Company Law case briefs

59 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Company Law notes.

59 briefs in Company Law
Oudh Chief Court1946

Anand Bihari Lal v Dinshaw & Co

AIR 1946 Oudh 408

The Turquand rule does not protect a person who has knowledge of the irregularity or where circumstances are suspicious enough to put a reasonable person on inquiry

indoor-managementturquand-ruleexceptionsuspicious-circumstancesindian-law
Read case brief
House of Lords1875

Ashbury Railway Carriage & Iron Co v Riche

(1875) LR 7 House of Lords 653

An act beyond the objects clause of the memorandum is ultra vires the company, void ab initio, and incapable of ratification even by unanimous shareholders

ultra-viresmemorandumobjects-clausevoidratification
Read case brief
House of Lords1880

Attorney General v Great Eastern Railway Co

(1880) 5 Appeal Cases 473

A company has implied power to do everything fairly incidental to or consequential upon its expressly stated objects; the doctrine of ultra vires should not be applied unreasonably to destroy the useful transactions of a company.

ultra-viresincidental-powersancillary-powersobjects-clauseimplied-powers
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1971

Bajaj Auto Ltd v NK Firodia

AIR 1971 Supreme Court 321

The Board of Directors' refusal to register a transfer of shares must be exercised bona fide, in the interest of the company, and within a reasonable time; arbitrary or mala fide refusal is invalid.

transfer-of-sharesboard-powersbona-fideregistration-refusal
Read case brief
House of Lords1893

Balkis Consolidated Co Ltd v Tomkinson

[1893] Appeal Cases 396

A company that issues a share certificate is estopped from denying the truth of statements therein against persons who acted on the faith of the certificate

share-certificateestoppelprima-facie-evidencebona-fide-purchaser
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1966

Barium Chemicals Ltd v Company Law Board

AIR 1966 Supreme Court 1648

The Central Government's power to order investigation of a company must be exercised on a reasonable basis; the satisfaction of the government must be objective and not based on mere suspicion.

investigationcentral-governmentobjective-satisfactionreasonable-basisjudicial-review
Read case brief
Chancery Division1901

Borland's Trustee v Steel Brothers & Co Ltd

[1901] 1 Chancery 279

A share is not a sum of money but an interest measured by a sum of money: a bundle of rights including the right to dividend, vote, and surplus assets on winding up

sharesnature-of-sharebundle-of-rightsmembershipchose-in-action
Read case brief
Court of Chancery1742

Charitable Corporation v Sutton

(1742) 2 Atk 400

Directors are in the nature of trustees for the company; they are liable for breach of trust if they misapply or negligently handle corporate property

directorstrusteesfiduciary-dutybreach-of-trusthistorical
Read case brief
House of Lords1937

Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Crossman

[1937] Appeal Cases 26

The value of shares for estate duty purposes includes all rights attached to them under the Articles of Association, including restrictions on transfer; shares represent a bundle of rights.

sharesvaluationbundle-of-rightsAOA-restrictions
Read case brief
House of Lords1860

Cox v Hickman

(1860) 8 House of Lords Cases 268

Sharing of profits is not conclusive evidence of partnership; the true test is whether there is mutual agency between the parties

partnershipprofit-sharingmutual-agencydistinction-from-company
Read case brief
House of Lords1889

Derry v Peek

(1889) 14 Appeal Cases 337

Fraud requires knowledge of falsehood or recklessness; honest belief in truth, even if unreasonable, negates fraud.

fraudmisrepresentationhonest-beliefmens-reaprospectus
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1954

Dhakeswari Cotton Mills Ltd v Commissioner of Income Tax

AIR 1954 Supreme Court 564

Adequate notice and a reasonable opportunity of being heard must be given before an adverse order is passed; the principles of natural justice apply to quasi-judicial proceedings affecting corporate entities.

natural-justicenoticeopportunityquasi-judicialprocedural-fairness
Read case brief
Chancery Division1900

