Constitutional Law II case briefs

64 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Constitutional Law II notes.

64 briefs in Constitutional Law II
Supreme Court of India2002

All India Judges Association v Union of India

(2002) 4 Supreme Court Cases 247; All India Reporter 2002 Supreme Court 1752

The independence and efficiency of the subordinate judiciary are constitutional imperatives, and the Court may issue structural directions to secure them. Directions were given on pay, the judge to population ratio, direct recruitment of about twenty five per cent of district judges from the Bar, and a limited competitive examination for accelerated promotion.

constitutional-lawsubordinate-judiciaryjudicial-serviceshetty-commissiondirect-recruitmentjudicial-independenceservice-conditions
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2023

Anoop Baranwal v Union of India

(2023) 6 Supreme Court Cases 161; judgment of 2 March 2023

The independence of the Election Commission is essential to free and fair elections, which form part of the basic structure. Exclusive executive control over appointments to the Commission is inconsistent with that independence. Until Parliament legislates, appointments were directed to be made on the advice of a committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition and the Chief Justice of India.

constitutional-lawarticle-324election-commissionappointmentbasic-structurefree-and-fair-electionsindependenceselection-committee
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1961

Atiabari Tea Co Ltd v State of Assam

All India Reporter 1961 Supreme Court 232; (1961) 1 Supreme Court Reports 809

The freedom under Article 301 is a freedom from restrictions on the movement or transport of goods. A law which imposes a tax that directly and immediately restricts or impedes the free flow of trade falls within Article 301 and must be justified under Article 302 or Article 304. Laws affecting trade only indirectly are outside it.

constitutional-lawarticle-301article-304interstate-tradedirect-and-immediate-restrictionpresidential-sanctionpart-xiii
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1962

Automobile Transport (Rajasthan) Ltd v State of Rajasthan

All India Reporter 1962 Supreme Court 1406; (1963) 1 Supreme Court Reports 491

Regulatory measures, and compensatory taxes levied for the use of trading facilities, do not fall within the purview of Article 301 at all and need no justification under Article 302 or Article 304. Such levies do not hamper trade but facilitate it.

constitutional-lawarticle-301compensatory-taxregulatory-measureinterstate-trademotor-vehicles-taxpart-xiii
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

B P Singhal v Union of India

(2010) 6 Supreme Court Cases 331

The doctrine of pleasure in Article 156(1) is not subject to any limitations and requires no reasons, but the power cannot be exercised arbitrarily, capriciously or for irrelevant or extraneous reasons. A change of government at the Centre is not by itself a ground for removing a Governor.

constitutional-lawarticle-155article-156governordoctrine-of-pleasureremovalarbitrarinessjudicial-review
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1962

Bhikraj Jaipuria v Union of India

All India Reporter 1962 Supreme Court 113; (1962) 2 Supreme Court Reports 880

The constitutional form prescribed for government contracts is mandatory and not directory. A contract that does not comply is void and unenforceable against the Government, and because the requirement exists for the protection of the public it cannot be waived, nor can the contract be ratified by conduct.

constitutional-lawarticle-299government-contractsmandatory-formratificationestoppelvoid-contract
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1995

C Ravichandran Iyer v Justice A M Bhattacharjee

(1995) 5 Supreme Court Cases 457

A Bar Association has no authority to sit in judgment on a Judge or to demand his resignation by resolution or by abstention from work. There is a gap between conduct amounting to proved misbehaviour warranting removal and conduct merely unbecoming of judicial office, and that gap is filled by an in-house procedure headed by the Chief Justice of India.

constitutional-lawjudicial-accountabilityin-house-procedurebar-associationarticle-124yawning-gapjudicial-independence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2020

Central Public Information Officer, Supreme Court of India v Subhash Chandra Agarwal

(2020) 5 Supreme Court Cases 481; judgment of 13 November 2019

The office of the Chief Justice of India is a public authority under the Right to Information Act, 2005 and is not a separate authority from the Supreme Court. Judicial independence is not a shield against accountability, though disclosure must be tested against the statutory exemptions applying a public interest balancing test.

