Air India v. Nergesh Meerza
(1981) 4 Supreme Court Cases 335 / AIR 1981 Supreme Court 1829
Compulsory retirement on first pregnancy is unconstitutional. An employer who permits marriage cannot penalise its natural consequence.
Read case brief48 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Labour Law II notes.
(1981) 4 Supreme Court Cases 335 / AIR 1981 Supreme Court 1829
Compulsory retirement on first pregnancy is unconstitutional. An employer who permits marriage cannot penalise its natural consequence.
Read case briefAIR 1962 Supreme Court 171
Art.19(1)(c) guarantees right to form unions but does not include right to collective bargaining or strike; those are statutory, not constitutional
Read case briefAIR 1962 Supreme Court 29
The definition of 'factory' under Section 2(m) of the Factories Act, 1948 turns on whether a 'manufacturing process' is carried on with the aid of power, and the concept of 'manufacturing process' is broadly construed to include activities that transform or treat raw material into a different or usable form, such as the conversion of seawater into salt through natural processes assisted by mechanical means, bringing such premises within the scope of the Act.
Read case briefAIR 1959 Supreme Court 967
Bonus is a deferred wage and a share in the prosperity of the enterprise. The Full Bench Formula provides the framework for computing available surplus from which bonus is payable.
Read case briefAIR 1978 Supreme Court 12
Maternity benefit must be calculated for all days of absence including Sundays and rest days, not just working days. Beneficial legislation must be construed liberally.
Read case brief(1989) 4 Supreme Court Cases 710
Strike is not raised to the status of a fundamental right, but is recognized as an important weapon in the armoury of workers for redressing grievances; the right to form a union, by contrast, IS a fundamental right under Art.19(1)(c).
Read case brief(1984) 3 Supreme Court Cases 161
Bonded labour violates Arts.21 and 23; State has positive obligation to identify, release, and rehabilitate bonded labourers.
Read case brief(1978) 2 Supreme Court Cases 213
Triple Test for determining 'industry': (1) systematic activity, (2) cooperation between employer and employee, (3) for production/supply/distribution of goods or services satisfying human wants
Read case briefAIR 1963 Supreme Court 1591
Section 85 of the Factories Act, and notifications issued under it, are constitutional and may be used to deem workers and extend the Act’s provisions without violating Articles 14 or 19(1)(g).
Read case briefAIR 1955 Supreme Court 33
Minimum Wages Act is constitutionally valid. Securing living wages is a reasonable restriction on freedom of trade under Article 19(6).
Read case brief(2002) 2 Supreme Court Cases 542
ESI Act applies to casual and temporary workers within covered establishment premises. Casual employment does not exempt from coverage.
Read case briefAIR 1951 Supreme Court 41
A statute may validly single out one enterprise for special treatment (nationalisation/takeover) if there is an intelligible differentia with a rational nexus to the object sought. Classification need not be abstract; it can be a "class of one" if circumstances justify.
Read case brief(1995) 3 Supreme Court Cases 42
Right to health and medical care at the workplace is a fundamental right under Article 21 (right to life). Employers in hazardous industries (asbestos) must provide health insurance, periodic medical examination, and safe working conditions. Workers' right to know about health hazards is part of Article 21.
Read case briefAIR 1978 SC 1489
Workmen are entitled to wages for a strike period only if the strike is both legal and justified, and they are disentitled if they resorted to force or violence.
Read case brief1958 Supreme Court Reports 651 / AIR 1958 Supreme Court 30
An industry that cannot pay minimum wages has no right to exist — "a right to exist unless it is able to pay" (exact judgment wording). Employer's inability to pay is no defence against the minimum wage obligation, though a wage structure set above the bare minimum may still be revised to workmen's prejudice if justified; the appeal in this case was dismissed.
Read case briefAIR 1992 Supreme Court 457; 1991 Supp (2) SCR 401; (1992) 1 SCC 695
Under the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970, failure of the principal employer to register or of the contractor to obtain a licence does not make contract labour employees of the principal employer. Abolition is for the appropriate Government under S.10, and a High Court cannot direct absorption under Art.226.
Read case briefAIR 1957 Supreme Court 264
The employer-employee relationship is determined by the right to control not only what work is done but how it is done
Read case briefAIR 1994 Supreme Court 1754
Persons working through a contractor but under the principal employer's supervision and control are employees under Section 2(9) of the ESI Act.
Read case brief(1979) 1 Supreme Court Cases 292
Section 25-O of the ID Act (prior government permission for closure) was struck down as an unreasonable restriction violating Art.19(1)(g); the right to carry on business includes the right to close it, and the State cannot force indefinite operation of a genuinely unviable business.
Read case briefAIR 1958 Supreme Court 578
Fair wage must consider the industry's capacity to pay. A wage fixation that forces an employer to close is an unreasonable restriction on Article 19(1)(g), but minimum wage remains inviolable.
Read case brief(1995) 6 SCC 326
Under the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, a Labour Court may entertain a complaint under Item 1 of Schedule IV even before the employer has passed a final order of discharge or dismissal; the Act is intended to prevent unfair labour practices at that earlier stage as well.
Read case briefAIR 1963 Supreme Court 1332; (1964) 1 SCR 234
Wage structures are fixed on an industry-cum-region basis with careful regard to the industry's capacity to pay. Workers should get a fair share of the national income without the source of that income being dried up.
Read case briefAIR 1967 Supreme Court 691; (1967) 1 SCR 15
The Payment of Bonus Act, 1965 is within Parliament's competence, and the minimum bonus under S.10 is valid as part of the scheme of set on and set off. S.33, S.34(2) and S.37 were held invalid.
