Trademark lawPerson aggrievedSupreme Court of India

Infosys Technologies Ltd v Jupiter Infosys Ltd

Civil Appeal Nos. 5743-5745 of 2005 (decided 9 November 2010); reporter citation not independently confirmed20102 min read

Partly verified Not every detail here has been checked against the full judgment yet.

The case in brief30-second read
Facts
Infosys registered "Infosys" for computer stationery, manuals, hardware and machine tools (Classes 7, 9, 16) in 1987-88. Jupiter Infosys Ltd used "Infosys" in its name; Infosys sued for infringement/passing off in the Calcutta HC (1996), Madras HC (2001) and Delhi HC (2002) — the Delhi vacation judge's 2002 order restrained use of "INFOSYS" including in domain names, but this order is only quoted as background and was never itself reviewed by the Supreme Court.
Issue
Whether Jupiter was a "person aggrieved" under S.46 (narrower, non-use ground) and S.56 (broader, public-interest ground), and whether that status had to subsist not just when the rectification application was filed but also when it was finally decided.
Held
"Person aggrieved" under S.46 is narrower than under S.56 (adopting the test from Hardie Trading and Royal Baking Powder v. Wright, Crossley). Under S.46 the applicant's interest must genuinely be affected — "it must not be a fanciful suggestion of grievance."
Principle
Under S.46 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, a rectification/removal applicant must be a 'person aggrieved' whose interest is genuinely affected ('not a fanciful suggestion of grievance'), and that grievance must subsist both when the application is made AND when it is finally decided by the Registrar/IPAB. The tribunal must be satisfied of this locus standi for each registration before ordering removal.

Facts

  • Infosys registered "Infosys" for computer stationery, manuals, hardware and machine tools (Classes 7, 9, 16) in 1987-88.
  • Jupiter Infosys Ltd used "Infosys" in its name; Infosys sued for infringement/passing off in the Calcutta HC (1996), Madras HC (2001) and Delhi HC (2002) — the Delhi vacation judge's 2002 order restrained use of "INFOSYS" including in domain names, but this order is only quoted as background and was never itself reviewed by the Supreme Court.
  • Jupiter separately applied under Ss. 46 and 56 of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 to remove Infosys's three registrations for non-use; the applications were transferred to the IPAB.
  • The IPAB ordered the registrations removed. By the time of a 14 July 2004 affidavit in the Delhi suit, Jupiter stated there was "now... no dispute between the plaintiff and defendant under the Trade Mark."

Issue

  1. Whether Jupiter was a "person aggrieved" under S.46 (narrower, non-use ground) and S.56 (broader, public-interest ground), and whether that status had to subsist not just when the rectification application was filed but also when it was finally decided.

Held

  • "Person aggrieved" under S.46 is narrower than under S.56 (adopting the test from Hardie Trading and Royal Baking Powder v. Wright, Crossley). Under S.46 the applicant's interest must genuinely be affected — "it must not be a fanciful suggestion of grievance."
  • The grievance "must continue to exist when such application is decided," not merely when it was filed.
  • "The pre-requisite for exercise of power under Section 46(1) is that the applicant is a person aggrieved" — the IPAB had to consider this separately for each of the three registrations and be satisfied of it before ordering removal, which it had not properly done (especially given Jupiter's own 2004 affidavit suggesting the dispute had ended).
  • Result: appeals allowed in part; the IPAB's removal order set aside and the three rectification applications restored to the IPAB at Chennai for fresh hearing; the merits (non-use, S.56) left open.

Ratio decidendi

A rectification/removal applicant under S.46 of the 1958 Act must be a "person aggrieved" with a real (not fanciful) interest, and that standing must persist through to the date of the tribunal's decision, not just the date of filing — a tribunal cannot order removal without separately satisfying itself of this for each registration challenged.

Exam use

How to use it in an answer

Do not cite this case for a substantive deceptive-similarity/passing-off holding, or for a domain-name/cyber-squatting proposition — those were this note's own prior errors. Use it for the "person aggrieved" locus-standi requirement in trademark rectification proceedings under the 1958 Act.

Cite this

Citation

Infosys Technologies Ltd v Jupiter Infosys Ltd Civil Appeal Nos. 5743-5745 of 2005 (decided 9 November 2010); reporter citation not independently confirmed

Reported: https://indiankanoon.org/doc/806212 (read verbatim 2026-11-14, full text). Corrects a prior version of this note that wrongly framed the case as a substantive trademark-infringement/domain-name decision — the Supreme Court here decided only the procedural 'person aggrieved' question for a rectification application; the domain-name reference is a quoted Delhi HC interim order mentioned only as background, never analysed by the Supreme Court.. This is an educational summary, not the judgment itself. Cite the reported version in professional or academic work.