Property Law case briefs

60 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Property Law notes.

60 briefs in Property Law
Court of Chancery (England)1803

Aldrich v Cooper

(1803) 8 Ves 382

Marshalling: where senior creditor has two funds and junior creditor has one, senior must be directed to the fund junior cannot reach

property-lawmarshallingequitytwo-fundssection-81
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1956

Ananda Behera v. State of Orissa

AIR 1956 Supreme Court 17

Right to catch and carry away fish from a lake is a profit-a-prendre and constitutes an interest in immovable property

property-lawTPAimmovable-propertyfisheryprofit-a-prendre
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2000

Anthony v KC Ittoop and Sons

(2000) 6 SCC 394; 2000 INSC 348

An unregistered lease deed for more than a year cannot create a lease (S.107 TPA, S.17 and S.49 Registration Act), but a lease can still arise by conduct: possession given by the owner and monthly rent paid create a tenancy presumed to be month to month.

property-lawleasesection-107unregistered-leasetenancy-by-conductrent-control
Read case brief
Privy Council1915

Bal Gangadhar Tilak v. Shrinivas Pandit

AIR 1915 Privy Council 7

Condition precedent requires only substantial compliance, not literal compliance; the essence of the condition must be fulfilled

property-lawTPAsection-25condition-precedentsubstantial-compliancelandmark
Read case brief
Privy Council1899

Balkishen Das v. Legge

(1899) ILR 22 Allahabad 149 (PC)

Courts look behind the form to the substance; a conditional sale intended as security for a debt is a mortgage, not a sale

property-lawTPAsection-58conditional-salesubstance-over-formlandmark
Read case brief
Court of Appeal in Chancery (England)1857

Bellamy v Sabine

(1857) 1 De G & J 566

Lis pendens operates on principle of public policy and necessity, not on notice

property-lawlis-pendenspublic-policysection-52notice
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1959

Bhaskar Waman Joshi v Narayan Rambilas Agarwal

AIR 1960 SC 301

Whether a deed of sale with a condition of repurchase is a mortgage by conditional sale depends on the parties' intention, gathered from the deed read with surrounding circumstances; a debtor-creditor relation and transfer as security for the debt mark a mortgage.

property-lawmortgageconditional-salesection-58csale-with-repurchase
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1958

Bishan Singh v. Khazan Singh

AIR 1958 SC 838

A right of pre-emption is effectively exercised only when the pre-emptor has been substituted for the vendee, which under a conditional decree occurs only after the decree conditions are fulfilled. Lis pendens does not defeat such a pre-existing right.

pre-emptionlis-pendenssubstitutionpunjab-pre-emption-act
Read case brief
House of Lords1904

Colls v Home and Colonial Stores Ltd

[1904] AC 179; [1904] UKHL 1

An easement of light protects only against substantial deprivation amounting to a nuisance: enough to make a building uncomfortable to live in or to prevent beneficial use for business, judged by the ordinary notions of mankind; a mere reduction of light is not actionable.

property-laweasementseasement-of-lightnuisanceenglish-case
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1968

Delhi Motor Company v UA Basrurkar

AIR 1968 SC 794; (1968) 2 SCR 720

S.53A TPA is only a defence (a shield) for a transferee in possession; it gives no right to claim possession or other rights on an unregistered lease or contract.

property-lawpart-performancesection-53Ashield-not-swordunregistered-lease
Read case brief
Calcutta High Court1913

Devi Prasad v. Gopal Chandra

AIR 1913 Calcutta 259

A person who accepts a benefit under an instrument is deemed to have elected in favor of all provisions of that instrument, including those disposing of their own property

property-lawTPAsection-35electionacceptance
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from Oudh)1907

Faiyaz Husain Khan v Munshi Prag Narain

(1907) 34 IA 102; [1907] UKPC 12

Under S.52 TPA, a suit is pending from its institution, not from service of summons; lis pendens rests not on notice but on the need for litigation to reach an effective end, so neither party can alienate the property in dispute to affect the other.

property-lawlis-pendenssection-52pendencyprivy-council
Read case brief
Allahabad High Court1877

Fateh Singh v. Sanwal Singh

(1877) Indian Law Reports 1 Allahabad 75

A condition restraining a widow's remarriage attached to a property transfer is void as an absolute restraint on marriage

property-lawTPAsection-29marriage-restraintwidow
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1961

Ganga Dutt Murarka v Kartik Chandra Das

AIR 1961 SC 1067; (1961) 3 SCR 813

Acceptance of rent from a statutory tenant after the contractual tenancy ends does not create a new tenancy by holding over under S.116 TPA; his occupation rests on the rent statute, not on contract, and needs no S.106 notice to end.

