits an expressly prohibited act, if the prohibited act is merely an unauthorised MODE of doing authorised work

vicarious-liabilityprohibited-actunauthorised-modecourse-of-employment
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1891

Smith v. Baker

[1891] Appeal Cases 325

Mere continued work with knowledge of a risk, absent genuine free choice to accept it given economic necessity, does not establish volenti non fit injuria. Scienti (knowledge) is not volenti (consent).

volenti-non-fit-injuriascienti-non-fit-injuriaemploymentdefences
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division (England)1891

Stanley v. Powell

[1891] 1 Queen's Bench 86

Where harm results despite the defendant's exercise of full reasonable care, through a genuinely unforeseeable and unavoidable occurrence, this constitutes an inevitable accident excusing liability.

inevitable-accidentdefencesreasonable-carenegligence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1978

State Bank of India v Shyama Devi

AIR 1978 Supreme Court 1263

Employer is vicariously liable for wrongs committed by employee in the course of employment, even if the specific act was unauthorised.

vicarious-liabilityemployer-employeecourse-of-employmentrespondeat-superior
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1962

State of Rajasthan v. Vidyawati

AIR 1962 Supreme Court 933

State is vicariously liable for torts of its servants committed in non-sovereign functions; no justification for government immunity in a welfare state.

administrative-lawstate-liabilityvicarious-liabilitytortious-liabilitywelfare-state
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1879

Sturges v. Bridgman

(1879) 11 Chancery D 852

The reasonableness of an activity is assessed relative to its current effect on the specific neighbouring use; prior uncomplained-of duration does not create a permanent right to continue causing substantial interference.

private-nuisancecoming-to-the-nuisancereasonableness
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1924

The Koursk

[1924] P 140

Joint tortfeasors are those acting pursuant to a common design or shared duty; several tortfeasors act entirely independently, though both categories may face similar practical consequences regarding recovery.

joint-tortfeasorsseveral-tortfeasorscontribution
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1989

Union Carbide Corporation v Union of India

(1989) 1 Supreme Court Cases 674

Mass disaster litigation can be settled by the Supreme Court acting parens patriae; absolute liability of hazardous industries affirmed in the Bhopal gas tragedy context.

tort-lawabsolute-liabilitybhopal-gas-tragedymass-tortparens-patriaehazardous-industry
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1860

Vaughan v. Taff Vale Railway Co.

(1860) 5 H&N 679

Where harm results from the inevitable, inherent consequence of properly conducting a statutorily authorised activity, without additional negligence, the statutory authority provides a complete defence.

statutory-authoritydefencesrailwayabsolute-authority
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division (England)1897

Wilkinson v. Downton

[1897] 2 Queen's Bench 57

Deliberate conduct calculated to cause, and which does cause, psychiatric or physical harm through nervous shock is actionable, independent of physical contact.

nervous-shockintentional-inflictionpsychiatric-injury
Read case brief