Read case brief(2009) 7 SCC 526
Where cognizance is taken on a complaint under s.22 of the Transplantation of Human Organs Act, 1994, the CBI, though otherwise competent to investigate, is precluded by that special provision from filing a police report; the default-bail regime of s.167(2) CrPC, which is tied to investigation culminating in a police report, does not apply in that situation.
Read case briefAIR 1997 Supreme Court 699 / (1996) 6 Supreme Court Cases 756
State has a constitutional obligation to eliminate child labour in hazardous industries. Prohibition must be accompanied by rehabilitation (education fund, alternative employment for parents).
Read case briefAIR 1970 Supreme Court 1906; (1970) 1 SCR 869; (1969) 2 SCC 607
Compensation needs an injury by accident arising both out of and in the course of employment. The claimant must prove this; it may be proved by inference from proved facts, but not by conjecture.
Read case briefAIR 1987 Supreme Court 1281
Under the Equal Remuneration Act, 1976, the test for determining whether male and female employees are performing 'same or similar work' is a functional one: what matters is the nature and substance of the work actually performed, not the formal job title or designation assigned to the post; where the work performed is substantially similar in nature, skill, and responsibility, differential pay based on sex-linked designations or classifications violates the Act.
Read case briefAIR 1971 SC 2171
Reinstatement is the ordinary remedy when a dismissal is found to be wrongful, unless special circumstances justify compensation in lieu. The Supreme Court will not readily interfere under Art. 136 with a labour court's exercise of that discretion.
Read case brief(2011) 11 Supreme Court Cases 657
PF contributions must be calculated on basic wages plus dearness allowance. Allowances that are universally paid and linked to price index are part of basic wages for PF computation.
Read case briefAIR 1950 LAT 155
Origin of the Full Bench Formula for bonus computation. Established the principle that bonus is payable from available surplus after deducting prior charges from gross profits.
Read case brief(2000) 3 Supreme Court Cases 224
Maternity benefits must be extended to casual and muster-roll women workers, not just permanent employees. The Maternity Benefit Act applies regardless of the nature of employment.
Read case brief(1970) 2 Supreme Court Cases 879
Termination styled as 'discharge simpliciter' (without attributing misconduct) constitutes retrenchment requiring statutory compliance
Read case brief(1982) 3 Supreme Court Cases 235
Payment below minimum wage constitutes forced labour under Art.23; poverty vitiates consent; Art.23 operates horizontally against private employers
Read case briefAIR 1959 Supreme Court 1111
Tribunal retains jurisdiction to examine proportionality of punishment even when domestic inquiry is valid and misconduct proven; can reduce disproportionate punishment
Read case brief(1990) 3 Supreme Court Cases 682
Termination of worker with 240+ days continuous service, styled as 'end of temporary engagement,' constitutes retrenchment regardless of label
Read case briefAIR 1982 Supreme Court 879
The principle of 'equal pay for equal work,' though not expressly named as a fundamental right in Part III, is deducible from the equality guarantees under Articles 14 and 16, read with the Directive Principle in Article 39(d); persons performing the same or substantially similar duties, functions, and responsibilities are entitled to the same pay scale, absent a rational justification for differentiation.
Read case briefAIR 1997 Supreme Court 432
Whether a commuting accident counts as an 'employment injury' under the ESI Act depends on whether there is a sufficient nexus with employment, not merely that the journey was to or from work.
Read case briefAIR 2000 Supreme Court 331; (2000) 1 Supreme Court Cases 98
A Provident Fund member is a 'consumer' and the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner renders a 'service' to them under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 — a PF member may sue the Commissioner before a consumer forum.
Read case briefAIR 1983 Supreme Court 328
Payment of wages below the statutorily prescribed minimum wage to workers engaged on famine relief or drought relief works amounts to forced labour within the meaning of Article 23 of the Constitution, and cannot be justified merely because the work is offered as relief during a scarcity or emergency; the state cannot use economic distress as a ground to pay less than minimum wages.
Read case briefAIR 1958 Supreme Court 881
Workers who travel to/from a dangerous, employer-chosen workplace are covered while on the employer's premises, but an accident on a public waterway/road while commuting does not arise out of and in the course of employment merely because the workplace itself was hazardous, unless the employer imposed that specific route/mode of travel as a term of employment.
Read case briefAIR 1974 Supreme Court 890
Res ipsa loquitur applied where a State truck that was not roadworthy caught fire and a passenger died jumping out; famine relief work is not a sovereign function, so the State was vicariously liable for its driver's negligence.
Read case briefAIR 1960 Supreme Court 610
A government hospital where employer-employee relations exist constitutes an 'industry' regardless of charitable or governmental nature
Read case brief(2003) 6 Supreme Court Cases 581
There is no fundamental right to strike under the Indian Constitution; government employees especially have no moral or equitable justification for strikes
Read case briefAIR 1962 Supreme Court 12
Most authoritative judicial statement of the three-tier wage framework (minimum, fair, living). Individual employer hardship is irrelevant to minimum wage fixation.
Read case brief(1998) 6 Supreme Court Cases 538
Back wages are not automatic upon reinstatement; Tribunal must consider whether worker was gainfully employed elsewhere during dispute period
Read case briefAIR 1997 Supreme Court 3011
Unratified international conventions can be used as interpretive aids to fill gaps in domestic law where no contrary legislation exists
Read case briefAIR 1958 Supreme Court 353
An individual worker's dismissal becomes an industrial dispute only when espoused (taken up) by co-workers or trade union
Read case brief(1992) 1 Supreme Court Cases 290 / AIR 1992 Supreme Court 504
Minimum wage must include a sixth component (25% addition) for children's education, medical needs, and recreation beyond the four norms of the 15th Indian Labour Conference.
Read case briefTry another term, or search all cases.