Devi Prasad v Gopal Chandra
Under review This case note is being re-checked against the judgment.
- Facts
- A will gave a legacy to X and also disposed of X's self-acquired property in favor of Y. X accepted the legacy without raising objection to the disposition of their property.
- Issue
- Whether acceptance of a benefit under an instrument amounts to election in favor of all provisions of that instrument, including those that dispose of the beneficiary's own property.
- Held
- X is deemed to have elected in favor of the transfer. By accepting the legacy, X consented to all provisions of the will, including the transfer of X's property to Y. X cannot approbate and reprobate the same instrument.
- Principle
- A person who accepts a benefit under an instrument is deemed to have elected in favor of all provisions of that instrument, including those disposing of their own property
Facts
- A will gave a legacy to X and also disposed of X's self-acquired property in favor of Y
- X accepted the legacy without raising objection to the disposition of their property
- X later tried to reclaim the property while retaining the legacy
Issue
- Whether acceptance of a benefit under an instrument amounts to election in favor of all provisions of that instrument, including those that dispose of the beneficiary's own property.
Held
- X is deemed to have elected in favor of the transfer. By accepting the legacy, X consented to all provisions of the will, including the transfer of X's property to Y. X cannot approbate and reprobate the same instrument.
Ratio decidendi
S.35 embodies the maxim qui approbat non reprobat. A person who takes a benefit under a transaction must submit to all its provisions. Acceptance of the benefit raises an implied election, binding the person to surrender the property that the transaction purports to transfer from them.
Exam use
How to use it in an answer
Use in election problems where the beneficiary has accepted the benefit. Key line: "He who accepts a benefit under an instrument is deemed to have elected in favor of all its provisions, including those disposing of his own property."
Cite this
Citation
Devi Prasad v. Gopal Chandra AIR 1913 Calcutta 259Reported: Avatar Singh, Law of Transfer of Property. CAUTION (checked 2026-11-14 via indiankanoon.org): neither \"Devi Prasad v. Gopal Chandra\" (AIR 1913 Cal 259) nor an exact match for \"Debi Prasad v. Golab Bhagat\" (17 CWN 701) could be located. The closest real case is \"Debi Prosad Chowdhury v. Golap Bhagat\" (Calcutta HC, 1 April 1913, (1913) ILR 40 Cal 421) — a Full Bench reference on whether a Hindu widow's mortgage of her husband's estate, made without proved legal necessity but with the consent of the next reversioner, binds the actual reversioner. \"Debi Prasad\"/\"Golab Bhagat\" are plausible spelling variants of that case's parties, but this vault's second party, \"Gopal Chandra,\" does not match \"Golap Bhagat\" at all, and the real case's subject (widow's alienation/reversioner doctrine) has nothing to do with the Doctrine of Election under TPA S.35, which this note is entirely about. Identity and subject both unconfirmed — do not rely on this note without independent verification.. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.