constitutional-lawjudicial-accountabilityright-to-informationtransparencyjudicial-independencecollegiumpublic-interestasset-declaration
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1966

Chandra Mohan v State of Uttar Pradesh

All India Reporter 1966 Supreme Court 1987; (1967) 1 Supreme Court Reports 77

District judges may be appointed only from two sources: persons already in the judicial service, meaning a service consisting exclusively of persons intended to fill judicial posts, and advocates of at least seven years standing recommended by the High Court. Consultation with the High Court under Article 233 is mandatory.

constitutional-lawarticle-233article-236district-judgesubordinate-judiciaryarticle-50judicial-serviceseparation-of-powers
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1958

In Re: The Kerala Education Bill, 1957

All India Reporter 1958 Supreme Court 956; (1959) Supreme Court Reports 995

Article 143(1) uses the word 'may', so the Supreme Court has a discretion and is not obliged to answer a reference. It will decline where the questions are vague, political or socio-economic, or where an answer would serve no useful purpose. On the merits, several provisions of the Bill were held inconsistent with the rights of minorities under Article 30.

constitutional-lawarticle-143advisory-jurisdictionarticle-30minority-institutionspresidential-referencediscretion
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1963

In Re: The Sea Customs Act, 1878, Section 20(2)

All India Reporter 1963 Supreme Court 1760; (1964) 3 Supreme Court Reports 787

The mutual tax immunities in Articles 285 and 289 are confined to taxes on property and on income as such. They do not extend to indirect taxes such as customs duty and excise duty, where the taxable event is import or manufacture rather than ownership of property.

constitutional-lawarticle-285article-289article-143tax-immunityindirect-taxcustoms-dutyfinancial-relations
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2016

Jindal Stainless Ltd v State of Haryana

(2017) 12 Supreme Court Cases 1; judgment of 11 November 2016

The concept of compensatory tax has no basis in the Constitution and is discarded. A tax simpliciter is not a restriction on the freedom guaranteed by Article 301. The enquiry in the case of a State tax is whether it discriminates between imported goods and similar goods produced within the State under Article 304(a).

constitutional-lawarticle-301article-304compensatory-taxentry-taxdiscriminationinterstate-tradepart-xiii
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1953

K C Gajapati Narayan Deo v State of Orissa

All India Reporter 1953 Supreme Court 375; (1954) Supreme Court Reports 1

The doctrine of colourable legislation has nothing to do with the bona fides or mala fides of the legislature. The only question is one of competence: whether the legislature, while purporting to act within its power, has in substance transgressed it. If the subject matter is within its competence, the motive for enacting the law is irrelevant.

constitutional-lawcolourable-legislationlegislative-competencemotiveagricultural-income-taxestates-abolitionfraud-on-the-constitution
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

K Krishna Murthy v Union of India

(2010) 7 Supreme Court Cases 202

Articles 243D(6) and 243T(6) are enabling provisions: reservation for backward classes in local bodies is permitted but not constitutionally compelled. Political reservation requires a separate and rigorous empirical inquiry, and the aggregate of reservation for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and backward classes should not exceed fifty per cent of the total seats.

constitutional-lawarticle-243darticle-243treservationbackward-classeslocal-self-governmentfifty-per-cent-ceilingpolitical-reservation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1991

K Veeraswami v Union of India

(1991) 3 Supreme Court Cases 655; All India Reporter 1991 Supreme Court 1954

A Judge of the Supreme Court or of a High Court is a public servant within the Prevention of Corruption Act and may be prosecuted. Article 124(4) provides a mode of removal and confers no immunity from the criminal law. But no criminal case may be registered against such a Judge without prior consultation with and sanction of the Chief Justice of India.

constitutional-lawjudicial-accountabilityarticle-124prevention-of-corruptionpublic-servantsanctionchief-justice-of-india
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2020

Keisham Meghachandra Singh v Hon'ble Speaker, Manipur Legislative Assembly

(2021) 16 Supreme Court Cases 503; judgment of 21 January 2020

A disqualification petition under the Tenth Schedule must be decided by the Speaker within a reasonable period, which absent exceptional circumstances is about three months. The Court also questioned whether the Speaker, being a member of a political party, is the appropriate authority to adjudicate such petitions.

