Information Technology Law case briefs

41 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Information Technology Law notes.

41 briefs in Information Technology Law
Supreme Court of the United States2014

Alice Corp v CLS Bank International

573 U.S. 208 (2014)

Abstract ideas implemented on a generic computer are not patent-eligible; mere computerization of a conventional business method does not make it patentable (US Supreme Court).

it-lawsoftware-patentabstract-ideapatent-eligibilityus-law
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2019

Amway India Enterprises Pvt Ltd v 1MG Technologies Pvt Ltd (and connected suits)

CS(OS) 410/2018 etc. (single judge, Delhi HC, decided 8 July 2019); REVERSED on appeal, Amazon Seller Services Pvt Ltd v Amway India Enterprises Pvt Ltd, FAO(OS) 133/2019 etc. (Division Bench, Delhi HC, decided 31 Jan 2020)

REVERSED ON APPEAL (see Note below). The single-judge view (since overturned) was that e-commerce platforms could be restrained from listing direct-selling companies' products via unauthorized sellers, based on the Direct Selling Guidelines, 2016. The Division Bench instead held those Guidelines are advisory, not enforceable law, and that the platforms were not liable for tortious interference.

it-lawe-commerceintermediarydirect-selling-guidelinesreversed-on-appeal
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2014

Anvar PV v. PK Basheer

(2014) 10 Supreme Court Cases 473

S.65B(4) certificate is mandatory for admission of secondary electronic evidence; oral evidence cannot substitute for the statutory certificate

IT-lawelectronic-evidenceS65BcertificateadmissibilityBSA-S58landmark
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2008

Avnish Bajaj v State (NCT of Delhi)

150 (2008) Delhi Law Times 769

The CEO of an intermediary platform (Bazee.com/eBay) is not automatically liable for obscene content uploaded by users; intermediary liability requires knowledge and failure to act.

it-lawintermediary-liabilityobscenityceo-liabilitysection-79
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2010

Banyan Tree Holding v. A. Murali Krishna Reddy

2010 (42) PTC 361 (Del)

Mere accessibility of a website does not confer jurisdiction; court must apply 'purposeful availment' or 'targeting' test for internet jurisdiction

IT-lawjurisdictiontargeting-testinternettrademarkpurposeful-availmentlandmark
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2003

Casio India v Ashita Tele Systems

106 (2003) DLT 554; 2003 (27) PTC 265 (Del)

A website accessible in Delhi gives the Delhi court territorial jurisdiction; registering a domain containing another's mark (casioindia.com) to trade on its goodwill is passing off, restrained at the interim stage (Delhi HC).

it-lawdomain-namepassing-offtrademarkcyber-squatting
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2018

Christian Louboutin v Nakul Bajaj

253 (2018) Delhi Law Times 728

An e-commerce platform that actively promotes counterfeit goods loses intermediary safe harbour under S.79; distinction between active and passive intermediary.

it-lawintermediaryactive-vs-passivee-commercecounterfeit
Read case brief
Supreme Court of the United States1981

Diamond v Diehr

450 U.S. 175 (1981)

A process that incorporates a computer program may be patentable if it produces a useful, concrete, and tangible result; the program element alone does not bar patentability (US Supreme Court).

it-lawsoftware-patentprocess-patentuseful-resultus-law
Read case brief
High Court of Australia2002

Dow Jones v Gutnick

[2002] HCA 56

For internet defamation, the tort is committed where the publication is downloaded and read, not where it is uploaded; the place of downloading determines jurisdiction (Australian High Court).

it-lawinternet-jurisdictiondefamationplace-of-publicationaustralia
Read case brief
Kerala High Court2019

Faheema Shirin R.K. v State of Kerala

WP(C) No. 19716 of 2019; AIR 2020 Ker 35; (2019) 4 KLT 301

The right to have access to the internet is part of the right to education and the right to privacy under Art.21; a college hostel ban on mobile phone use from 6 p.m. to 10 p.m. was unreasonable (Kerala HC 2019).

it-lawright-to-internetright-to-educationprivacyarticle-21
Read case brief
Kerala High Court2019

