Harinarayan v Badridass
Under review This case note is being re-checked against the judgment.
- Facts
- Harinarayan's house had windows facing Badridass's vacant plot for over 20 years. Badridass proposed to construct a multi-storey building that would block approximately 50% of the light to Harinarayan's windows.
- Issue
- Whether construction on servient land that obstructs 50% of the light enjoyed by the dominant heritage through prescriptive easement is actionable.
- Held
- Yes. The obstruction is actionable. Once an easement of light is established, the servient owner cannot diminish it substantially. A 50% reduction constitutes substantial diminution. The court granted a mandatory injunction directing modification of the construction plans.
- Principle
- Once an easement of light is established, the servient owner cannot construct anything that substantially diminishes the light
Facts
- Harinarayan's house had windows facing Badridass's vacant plot for over 20 years
- Badridass proposed to construct a multi-storey building that would block approximately 50% of the light to Harinarayan's windows
- Harinarayan sought injunction
Issue
- Whether construction on servient land that obstructs 50% of the light enjoyed by the dominant heritage through prescriptive easement is actionable.
Held
- Yes. The obstruction is actionable. Once an easement of light is established, the servient owner cannot diminish it substantially. A 50% reduction constitutes substantial diminution. The court granted a mandatory injunction directing modification of the construction plans.
Ratio decidendi
An easement of light, once acquired, protects the quantum of light historically received. The servient owner cannot build anything that materially reduces this quantum. The test is "substantial" diminution, not mere reduction. The court considers the purpose of the windows, the extent of obstruction, and the effect on habitability.
Exam use
How to use it in an answer
Use in easement of light problems involving proposed construction. Key line: "Substantial diminution of light after easement is established is actionable; 50% obstruction qualifies."
Cite this
Citation
Harinarayan v. Badridass AIR 1964 Madhya Pradesh 250Reported: Mulla, Indian Easements Act. CAUTION: confirmed twice independently (2026-11-13 and 2026-11-14) that no record of a Madhya Pradesh High Court 1964 case under this name/citation (\"AIR 1964 Madhya Pradesh 250\") exists on Indian Kanoon (0 results on direct name and citation searches). A real Supreme Court case, \"Hari Narain v Badri Das\" ([1964] 2 SCR 203, decided 1963-03-04), exists under a near-identical name — but it is a different court (SC, not MP HC) deciding a different subject entirely (untrue statements in a special-leave petition, not easement of light). Likely wrong-case/conflated-identity rather than merely unverified; needs a human to locate the real MP HC easement case, if one exists, or retire this entry.. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.