constitutional-lawanti-defectiontenth-schedulespeakerreasonable-periodthree-monthsindependent-tribunaldelay
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1992

Kihoto Hollohan v Zachillhu

(1992) Supplementary (2) Supreme Court Cases 651; All India Reporter 1993 Supreme Court 412

The Tenth Schedule is valid except Paragraph 7, which was struck down for want of ratification under Article 368(2) because it affected the powers of the Supreme Court and the High Courts. The Speaker deciding under Paragraph 6 acts as a tribunal, so the decision is reviewable on narrow grounds and only after it is made.

constitutional-lawanti-defectiontenth-schedulearticle-368ratificationseverabilityspeaker-as-tribunaljudicial-review
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2006

Kishansing Tomar v Municipal Corporation of the City of Ahmedabad

(2006) 8 Supreme Court Cases 352

The requirement that elections to a Municipality or Panchayat be completed before the expiry of its five year term is mandatory. Pending delimitation, administrative difficulty and want of funds or staff are not valid grounds for postponement, and the State Election Commission stands on the same footing as the Election Commission of India.

constitutional-lawarticle-243uarticle-243elocal-self-governmentstate-election-commissionmandatory-electionsmunicipalitiespanchayats
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2006

Kuldip Nayar v Union of India

(2006) 7 Supreme Court Cases 1; All India Reporter 2006 Supreme Court 3127

Article 84 states the qualifications for membership of Parliament exhaustively, and residence in the State represented is not among them. The Council of States is not a purely federal chamber, so deleting the residence requirement does not violate federalism. The open ballot in such elections is valid.

constitutional-lawarticle-80article-84council-of-statesrajya-sabhafederalismbasic-structureopen-ballot
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1979

M Karunanidhi v Union of India

(1979) 3 Supreme Court Cases 431; All India Reporter 1979 Supreme Court 898

Repugnancy under Article 254 requires a direct and irreconcilable conflict between a Union and a State law, such that obedience to one involves disobedience to the other, or an intention on Parliament's part to lay down an exhaustive code occupying the whole field. Where the two operate in different fields or the State law merely supplements the central law, both may stand.

constitutional-lawrepugnancyarticle-254concurrent-listoccupied-fieldlegislative-relationsprevention-of-corruption
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1959

M S M Sharma v Sri Krishna Sinha

All India Reporter 1959 Supreme Court 395; (1959) Supplementary (1) Supreme Court Reports 806

The privileges conferred by Article 194(3), and correspondingly by Article 105(3), are themselves provisions of the Constitution and prevail over the fundamental right in Article 19(1)(a). They do not, however, prevail over Article 21.

constitutional-lawprivilegesarticle-194article-105article-19freedom-of-speechcontempt-of-housesearchlight-case
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1964

Makhan Singh v State of Punjab

All India Reporter 1964 Supreme Court 381; (1964) 4 Supreme Court Reports 797

An order under Article 359 bars only reliance on the rights specified in it. A detenu remains free to raise grounds outside those rights, including that the detention is mala fide, that the authority was not empowered, that the detention falls outside the four corners of the statute, or that the statute is invalid for reasons unconnected with the suspended articles.

constitutional-lawarticle-359emergencypreventive-detentionhabeas-corpusdefence-of-india-actsuspension-of-rights
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1993

Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad v B Karunakar

(1993) 4 Supreme Court Cases 727; All India Reporter 1994 Supreme Court 1074

Where the inquiry officer is a person other than the disciplinary authority, a copy of the inquiry report must be furnished to the delinquent servant before the penalty is decided, as part of the reasonable opportunity under Article 311(2). Relief for non-supply depends on the servant establishing prejudice, and the ordinary course is to remit rather than to quash.

constitutional-lawarticle-311inquiry-reportnatural-justiceprejudicedisciplinary-proceedingsremitservices
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2014

