Law of Evidence case briefs

34 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Law of Evidence notes.

34 briefs in Law of Evidence
Supreme Court of India1973

Akalu Ahir v. Ramdeo Ram

AIR 1973 Supreme Court 2145

In a criminal appeal, the appellate court can reappraise evidence independently but should not disturb findings of fact unless they are perverse, based on no evidence, or result in miscarriage of justice.

appealrevisionevidence-reappreciationS.415-BNSSappellate-powerssem-5
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2014

Anvar PV v. PK Basheer

(2014) 10 Supreme Court Cases 473

S.65B(4) certificate is mandatory for admission of secondary electronic evidence; oral evidence cannot substitute for the statutory certificate

IT-lawelectronic-evidenceS65BcertificateadmissibilityBSA-S58landmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1975

Ashok Dulichand v. Madhavlal Dube

(1975) 4 SCC 664

Secondary evidence is inadmissible without laying proper foundation by proving the original exists and falls within a prescribed condition for its reception.

evidence-lawsecondary-evidencefoundationsection-65documentary-evidence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1982

Gangabai v. Chhabubai

(1982) 1 SCC 4

Under S.92 Evidence Act, the bar on oral evidence applies only where a party relies on a document as embodying the transaction; it does not apply where the party's case is that the document was never intended to be acted upon at all (a sham) — oral evidence is then admissible to prove the real transaction. Separately, a finding on title made only incidentally in a Small Causes Court suit does not operate as res judicata in a later regular civil suit on title (Explanation VIII, S.11 CPC requires the issue to have been directly and substantially in issue, not merely incidental).

evidence-lawsection-92sham-documentoral-evidenceres-judicatasection-11-cpcsmall-causes-court
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator of APS Star Industries Ltd.

(2010) 10 SCC 1

Inter-bank assignment of non-performing assets, carried out in accordance with RBI guidelines issued under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, is a permissible banking activity; the assignee bank may be substituted as secured creditor in the borrower's liquidation.

NPAassignmentbanking-regulation-actRBI-guidelinessecured-creditorsubstitutionliquidation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2011

Kalyan Kumar Gogoi v. Ashutosh Agnihotri

(2011) 2 SCC 532

In an election petition under S.100(1)(d)(iv) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, the petitioner must prove that a breach of the Act/Rules materially affected the election result — mere breach is not enough. The standard of proof for that 'material effect' question is beyond reasonable doubt, not mere probabilities. Because the Evidence Act applies to election-petition trials via S.87(2) RP Act, the ordinary hearsay rule applies in full: a witness's account of what others told them, or an unproduced original document, cannot establish the result was affected.

evidence-lawelection-lawhearsayrepresentation-of-people-actsection-100standard-of-proof
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1991

Khujji v. State of Madhya Pradesh

(1991) 3 SCC 627

A previous inconsistent statement proved to contradict a witness is not substantive evidence of the facts stated; it can only be used to impeach credibility.

evidence-lawprevious-inconsistent-statementimpeachmentsection-155credibility
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1975

Narayan Ganesh Dastane v. Sucheta Narayan Dastane

(1975) 1 SCC 326

In civil cases, the standard of proof is balance of probabilities (preponderance of evidence), not proof beyond reasonable doubt, even for serious allegations like cruelty.

evidence-lawstandard-of-proofcivil-standardbalance-of-probabilitiespreponderance-of-evidencecruelty
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1998

Pawan Kumar v. State of Haryana

(1998) 3 SCC 309

\"Soon before her death\" in S.113B IEA (now S.113 BSA) does not require cruelty on the day of death; continuous cruelty persisting up to or near death satisfies the requirement.

evidence-lawpresumptiondowry-deathsection-113Bsoon-before-deathcrueltysection-304B
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1837

Pickard v. Sears

(1837) 6 Ad & El 469

Where a person by words or conduct wilfully causes another to believe in a certain state of things and induces him to act on that belief to alter his position, the former is estopped from denying that state of things.

evidence-lawestoppelestoppel-by-conductenglish-law
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1974

Pooran Mal v. Director of Inspection

AIR 1974 Supreme Court 348

Art. 20(3) protects against testimonial compulsion, not against search and seizure of physical evidence. Seizure of documents from accused does not violate self-incrimination privilege.

self-incriminationarticle-20-3search-seizureevidencesem-5
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1973

R v. Barton

[1973] 1 WLR 115

In exceptional criminal cases where the liberty of a person is at stake, the court may require disclosure of lawyer-client privileged communications if they are essential to establishing innocence; the right to fair trial may override professional privilege.

evidence-lawprivilegelegal-professional-privilegefair-trialenglish-law
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2009