Dixon v Kennaway & Co

[1900] 1 Chancery 833

A company is estopped from making calls on shares that have been certified as fully paid; the share certificate operates as a representation upon which holders are entitled to rely

share-certificateestoppelcallsfully-paid-shares
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1963

Dr. A. Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar v Life Insurance Corporation of India

AIR 1963 Supreme Court 1185

An act of a company beyond the objects stated in its Memorandum of Association is ultra vires the COMPANY: void ab initio, and incapable of ratification even by unanimous shareholder resolution. A benefit only indirectly or remotely connected to the company's stated objects does not count as incidental to those objects. Directors (or others) responsible for causing such a void payment to be made are personally liable to restore it.

ultra-viresmemorandum-of-associationvoid-ab-initiono-ratificationpersonal-liabilitylife-insurance-corporation-act
Read case brief
House of Lords1973

Ebrahimi v Westbourne Galleries Ltd

[1973] Appeal Cases 360

In quasi-partnership companies, the court may order winding up on the 'just and equitable' ground where there has been a breach of the equitable considerations (legitimate expectations) superimposed upon the strict legal rights.

winding-upjust-and-equitablequasi-partnershiplegitimate-expectationsequitable-considerations
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1950

Edwards v Halliwell

[1950] 2 All ER 1064

Four exceptions to the rule in Foss v Harbottle: (1) ultra vires or illegal acts; (2) acts requiring special majority passed by simple majority; (3) fraud on the minority where wrongdoers control the company; (4) infringement of individual membership rights.

minority-rightsexceptionsFoss-v-Harbottleultra-viresfraud-on-minoritypersonal-rights
Read case brief
House of Lords1878

Erlanger v New Sombrero Phosphate Co

(1878) 3 Appeal Cases 1218

A promoter stands in fiduciary relation to the company and must disclose all material facts including personal profit to an independent board

promoterfiduciary-dutysecret-profitdisclosureindependent-board
Read case brief
Court of Appeal in Chancery1866

Ferguson v Wilson

(1866) LR 2 Chancery App 77

Directors are agents of the company and stand in a fiduciary relationship to it; they must act within their authority and in the company's interest.

directorsagencyfiduciary-relationshipcompany-management
Read case brief
Court of Chancery1843

Foss v Harbottle

(1843) 2 Hare 461

The proper plaintiff for wrongs done to a company is the company itself (acting through its majority); individual members cannot sue for corporate wrongs

majority-ruleproper-plaintiffcorporate-wrongsminority-rightsfoundational
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1933

Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne

[1933] Chancery 935

The corporate veil will be lifted where a company is formed as a mere cloak or sham to evade a contractual obligation such as a non-compete covenant

lifting-the-veilsham-companynon-competefraud-evasion
Read case brief
House of Lords1900

Gluckstein v Barnes

[1900] Appeal Cases 240

Promoters must disclose ALL profits connected with the company's formation; partial disclosure is insufficient; duty extends to every profit, not just the final sale

promoterfiduciary-dutysecret-profitfull-disclosurepartial-disclosure
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1890

Henderson v Bank of Australasia

(1890) 45 Chancery D 330

A defective notice of a general meeting vitiates any resolution passed thereat; procedural compliance with notice requirements is essential for the validity of corporate acts.

meetingsnoticeresolutionprocedural-compliancevalidity
Read case brief
Securities Appellate Tribunal / SEBI1998

Hindustan Lever Ltd v SEBI

SAT Appeal No.15/2001 (originally 1998 SEBI order)

A company can be an 'insider' if its officers possess UPSI; company's trade is attributed to those officers' knowledge; merger information is classic UPSI

insider-tradingUPSIcompany-as-insidermergerSEBI
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2006

Jay Engineering Works Ltd v Industry Facilitation Council

(2006) 8 SCC 677

An award under the Interest on Delayed Payments to Small Scale and Ancillary Industrial Undertakings Act, 1993 cannot be executed against a sick company without BIFR consent where the debt falls within a sanctioned scheme; S.22 SICA bars enforcement, though adjudication may proceed.