Mohd. Saeed Siddiqui v State of Uttar Pradesh

(2014) 11 Supreme Court Cases 415

The Speaker's certificate that a Bill is a Money Bill is final and conclusive, and the validity of legislative proceedings cannot be questioned on the ground of an irregularity of procedure. The correctness of the certification is therefore not open to judicial review.

constitutional-lawmoney-billarticle-110article-199article-212speakers-certificatenon-justiciability
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1978

Mohinder Singh Gill v Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi

(1978) 1 Supreme Court Cases 405; All India Reporter 1978 Supreme Court 851

Article 324 is a reservoir of power enabling the Election Commission to act where the enacted law is silent, so as to ensure a free and fair election. The power must be exercised consistently with existing law and in conformity with natural justice, and is subject to judicial review. A public order must stand on the reasons it discloses and cannot be supported by fresh reasons supplied later.

constitutional-lawarticle-324election-commissionreservoir-of-powerfree-and-fair-electionsnatural-justicereasonsrepoll
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1968

Mulamchand v State of Madhya Pradesh

All India Reporter 1968 Supreme Court 1218; (1968) 3 Supreme Court Reports 214

Where a contract is void for non-compliance with Article 299, no action lies on the contract and there can be no estoppel or ratification. But the party who has performed may recover the value of the benefit conferred under Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, on a quasi-contractual basis.

constitutional-lawarticle-299government-contractsquasi-contractsection-70restitutionunjust-enrichment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1952

N P Ponnuswami v Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency

All India Reporter 1952 Supreme Court 64; (1952) Supreme Court Reports 218

The word 'election' in Article 329(b) is used in the wide sense of the entire process from the notification calling the election to the declaration of the result. No intermediate step, including the rejection of a nomination paper, may be questioned except by an election petition after the result.

constitutional-lawarticle-329election-petitionnominationwrit-jurisdictionelectionsbar-on-courts
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2016

Nabam Rebia and Bamang Felix v Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly

(2016) 8 Supreme Court Cases 1

Article 163(1) confers no general discretionary power on the Governor. His discretion is confined to functions which the Constitution expressly requires him to exercise in his discretion, or which arise by necessary implication. Summoning, proroguing and dissolving the House under Article 174 must be done on ministerial advice.

constitutional-lawarticle-163article-174article-175governordiscretionstatus-quo-antejudicial-review
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1998

Naga People's Movement of Human Rights v Union of India

(1998) 2 Supreme Court Cases 109; All India Reporter 1998 Supreme Court 431

Entry 2A of the Union List covers the deployment of armed forces of the Union in a State in aid of the civil power. Such deployment does not supplant the State administration: the forces act in aid of the civil power, which continues to function, so there is no imposition of emergency by implication.

constitutional-lawentry-2aarmed-forces-special-powers-actdeploymentpublic-orderadministrative-relationsdisturbed-areasafeguards
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1993

Nilabati Behera v State of Orissa

(1993) 2 Supreme Court Cases 746; All India Reporter 1993 Supreme Court 1960

A claim in public law for compensation for contravention of a fundamental right is distinct from and in addition to the private law remedy in tort. It rests on the State's strict liability for the breach, and the defence of sovereign immunity is inapplicable to it. Articles 32 and 226 include the power to award compensation.

constitutional-lawconstitutional-tortarticle-32article-21custodial-deathsovereign-immunitycompensationpublic-law-remedy
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1958

Parshotam Lal Dhingra v Union of India

All India Reporter 1958 Supreme Court 36; (1958) Supreme Court Reports 828

Article 311(2) applies only where the action amounts to punishment. The two indicia of punishment are whether the servant had a right to hold the post, and whether the order visits him with evil consequences or casts a stigma. Misconduct which is merely the motive for an order is distinguished from misconduct which is its foundation.

constitutional-lawarticle-311article-310reduction-in-ranktermination-simpliciterstigmamotive-and-foundationprobationer
Read case brief
Supreme Court of Calcutta1861

Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Co v Secretary of State for India

(1861) 5 Bombay High Court Reports Appendix 1

The East India Company had a dual character. No action lies against the Government for acts done in the exercise of sovereign powers, but the Government is liable for acts done in the conduct of undertakings which might be carried on by private persons without sovereign authority.