Ramesh Chandra Agrawal v. Regency Hospital

(2009) 9 SCC 709

Expert medical opinion is advisory, not conclusive; when experts conflict, court evaluates based on reasoning and qualifications and must give reasons for preferring one over another.

evidence-lawexpert-opinionmedical-evidencesection-45medical-negligence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1952

Rameshwar v. State of Rajasthan

AIR 1952 SC 54

There is no legal requirement that a victim of sexual offence must be corroborated, but as a rule of prudence courts seek independent corroboration; a previous consistent statement (FIR) is not independent corroboration but supports credibility under S.157 IEA (now S.151 BSA).

evidence-lawcorroborationsexual-offencesection-157previous-consistent-statementFIR
Read case brief
Privy Council1972

Ratten v The Queen

[1972] AC 378; [1971] UKPC 23

A statement made under the pressure of an event, without opportunity for concoction, is admissible as res gestae.

Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

Sarwan Singh v. State of Punjab

AIR 1957 SC 637

While S.133 IEA (now S.156 BSA) makes conviction on uncorroborated accomplice testimony technically legal, it is a rule of prudence (almost approaching law) that courts should not convict without corroboration in material particulars implicating the accused.

evidence-lawaccomplicecorroborationsection-133rule-of-prudence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1976

Sat Paul v. Delhi Administration

(1976) 1 SCC 727

The testimony of a hostile witness is not entirely worthless; the court may rely upon so much of the testimony as is corroborated by other reliable evidence.

evidence-lawhostile-witnesssection-154cross-examination-by-own-party
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1956

Shambhu Nath Mehra v. State of Ajmer

AIR 1956 SC 404

Under S.106 IEA (now S.106 BSA), when a fact is especially within the knowledge of the accused (such as source of disproportionate assets), the burden of proving it lies on that person.

evidence-lawburden-of-proofsection-106special-knowledgedisproportionate-assets
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

State of Gujarat v. Shyamlal Mohanlal

AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1251

Section 94(1) CrPC (compelling production of documents), on its true construction, does not apply to an accused person — reading it to cover an accused would conflict with the protection against self-incrimination under Article 20(3).

self-incriminationarticle-20-3section-94-crpcproduction-of-documentssem-5
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1999

State of Himachal Pradesh v. Jai Lal

(1999) 7 SCC 280

Expert evidence is admissible only if the witness has made the subject a matter of particular study, practice or observation and has special knowledge of it. An unsupported opinion, without the data or expertise required, cannot sustain a prosecution, and the Court will not interfere with an acquittal based on rejection of such evidence.

expert-evidencespecial-knowledgesection-45horticultureacquittalconspiracy
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1961

State of Punjab v. Sodhi Sukhdev Singh

AIR 1961 SC 493

The minister's claim of State privilege under S.123 IEA (now S.130 BSA) is not conclusive; the court has power to inspect documents to determine whether the privilege claim is justified.

evidence-lawprivilegestate-privilegeunpublished-official-recordssection-123
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1997

State of Rajasthan v. Ani alias Hanif

(1997) 6 SCC 162

A trial court may, under s.165 of the Evidence Act, interject during cross-examination to clarify a confusion in the witness's evidence. The evidence of an eyewitness should not be rejected merely because that person was not named in the First Information Statement.

section-165trial-judge-questionsFIR-omissioneyewitnessacquittal-reversed
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1999

Sukhar v State of UP

decided 1999-10-01 (reporter citation not confirmed)

A statement is res gestae only if made at or immediately after the event, before there is time to fabricate.

Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1959

Tahsildar Singh and Another v. The State of Uttar Pradesh

AIR 1959 SC 1012; 1959 SCR Supp (2) 875

Under S.162 CrPC (1898, pre-1955 amendment) read with S.145 Evidence Act, a witness's police statement can be used only to contradict the witness's testimony in court, for no other purpose -- not for cross-examination generally, and not for corroboration. A bare omission in the police statement counts as a \"contradiction\" only where it is a necessarily implied recital, the negative of a positive recital, or otherwise cannot stand together with the court testimony; other omissions cannot be used to contradict.

evidence-lawsection-162-crpccontradictionpolice-statementomissionssection-145
Read case brief
House of Lords (England)1935

Woolmington v. DPP

[1935] AC 462

The golden thread: it is the duty of the prosecution to prove the prisoner's guilt beyond reasonable doubt; the burden of proof lies on the prosecution throughout and never shifts to the accused except for insanity.

evidence-lawburden-of-proofpresumption-of-innocencegolden-threadcriminal-standardbeyond-reasonable-doubt
Read case brief