Union Bank of India v Anil Kumar
Under review This case note is being re-checked against the judgment.
- Facts
- A debtor's properties were mortgaged to multiple creditors. A junior creditor sought marshalling to protect their security. However, applying marshalling would have delayed the senior creditor's recovery and adversely affected an intermediate encumbrancer.
- Issue
- Whether marshalling can be refused if its application would prejudice the senior creditor or an intermediate third-party encumbrancer.
- Held
- Yes. Marshalling is an equitable remedy. It is not absolute. Courts will refuse to apply it where: (1) it would prejudice the senior creditor's right to timely recovery; (2) it would injure an intermediate encumbrancer; or (3) it would create injustice to innocent third parties.
- Principle
- Marshalling cannot be applied if it would prejudice the senior creditor's recovery or injure the rights of an intermediate encumbrancer
Facts
- A debtor's properties were mortgaged to multiple creditors
- A junior creditor sought marshalling to protect their security
- However, applying marshalling would have delayed the senior creditor's recovery and adversely affected an intermediate encumbrancer
Issue
- Whether marshalling can be refused if its application would prejudice the senior creditor or an intermediate third-party encumbrancer.
Held
- Yes. Marshalling is an equitable remedy. It is not absolute. Courts will refuse to apply it where: (1) it would prejudice the senior creditor's right to timely recovery; (2) it would injure an intermediate encumbrancer; or (3) it would create injustice to innocent third parties.
Ratio decidendi
Marshalling exists to prevent prejudice to junior creditors. But equity will not cure one injustice by creating another. If marshalling would merely shift prejudice from the junior creditor to the senior creditor or a third party, the court will decline to apply it.
Exam use
How to use it in an answer
Use as the limitation/exception to marshalling. Key line: "Marshalling is refused if it would prejudice the senior creditor or an intermediate encumbrancer."
Cite this
Citation
Union Bank of India v. Anil Kumar AIR 2001 Supreme Court 2083Reported: Mulla TPA 13th ed. CAUTION (checked 2026-11-14 via Indian Kanoon): the citation \"AIR 2001 SC 2083\" actually belongs to a different, unrelated case — Uniply Industries Ltd. v. Unicorn Plywood Pvt. Ltd., a trademark/passing-off decision, confirmed by multiple citing judgments on Indian Kanoon all pointing to that case at this exact citation. No case named \"Union Bank of India v. Anil Kumar\" on marshalling was found under any search variant tried. The content below (marshalling, senior creditor prejudice) may still be a real legal point from Mulla's textbook, but it is not attached to its claimed citation; needs a human to find the real source or confirm this was a secondary-source paraphrase without a real case behind it.. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.