constitutional-lawstate-liabilitysovereign-immunityarticle-300vicarious-liabilitysovereign-and-non-sovereigndual-character
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1962

Purushothaman Nambudiri v State of Kerala

All India Reporter 1962 Supreme Court 694; (1962) Supplementary (1) Supreme Court Reports 753

Once a Bill has been passed by the House and submitted for assent, the legislative process so far as the House is concerned is complete, and the Bill does not lapse on a subsequent dissolution of the Assembly. The Constitution prescribes no time limit within which assent must be given under Article 200 or Article 201.

constitutional-lawarticle-200article-201assentdissolutionstate-legislaturelapse-of-bills
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2007

Raja Ram Pal v Hon'ble Speaker, Lok Sabha

(2007) 3 Supreme Court Cases 184

Article 105(3) carries an inherent power in each House to punish for contempt, including by expulsion of a member. The exercise of that power is subject to judicial review, but only on limited grounds. Article 122 excludes review for irregularity of procedure, not for substantive illegality.

constitutional-lawprivilegesarticle-105article-122expulsioncontempt-of-housejudicial-reviewnatural-justice
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2007

Rajendra Singh Rana v Swami Prasad Maurya

(2007) 4 Supreme Court Cases 270; All India Reporter 2007 Supreme Court 1305

The question of disqualification under the Tenth Schedule must be determined as at the date of the act of defection. A Speaker who fails to decide a pending disqualification petition and instead acts on a later claim of split abdicates his jurisdiction, and that failure is itself correctable by the courts.

constitutional-lawanti-defectiontenth-schedulesplitspeakerdelayabdication-of-jurisdictionjudicial-review
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1979

Ramana Dayaram Shetty v International Airport Authority of India

(1979) 3 Supreme Court Cases 489; All India Reporter 1979 Supreme Court 1628

The State and its instrumentalities must act fairly and without arbitrariness or discrimination in awarding contracts and conferring benefits. Having laid down a standard or norm for eligibility, the State is bound to adhere to it and cannot depart from it in an individual case.

constitutional-lawarticle-14government-contractstenderarbitrarinessinstrumentality-of-stateeligibility-criteriapublic-largesse
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2006

Rameshwar Prasad v Union of India

(2006) 2 Supreme Court Cases 1; All India Reporter 2006 Supreme Court 980

A Governor's report founding action under Article 356 cannot rest on surmise, conjecture or apprehension. He is not a constitutional guardian of political morality, and post-election realignment among parties is not by itself illegitimate. Dissolution of an Assembly on such a report is unconstitutional.

constitutional-lawarticle-356governordissolutionpresidents-rulehorse-tradingjudicial-reviewsuspended-animation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1994

Ravi S Naik v Union of India

1994 Supplementary (2) Supreme Court Cases 641; All India Reporter 1994 Supreme Court 1558

The expression 'voluntarily gives up his membership' in Paragraph 2(1)(a) of the Tenth Schedule has a wider connotation than resignation. In the absence of a formal resignation, the conclusion that a member has voluntarily given up his membership may be drawn from his conduct.

constitutional-lawanti-defectiontenth-schedulevoluntarily-giving-upconductdisqualificationspeaker
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2020

Rojer Mathew v South Indian Bank Ltd

(2020) 6 Supreme Court Cases 1

Whether a Bill answers the definition of a Money Bill in Article 110 is a question of constitutional interpretation, and the finality of the Speaker's certificate is not settled. The question was referred to a larger Bench, doubting Mohd. Saeed Siddiqui. Rules restructuring tribunals were struck down for excessive delegation.

constitutional-lawmoney-billarticle-110tribunalsexcessive-delegationfinance-act-2017judicial-review
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

Sajjan Singh v State of Rajasthan

All India Reporter 1965 Supreme Court 845; (1965) 1 Supreme Court Reports 933

Shankari Prasad was affirmed, so a constitutional amendment is not 'law' within Article 13 and fundamental rights are amenable to amendment. An effect on Article 226 which is merely incidental is not a 'change in' that Chapter, so no ratification is required under the proviso to Article 368(2).