Faheema Shirin R.K. v State of Kerala

AIR 2020 Kerala 35; (2019) 4 KER LJ 634

The right to have access to the internet is part of the right to education and the right to privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution; a hostel rule restricting phone/internet use that is not shown to cause any indiscipline cannot stand.

it-lawinternet-accessarticle-21privacyhostel-rules
Read case brief
Supreme Court of the United States1991

Feist Publications v Rural Telephone Service

499 U.S. 340 (1991)

Facts and data in a compilation are not copyrightable; copyright requires a minimum degree of creativity in selection and arrangement (US Supreme Court, 'sweat of the brow' rejected).

it-lawdatabase-protectioncopyrightcreativitysweat-of-brow
Read case brief
US District Court1998

Hotmail Corporation v Van Money Pie Inc

47 U.S.P.Q.2d 1020 (N.D. Cal. 1998)

Sending unsolicited bulk email (spam) through another's email service violates terms of service and constitutes unauthorized access; injunctive relief granted (US).

it-lawspamunauthorized-accessinjunctionemailus-law
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator of APS Star Industries Ltd.

(2010) 10 SCC 1

Inter-bank assignment of non-performing assets, carried out in accordance with RBI guidelines issued under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, is a permissible banking activity; the assignee bank may be substituted as secured creditor in the borrower's liquidation.

NPAassignmentbanking-regulation-actRBI-guidelinessecured-creditorsubstitutionliquidation
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2007

India TV Independent News Service v India Broadcast Live

2007 (35) PTC 177 (Del); MIPR 2007 (2) 396

Mere accessibility of a website may not found jurisdiction, but an interactive site that lets forum residents subscribe, and whose harm to the plaintiff's goodwill is felt in the forum, gives the forum court personal jurisdiction (Delhi HC 2007).

it-lawinternet-jurisdictioneffects-doctrinedomain-nameanti-suit-injunction
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

Infosys Technologies Ltd v Jupiter Infosys Ltd

Civil Appeal Nos. 5743-5745 of 2005 (decided 9 November 2010); reporter citation not independently confirmed

Under S.46 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, a rectification/removal applicant must be a 'person aggrieved' whose interest is genuinely affected ('not a fanciful suggestion of grievance'), and that grievance must subsist both when the application is made AND when it is finally decided by the Registrar/IPAB. The tribunal must be satisfied of this locus standi for each registration before ordering removal.

trademark-lawperson-aggrievedrectificationsection-46section-56locus-standi
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2017

KS Puttaswamy v. Union of India

(2017) 10 Supreme Court Cases 1

Right to privacy is a fundamental right under Art.21; any interference must satisfy triple test of legality, legitimate aim, and proportionality

IT-lawprivacyArt-21fundamental-rightdata-protectionPuttaswamylandmark
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2005

NASSCOM v Ajay Sood

119 (2005) Delhi Law Times 596

Phishing: fraudulently collecting personal data by impersonating legitimate entities online: is actionable as passing off even in the absence of specific legislation; the Delhi HC recognized phishing as illegal.

it-lawphishingpassing-offcyber-frauddata-theft
Read case brief
US Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit1996

ProCD Inc v Zeidenberg

86 F.3d 1447 (7th Cir. 1996)

Shrink-wrap licenses are enforceable contracts; opening the package and using the software constitutes acceptance of the license terms (US 7th Circuit).

it-lawshrink-wrapsoftware-licenseacceptance-by-useus-law
Read case brief
2001

Ritu Kohli Case (Delhi)

Criminal Case No. 171/2001 (Delhi)

First reported Indian case of cyber-stalking: using another person's identity on internet chat rooms to cause harassment constitutes an offence under the IT Act.

it-lawcyber-stalkingidentity-theftfirst-caseit-act
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2015

Shreya Singhal v. Union of India

(2015) 5 Supreme Court Cases 1

S.66A IT Act unconstitutional (vague, overbroad, violates Art.19(1)(a)); S.79 intermediary liability triggered only by court order or government notification, not private complaint.