property-lawleaseholding-oversection-116statutory-tenantrent-control
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1955

Girja Datt Singh v Gangotri Datt Singh

AIR 1955 SC 346

A will must be proved to have been duly executed and attested; where due execution and attestation of the alleged will of 17 March 1928 were not proved, it could found no title.

property-lawwillsproof-of-willattestationtestamentary-succession
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2000

Govindrao v. Namdeo

AIR 2000 Supreme Court 1560

A landlocked parcel created by severance acquires an implied easement of necessity over the retained portion for access

property-laweasementssection-13necessitylandlockedlandmark
Read case brief
Madhya Pradesh High Court1964

Harinarayan v. Badridass

AIR 1964 Madhya Pradesh 250

Once an easement of light is established, the servient owner cannot construct anything that substantially diminishes the light

property-laweasementslightnegative-easementobstruction
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1972

Jayaram Mudaliar v Ayyaswami

(1972) 2 SCC 200; AIR 1973 SC 569; (1973) 1 SCR 139

S.52 TPA rests on public policy, not notice: a voluntary transfer of joint property during a partition suit is subject to the decree even if the buyer had no notice; lis pendens does not displace pre-existing charges, so a revenue sale enforcing a prior statutory charge is protected for the land charged.

property-lawlis-pendenssection-52public-policypartition-suitrevenue-sale
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1955

Jugalkishore Saraf v Raw Cotton Co Ltd

AIR 1955 SC 376; (1955) 1 SCR 1369

A written transfer of a debt that is the subject of a pending suit is not an assignment in writing of the later decree under O.XXI r.16 CPC; but the transferee claims under the decree-holder and may apply for execution under S.146 CPC.

CPCexecutionorder-XXI-rule-16section-146actionable-claimsection-130assignment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1962

Jumma Masjid Mercara v Kodimaniandra Deviah

AIR 1962 Supreme Court 847

S.43 (feeding the grant) operates automatically; interest passes to original transferee the moment transferor acquires title; S.43 does not conflict with S.6(a)

property-lawfeeding-the-grantestoppelsection-43section-6a
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2004

K Balakrishnan v K Kamalam

(2004) 1 Supreme Court Cases 681

Acceptance by donee is essential for valid gift; acceptance can be implied from conduct (mutation, possession, tax payment)

property-lawgiftacceptancesection-122implied-acceptance
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2004

Karnataka Board of Wakf v. Government of India

(2004) 10 SCC 779

A plea of title and a plea of adverse possession are mutually inconsistent. Adverse possession must be specifically pleaded and proved as actual, visible, exclusive, hostile possession, with animus, continued over the statutory period. The Government of India's title to the Bijapur monuments under the Ancient Monuments law was upheld; the Wakf Board's notifications were not sustained, and the Government's alternative adverse-possession plea was also unsustainable.

adverse-possessionmutually-inconsistent-pleasancient-monumentswakfpleading-and-proof
Read case brief
Allahabad High Court1937

Kashi Prasad v. Chhabi Nath

AIR 1937 Allahabad 287

A condition subsequent that absolutely bars alienation is void; the transferee takes property free of the restraint

property-lawTPAsection-10section-26restraintcondition-subsequent
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1951

Kedar Lall Seal v Hari Lall Seal

AIR 1952 SC 47; 1952 SCR 179

A claim is not to be dismissed for clumsy pleading where its substance is clear and no prejudice is caused; the parties plead facts and the court applies the law. Contribution between co-mortgagors is governed by S.82 and S.92 TPA (rateable by value).

CPCpleadingssubstance-over-formorder-VITPA-s82contributionsubrogation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1964

KJ Nathan v SV Maruty Reddy

AIR 1965 SC 430; (1964) 6 SCR 727; 1964 INSC 32

A mortgage by deposit of title deeds (S.58(f) TPA) needs only a debt, a deposit of title deeds (actual or constructive) and an intention that the deeds be security; no written instrument is needed, and intention is a question of fact.

property-lawmortgageequitable-mortgagedeposit-of-title-deedssection-58f
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from Allahabad)1940

Maharani Hemanta Kumari Debi v Gauri Shankar Tewari

AIR 1941 PC 38; [1940] UKPC 65; (1941) 43 Bom LR 777

The plaintiff was held to own the Prayag (Puthia) bathing ghat at Benares; the trial decree for removal of obstructions was restored, with the injunction limited to ghatia activity carried on without her consent.

property-lawownershipghatinjunctionprivy-council
Read case brief
Bombay High Court1912