constitutional-lawarticle-368article-13amendmentninth-scheduleratificationincidental-effectbasic-features
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1974

Samsher Singh v State of Punjab

(1974) 2 Supreme Court Cases 831; All India Reporter 1974 Supreme Court 2192

The President and the Governor are constitutional or formal heads of the executive. They exercise their powers and functions on the aid and advice of their Council of Ministers, save in a few well known exceptional situations, and the satisfaction required by the Constitution is that of the Council of Ministers and not their personal satisfaction.

constitutional-lawarticle-74article-163article-77article-166constitutional-headaid-and-advicesatisfaction
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2005

Sarbananda Sonowal v Union of India

(2005) 5 Supreme Court Cases 665; All India Reporter 2005 Supreme Court 2920

Large scale illegal influx of persons into a State can amount to external aggression within Article 355, which casts an enforceable duty on the Union to protect every State against it. A law which by reversing the ordinary burden of proof makes detection of illegal migrants practically impossible is a failure to discharge that duty and is unconstitutional.

constitutional-lawarticle-355external-aggressionillegal-migrationburden-of-proofadministrative-relationsforeigners-act
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2024

Sita Soren v Union of India

(2024) 5 Supreme Court Cases 629; 2024 SCC OnLine SC 229; judgment of 4 March 2024

The immunity in Articles 105(2) and 194(2) for anything said or any vote given does not extend to the acceptance of a bribe. The offence is complete on acceptance of the illegal gratification, independently of whether the legislator afterwards speaks or votes as agreed. P V Narasimha Rao v State (1998) overruled.

constitutional-lawprivilegesarticle-105article-194briberyimmunityoverrulingprevention-of-corruption
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1964

Special Reference No. 1 of 1964 (Keshav Singh's case)

All India Reporter 1965 Supreme Court 745; (1965) 1 Supreme Court Reports 413

A House of the legislature may punish for contempt, but the existence and extent of a claimed privilege is justiciable. A House is not a court of record, so its general warrant does not enjoy the immunity of a warrant of the House of Commons. A person committed for contempt may invoke Article 226, and the House cannot punish a Judge for the discharge of his judicial functions.

constitutional-lawprivilegesarticle-194article-143article-226contempt-of-housekeshav-singhjudicial-power
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1998

Special Reference No. 1 of 1998 (Third Judges case)

(1998) 7 Supreme Court Cases 739; All India Reporter 1999 Supreme Court 1

The Chief Justice of India must form his opinion in consultation with a collegium of the four senior-most Judges of the Supreme Court for appointments to that Court, and the two senior-most for appointments to and transfers from the High Courts. An opinion formed without such consultation is not binding on the Government.

constitutional-lawarticle-124article-217article-222article-143collegiumthird-judges-casejudicial-appointments
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2000

State of Bihar v Bal Mukund Sah

(2000) 4 Supreme Court Cases 640; All India Reporter 2000 Supreme Court 1296

Articles 233 and 234 constitute a special and self-contained scheme for recruitment to the judicial service, requiring the participation of the High Court. A general State law on recruitment to public services cannot displace that scheme, so reservation in the judicial service must be effected through rules framed in consultation with the High Court.

constitutional-lawarticle-233article-234judicial-servicereservationspecial-schemehigh-court-consultationsubordinate-judiciary
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1951

State of Bombay v F N Balsara

All India Reporter 1951 Supreme Court 318; (1951) Supreme Court Reports 682

In determining legislative competence the court looks to the pith and substance of the enactment, that is its true nature and character. If the law in substance falls within the enacting legislature's field, an incidental encroachment on a forbidden field does not invalidate it.

constitutional-lawpith-and-substancelegislative-competenceseventh-scheduleseverabilityprohibitionincidental-encroachment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

State of Bombay v R M D Chamarbaugwala

All India Reporter 1957 Supreme Court 699; (1957) Supreme Court Reports 874

A State law is not invalid for affecting persons or property outside the State if there is a sufficient territorial nexus between the State and the subject matter. Two conditions must be satisfied: the connection must be real and not illusory, and the liability sought to be imposed must be pertinent to that connection.

