Narayanan v Lakshmi Ammal
Under review This case note is being re-checked against the judgment.
- Facts
- A creditor assigned a debt to a third party. The debtor had already made partial payments to the original creditor before the assignment. The assignee demanded the full original amount from the debtor.
- Issue
- Whether the assignee (transferee) of an actionable claim takes it subject to defenses that the debtor could have raised against the original creditor (transferor).
- Held
- Yes. Under S.132, the assignee gets no better right than the assignor had. All defenses available against the original creditor (prior payment, set-off, illegality, limitation) can be raised against the assignee. The assignee can only recover what is actually due.
- Principle
- Transferee of actionable claim takes subject to all defenses available against the transferor, including prior payment
Facts
- A creditor assigned a debt to a third party
- The debtor had already made partial payments to the original creditor before the assignment
- The assignee demanded the full original amount from the debtor
Issue
- Whether the assignee (transferee) of an actionable claim takes it subject to defenses that the debtor could have raised against the original creditor (transferor).
Held
- Yes. Under S.132, the assignee gets no better right than the assignor had. All defenses available against the original creditor (prior payment, set-off, illegality, limitation) can be raised against the assignee. The assignee can only recover what is actually due.
Ratio decidendi
S.132 enacts the principle "nemo dat quod non habet" (no one can give what they do not have) for actionable claims. The transferor's right was already diminished by the partial payment; the transferee receives only this diminished right. This protects debtors from having to pay twice.
Exam use
How to use it in an answer
Use in problems where the debtor has defenses against the original creditor. Key line: "Assignee takes subject to all equities; debtor's defense of prior payment defeats the assignee's claim for the paid amount."
Cite this
Citation
Narayanan v. Lakshmi Ammal AIR 1953 Madras 420Reported: Mulla TPA 13th ed. CAUTION: the citation \"AIR 1953 Madras 420\" is confirmed (via Indian Kanoon, two independent lookups 2026-11-14) to actually belong to a different case entirely — \"Hajee Mahomed Abdul Rahman v Tajunnissa Begum And Anr\" (Madras HC, decided 3 September 1952, Venkatarama Aiyar J.), about interim maintenance pending a marriage/restitution suit, with no connection to actionable claims or S.132 TPA. No case named \"Narayanan v. Lakshmi Ammal\" matching this subject could be found under any searched term. This is a confirmed citation misattribution, not merely an unverified case — needs a human to either locate the real source or retire this entry.. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.