Mulraj Khatau v. Vishvanath Prabhuram Vaidya

(1913) 15 Bombay Law Reporter 9 (decided 21 Nov 1912); \"AIR 1912 Bombay 362\" as previously cited here is unconfirmed — the fetched report shows no AIR citation

Transfer of an actionable claim, whether absolute or by way of security, must be made by a written instrument signed by the transferor under S.130(1) TPA; an earlier, merely oral deposit/charge over the claim creates no enforceable right against a later written assignee, and English-law equitable-assignment principles do not apply given the section's exhaustive, positive language.

property-lawTPAsection-130actionable-claiminsurance-policywritten-instrument
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from Calcutta)1915

Musahar Sahu v Lala Hakim Lal

(1915) 43 IA 104; [1915] UKPC 60

A transfer to a genuine creditor in satisfaction of a real debt is not a fraudulent transfer under S.53 TPA merely because it prefers that creditor and leaves others unpaid; it is fraudulent only if it is a colourable device or keeps a benefit for the debtor.

property-lawfraudulent-transfersection-53preferencecreditorsprivy-council
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1977

Narandas Karsondas v SA Kamtam

AIR 1977 Supreme Court 774

Right of redemption subsists until extinguished by foreclosure decree, court sale, or limitation; mere passage of time does not destroy it

property-lawmortgageredemptionsection-60foreclosurelimitation
Read case brief
Madras High Court1953

Narayanan v. Lakshmi Ammal

AIR 1953 Madras 420

Transferee of actionable claim takes subject to all defenses available against the transferor, including prior payment

property-lawTPAsection-132actionable-claimequities
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from Oudh)1928

Nawab Sadiq Ali Khan v Jai Kishori

[1928] UKPC 27; (1928) 30 Bom LR 1346

A mortgage executed by minors is void under Indian law, and a deed executed by a minor cannot found an estoppel against him.

contract-lawminorvoid-agreementmortgageestoppelprivy-council
Read case brief
Bombay High Court1932

Official Assignee, Bombay v. Shroff

AIR 1932 Bombay 281

Property includes every type of interest capable of being owned, including intangible rights such as a seat on the stock exchange

property-lawTPAintangible-propertystock-exchange
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1954

Pandit Chunchun Jha v Sheikh Ebadat Ali

AIR 1954 SC 345; 1955 SCR 174

Whether a deed is a mortgage by conditional sale or a sale with a condition of repurchase depends on the intention of the parties, gathered first from the document itself; surrounding circumstances are looked at only if the language is ambiguous.

property-lawTPAsection-58mortgageconditional-saleintention-testlandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1974

Qudrat Ullah v. Municipal Board, Bareilly

AIR 1974 Supreme Court 396

A lease exceeding one year without a registered instrument does not create a valid leasehold interest; it may be treated as month-to-month tenancy

property-lawTPAsection-107leaseregistrationone-year
Read case brief
Allahabad High Court1897

Radha Kishan Das v Bishan Chand

ILR 19 All 489 (1897) (not checked against the printed report)

A deposit paid by a buyer is security for performance; if the buyer defaults, the seller may keep it and the buyer cannot recover it.

property-lawsaleearnest-moneydepositforfeiturebuyer-default
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

Rajes Kanta Roy v. Santi Debi

AIR 1957 Supreme Court 255

Where enjoyment is postponed to a date certain to arrive (e.g., attaining age), the interest is vested, not contingent

property-lawTPAsection-19vested-interestcertain-eventlandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1966

Rambaran Prosad v Ram Mohit Hazra

AIR 1967 SC 744; (1967) 1 SCR 293

A covenant of pre-emption creates no interest in land (S.14, S.54 TPA), so the rule against perpetuity does not apply to it; under S.40 TPA it binds assignees who take gratuitously or with notice, but not a bona fide purchaser for value without notice.

property-lawpre-emptionrule-against-perpetuitysection-14section-40covenant
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from Bengal)1872

Ramcoomar Koondoo v Macqueen

(1872) LR IA Supp 40; [1872] UKPC 46

Where the real owner lets another appear as owner (benami), a purchaser for value who buys in good faith after reasonable inquiry, without notice of the true title, takes a good title against the real owner.

property-lawostensible-ownersection-41benamiestoppelprivy-council
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England and Wales)1955

Re Ellenborough Park

[1956] Ch 131; [1955] EWCA Civ 4

An easement must (1) have a dominant and a servient tenement, (2) accommodate the dominant tenement, (3) have different owners of the two, and (4) be capable of forming the subject of a grant. A right accommodates the dominant land only if it is connected with its normal enjoyment, not merely of personal benefit to its owner.