constitutional-lawterritorial-nexusarticle-245extra-territorial-operationprize-competitionlegislative-competenceseverability
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1977

State of Rajasthan v Union of India

(1977) 3 Supreme Court Cases 592; All India Reporter 1977 Supreme Court 1361

The satisfaction of the President under Article 356 is subjective and largely political, and was held reviewable only in the narrowest circumstances, such as where the action rested on wholly extraneous considerations or was mala fide. The decision has since been substantially superseded by S R Bommai.

constitutional-lawarticle-356presidents-rulearticle-131subjective-satisfactionjusticiabilitydissolution
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

State of Uttar Pradesh v Manbodhan Lal Srivastava

All India Reporter 1957 Supreme Court 912; (1958) Supreme Court Reports 533

The requirement of consultation with the Public Service Commission in Article 320(3) is directory and not mandatory. It confers no right on a public servant, and failure to consult the Commission does not by itself invalidate disciplinary action taken against him.

constitutional-lawarticle-320public-service-commissiondirectoryconsultationdisciplinary-proceedingsservices
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1963

State of West Bengal v Union of India

All India Reporter 1963 Supreme Court 1241; (1964) 1 Supreme Court Reports 371

The Indian Constitution is not federal in the classical sense. It is not the result of a compact between sovereign units, and the States have no independent sovereign existence. Parliament is competent to legislate for the acquisition of property belonging to a State, and a suit under Article 131 requires a dispute involving a legal right.

constitutional-lawarticle-131federalismquasi-federalunitary-biasacquisition-of-state-propertyoriginal-jurisdiction
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2015

Supreme Court Advocates on Record Association v Union of India (Fourth Judges case, National Judicial Appointments Commission)

(2016) 5 Supreme Court Cases 1; judgment of 16 October 2015

Primacy of the judiciary in the appointment of Judges is an element of the independence of the judiciary, which is part of the basic structure. The Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014 and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014 were struck down, and the collegium revived.

constitutional-lawnjacarticle-124aarticle-368basic-structurejudicial-independencecollegiumfourth-judges-case
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1993

Supreme Court Advocates on Record Association v Union of India (Second Judges case)

(1993) 4 Supreme Court Cases 441; All India Reporter 1994 Supreme Court 268

In the matter of appointment of Judges, 'consultation' in Articles 124(2) and 217(1) means concurrence, and the opinion of the Chief Justice of India has primacy. The Chief Justice must form that opinion in consultation with his senior colleagues, which is the origin of the collegium. S P Gupta overruled on this point.

constitutional-lawarticle-124article-217article-222collegiumjudicial-appointmentsjudicial-independencesecond-judges-case
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1998

Supreme Court Bar Association v Union of India

(1998) 4 Supreme Court Cases 409; All India Reporter 1998 Supreme Court 1895

Article 142 confers a power of wide amplitude to do complete justice between parties, but it cannot be used to supplant substantive law or to ignore express statutory provisions dealing with the subject. The Court cannot exercise a jurisdiction which a statute vests exclusively in another authority.

constitutional-lawarticle-142article-129complete-justicecontemptadvocates-actlimits-of-power
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1995

T N Seshan v Union of India

(1995) 4 Supreme Court Cases 611

A multi-member Election Commission is consistent with Article 324(2). The Chief Election Commissioner is not superior in authority to the other Election Commissioners and they are not subordinate to him; his position under Article 324(3) is that of Chairman, and business is transacted by unanimity or by majority.

constitutional-lawarticle-324election-commissionmulti-memberchief-election-commissionerchairmanremovalindependence
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1971

U N R Rao v Smt Indira Gandhi

(1971) 2 Supreme Court Cases 63; All India Reporter 1971 Supreme Court 1002

Article 74(1) is mandatory. There must at all times be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at its head to aid and advise the President, and the Council does not cease to hold office on the dissolution of the House of the People.

constitutional-lawarticle-74article-75council-of-ministersdissolutionprime-ministerresponsible-government
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2002