IT-lawS66AArt-19freedom-of-speechintermediary-liabilitylandmark
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2004

SMC Pneumatics (India) Pvt Ltd v Jogesh Kwatra

Suit No. 1279/2001 (Delhi High Court)

Sending defamatory emails about an employer to its business associates constitutes cyber defamation; injunction can be granted to prevent further publication.

it-lawcyber-defamationemailinjunctionemployer
Read case brief
US Court of Appeals, Second Circuit2002

Specht v Netscape Communications Corp

306 F.3d 17 (2d Cir. 2002)

Browse-wrap agreements are not enforceable unless the user has actual or constructive notice of the terms; mere availability of terms on a linked page is insufficient (US 2nd Circuit).

it-lawbrowse-wrapnoticeenforceabilityonline-contractus-law
Read case brief
Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai2004

State of Tamil Nadu v. Suhas Katti

CC No.4680/2004 (Egmore Court, Chennai)

First Indian conviction under the IT Act 2000 (S.67); posting obscene and defamatory content about a woman on internet group is punishable

IT-lawcyber-crimeS67first-convictionobscenitylandmark
Read case brief
2014

State v Mehdi Masroor Biswas

FIR No. 01/2015, NIA Special Court, Bengaluru

Operating social media accounts to propagate terrorist ideology and recruit for terrorist organizations constitutes cyber-terrorism under S.66F of the IT Act.

it-lawcyber-terrorismsocial-mediasection-66frecruitment
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2017

Super Cassettes Industries Ltd v Myspace Inc

2017 SCC OnLine Delhi 7810

Copyright owners can seek injunction against platforms hosting infringing content; S.79 safe harbour does not protect platforms with actual knowledge of infringement.

it-lawcopyrightintermediaryinjunctionsafe-harbouractual-knowledge
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2004

Tata Consultancy Services v State of AP

(2005) 1 SCC 308; AIR 2005 SC 371

Canned (branded) software sold on a medium is 'goods' liable to sales tax; the Court did not decide unbranded or customised software (Supreme Court, Constitution Bench, 2004).

it-lawsoftware-as-goodssales-taxcanned-softwaretangible-property
Read case brief
Delhi High Court2001

Tata Sons Ltd v Manu Kosuri

2001 PTC 432 (Delhi)

Registration and use of a domain name identical to a well-known trademark (tata.net) by an unauthorized person constitutes cyber-squatting and passing off.

it-lawdomain-nametatacyber-squattingwell-known-mark
Read case brief
Bombay High Court2019

Tips Industries Ltd v Wynk Music Ltd

2019 SCC OnLine Bombay 1475

A statutory license under S.31D of the Copyright Act does not cover internet/online streaming; streaming services need direct licenses from copyright owners.

it-lawstatutory-licensestreamingcopyrightsection-31d
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

Trimex International FZE Ltd v. Vedanta Aluminium Ltd

(2010) 3 Supreme Court Cases 1

A contract concluded by offer and unconditional acceptance exchanged by e-mail is binding; that a formal contract was to be signed later does not affect it (SC 2010, under ss.4 and 7 Contract Act)

e-contractemail-contractarbitration-agreementconcluded-contractS4-contract-act
Read case brief
Delhi High Court (Division Bench)2014

World Wrestling Entertainment Inc v Reshma Collection

FAO(OS) 506/2013, decided 15 October 2014 (Delhi HC, Division Bench)

A plaintiff selling to Delhi customers through its website 'carries on business' in Delhi for s.134(2) Trade Marks Act and s.62(2) Copyright Act, since the online contract is concluded where the customer accepts (Delhi HC DB 2014).

it-lawtrademarkdomain-namewell-known-markglobal-reputation
Read case brief
US District Court, N.D. California2000

Yahoo! Inc v LICRA

169 F. Supp. 2d 1181 (N.D. Cal. 2001)

A foreign court's order directing a US company to block access to content violating local law raises jurisdictional conflict; the country where harm occurs can assert jurisdiction over internet content (French court).

it-lawinternet-jurisdictionfrancehate-speechcross-border
Read case brief
US District Court1997

Zippo Manufacturing Co v Zippo Dot Com Inc

952 F. Supp. 1119 (W.D. Pa. 1997)

The 'sliding scale' test for internet jurisdiction: passive websites (information only) = no jurisdiction; interactive websites (commercial transactions) = jurisdiction exists (US).

it-lawinternet-jurisdictionsliding-scale-testpassive-active-websiteus-law
Read case brief