property-laweasementsessentialsaccommodate-dominant-tenementenglish-case
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

S Kaladevi v VR Somasundaram

(2010) 5 SCC 401; AIR 2010 SC 1654; 2010 INSC 205

Under the proviso to S.49 Registration Act, an unregistered sale deed may be received in a suit for specific performance as evidence of the contract, or of a collateral transaction, though not as proof of a completed sale.

property-lawregistration-actsection-49unregistered-sale-deedspecific-performance
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1982

Sardar Govindrao v. Devi Sahai

AIR 1982 Supreme Court 989

Payment of substantial consideration coupled with delivery of possession constitutes sufficient part performance to invoke S.53A

property-lawTPAsection-53Apart-performanceacts-in-furtherance
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1958

Seth Ganga Dhar v Shankar Lal

AIR 1958 Supreme Court 770

A clause making property absolutely mortgagee's upon default is a clog on redemption and void; once a mortgage, always a mortgage

property-lawmortgageclog-on-redemptionsection-60once-a-mortgage
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1958

Shantabai v. State of Bombay

AIR 1958 Supreme Court 532

Standing timber is movable property; fruit-bearing trees rooted in earth are immovable property under S.3 TPA

property-lawTPAimmovable-propertystanding-timber
Read case brief
Punjab High Court1960

Shivdev Singh v. Sucha Singh

AIR 1960 Punjab 266

A charge under S.100 requires specific property to be made liable for payment; a vague direction to pay from 'property' is not a charge

property-lawTPAsection-100chargespecific-property
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2002

Shrimant Shamrao Suryavanshi v Pralhad Bhairoba Suryavanshi

(2002) 3 SCC 676

A transferee in possession under part performance can defend that possession under S.53A against the transferor and a later purchaser with notice, even after a suit for specific performance has become time-barred.

property-lawpart-performancesection-53Alimitationsubsequent-purchaser
Read case brief
Privy Council1872

Tagore v Tagore

(1872) LR Supp Vol 47 (Privy Council)

Rule against perpetuity tests possibility at date of transfer; if interest MIGHT vest beyond permitted period, it is void ab initio

property-lawperpetuitysection-14possibility-testunborn
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1988

Tej Bhan Madan v II Additional District Judge

(1988) 3 SCC 137; AIR 1988 SC 1413

A tenant who has attorned to and paid rent to a landlord cannot later deny that landlord's title or the title of his transferee; doing so is a denial of title that grounds eviction under the UP Rent Act. S.116 Evidence Act is not exhaustive of tenant estoppel.

property-lawleasetenant-estoppeldenial-of-titlesection-116-evidence-actrent-control
Read case brief
Court of Chancery (England)1848

Tulk v Moxhay

(1848) 2 Ph 774

Restrictive covenant binds subsequent purchaser with notice, even without privity of contract

property-lawcovenantrestrictivenoticeequitysection-40
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2001

Union Bank of India v. Anil Kumar

AIR 2001 Supreme Court 2083

Marshalling cannot be applied if it would prejudice the senior creditor's recovery or injure the rights of an intermediate encumbrancer

property-lawTPAmarshallinglimitationprejudice
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1967

Valliammai Achi v. Nagappa Chettiar and Ors.

AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1153; 1967 SCR (2) 448; Civil Appeal No. 806 of 1964

The doctrine of testamentary election under S.180 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 arises only where the legatee, to take a benefit given by the will, must choose between that benefit and some property of their own that the will also purports to dispose of; a person who takes no benefit under the will and claims independently of the testator (e.g. an adoptee whose interest arises by operation of law, not through the will) is not bound by any election the testator's original legatee may have made. A father in a Mitakshara joint family cannot convert joint family property into his own absolute property merely by making a will over it.

property-lawelectionindian-succession-actsection-180testamentary-electionjoint-family
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1999

Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao

AIR 1999 Supreme Court 1441

Delivery of possession without a registered sale deed does not constitute a valid sale for immovable property valued above Rs.100

property-lawTPAsection-54registrationdeliverypossession
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1995

Vidya Devi alias Vidya Vati v Prem Prakash

(1995) 4 SCC 496; AIR 1995 SC 1789; 1995 INSC 361

Under the Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954, where no limitation applies to a co-bhumidhar's partition suit, another co-bhumidhar cannot set up title by adverse possession; such a plea is clearly untenable and need not be referred to the civil court.

land-lawsdelhi-land-reforms-actco-bhumidharpartitionadverse-possessionsection-186
Read case brief