Union of India v Association for Democratic Reforms

(2002) 5 Supreme Court Cases 294; All India Reporter 2002 Supreme Court 2112

The right of a voter to know the antecedents of a candidate is part of the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a). Since Article 324 is a reservoir of power operating where the law is silent, the Election Commission may require candidates to disclose criminal cases, assets and liabilities, and educational qualifications.

constitutional-lawarticle-324article-19right-to-knowelection-commissiondisclosurecandidate-antecedentsfree-and-fair-elections
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1972

Union of India v H S Dhillon

(1971) 2 Supreme Court Cases 779; All India Reporter 1972 Supreme Court 1061

Legislative competence of Parliament is tested by first asking whether the subject falls within the State List. If it does not, Parliament is competent by virtue of Article 248 read with Entry 97 of the Union List, whether or not any specific Union entry covers it. Taxes on the capital value of assets are distinct from taxes on lands and buildings.

constitutional-lawresiduary-powerarticle-248entry-97wealth-taxlegislative-competenceagricultural-landfinancial-relations
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2022

Union of India v Mohit Minerals Pvt Ltd

(2022) 10 Supreme Court Cases 700; judgment of 19 May 2022

Article 246A confers simultaneous legislative power on the Union and the States over goods and services tax. The Goods and Services Tax Council under Article 279A is a deliberative body whose recommendations have persuasive value only and are not binding on the Union or the States.

constitutional-lawarticle-246aarticle-279agst-councilcooperative-federalismfiscal-federalismsimultaneous-powerfinancial-relations
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1977

Union of India v Sankalchand Himatlal Sheth

(1977) 4 Supreme Court Cases 193; All India Reporter 1977 Supreme Court 2328

The consent of a Judge is not required for a transfer under Article 222, but the power may be exercised only in the public interest and never by way of punishment. The consultation with the Chief Justice of India must be full and effective, meaning that he must have all relevant material and a real opportunity to form an informed view.

constitutional-lawarticle-222transfer-of-judgesjudicial-independenceeffective-consultationpublic-interesthigh-court
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1985

Union of India v Tulsiram Patel

(1985) 3 Supreme Court Cases 398; All India Reporter 1985 Supreme Court 1416

Where a proviso to Article 311(2) is validly invoked, the inquiry and with it the right to a hearing are excluded by the Constitution itself, and natural justice cannot be pleaded to restore them. But the satisfaction must rest on relevant material and be reached in good faith, and despite Article 311(3) it remains open to judicial review for mala fides, absence of material or extraneous grounds.

constitutional-lawarticle-311provisosnatural-justicenot-reasonably-practicablejudicial-review42nd-amendmentdismissal
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2021

Vikas Kishanrao Gawali v State of Maharashtra

(2021) 6 Supreme Court Cases 73

Reservation of seats for backward classes in local bodies must satisfy a triple test: a dedicated Commission must conduct a contemporaneous empirical inquiry, the State must specify the proportion in the light of its recommendations, and the aggregate reservation with Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes must not exceed fifty per cent.

constitutional-lawarticle-243darticle-243ttriple-testreservationbackward-classeslocal-self-governmentempirical-inquiry
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1981

Waman Rao v Union of India

(1981) 2 Supreme Court Cases 362; All India Reporter 1981 Supreme Court 271

The basic structure doctrine applies to constitutional amendments made after 24 April 1973, the date of Kesavananda Bharati. Amendments made before that date, and laws placed in the Ninth Schedule before it, are immune from challenge on basic structure grounds.

constitutional-lawbasic-structurearticle-31aarticle-31cninth-scheduleprospective-application24-april-1973land-reform
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1998

Whirlpool Corporation v Registrar of Trade Marks, Mumbai

(1998) 8 Supreme Court Cases 1; All India Reporter 1999 Supreme Court 22

The existence of an alternative statutory remedy is not an absolute bar to a petition under Article 226. The rule requiring its exhaustion is one of self-imposed restraint and discretion, and three exceptions are recognised: enforcement of a fundamental right, violation of natural justice, and want of jurisdiction or a challenge to vires.

constitutional-lawarticle-226alternative-remedywrit-jurisdictionnatural-justiceviresself-imposed-restraint
Read case brief