company-lawSICAsection-22BIFRinterest-on-delayed-paymentssmall-industries
Read case brief
Chancery Division1962

Jones v Lipman

[1962] 1 Weekly Law Reports 832

The corporate veil will be lifted to grant specific performance where a person transfers property to a company he controls in order to defeat the purchaser's equitable interest

lifting-the-veilspecific-performancealter-egosham-device
Read case brief
House of Lords1924

Jubilee Cotton Mills v Lewis

[1924] Appeal Cases 958

The Certificate of Incorporation is conclusive evidence that all requirements of the Act have been complied with; cannot be challenged on procedural grounds after issue

incorporationcertificateconclusive-evidenceirrebuttableregistration
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1940

Knightsbridge Estates Trust Ltd v Byrne

[1940] Appeal Cases 613

The equitable doctrine of clog on the equity of redemption does not apply to company debentures; a 40-year repayment term in a company mortgage is valid

debenturesclog-on-redemptioncompany-borrowinglong-term-mortgage
Read case brief
Privy Council1961

Lee v Lee's Air Farming Ltd

[1961] Appeal Cases 12

A person who is the controlling shareholder and governing director of a company can also be an employee of that company

separate-legal-entityone-man-companyemployee-directordual-capacity
Read case brief
House of Lords1925

Macaura v Northern Assurance Co Ltd

[1925] Appeal Cases 619

A shareholder, even a sole shareholder, has no insurable interest in the company's property because company property belongs to the company, not to shareholders

separate-entityinsurable-interestcompany-propertyshareholder-rights
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1997

Miheer H Mafatlal v Mafatlal Industries Ltd

AIR 1997 Supreme Court 506

The court's role in sanctioning a scheme of arrangement is limited to ensuring fairness, lawfulness, and that the class was fairly represented; commercial wisdom of the majority prevails over judicial second-guessing

scheme-of-arrangementNCLTcourt-sanctioncommercial-wisdommajority-creditors
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1954

Newborne v Sensolid (Great Britain) Ltd

[1954] 1 Queen's Bench 45

A contract signed by a promoter solely as 'agent' of a non-existent company is a nullity; no principal exists, so no agency exists, and no one is bound

pre-incorporation-contractnullityagentpromoterno-principal
Read case brief
House of Lords1892

Ooregum Gold Mining Co of India v Roper

[1892] Appeal Cases 125

Shares cannot be issued at a discount to their nominal (par) value; the capital represented by shares must be maintained intact for the protection of creditors

share-capitaldiscount-sharescapital-maintenancepar-value
Read case brief
House of Lords1873

Peek v Gurney

(1873) LR 6 House of Lords 377

Only persons who subscribed DIRECTLY on the faith of the prospectus can sue for misstatement; subsequent market purchasers cannot.

prospectusmisstatementreliancesecondary-marketprivity
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1953

Ram Kissendas Dhanuka v Satya Charan Law

AIR 1953 Supreme Court 365

An undischarged insolvent is automatically disqualified from holding office as director; the office is vacated by operation of law without requiring any formal removal.

directorsdisqualificationinsolvencyvacation-of-office
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1925

Re City Equitable Fire Insurance Co

[1925] Chancery 407

Directors are required to show a degree of skill reasonably expected from persons of their knowledge and experience; they are entitled to trust officers and delegate unless grounds for suspicion exist.

directorsduty-of-carestandard-of-skilldelegationtrust-in-officers
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1896

Re Kingston Cotton Mill Co (No 2)

[1896] 2 Chancery 279

An auditor is a watchdog, not a bloodhound; he is not bound to approach his work with suspicion or to be a detective unless the circumstances are such as to arouse suspicion.

auditorwatchdogbloodhoundduty-of-caresuspicionstandard-of-skill
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1895

Re London and General Bank (No 2)

[1895] 2 Chancery 673

An auditor's duty is to report to shareholders, not merely to directors; the auditor must form an independent opinion and report any matter that shareholders ought to know.

auditorduty-to-reportshareholdersindependent-opinionaccounts
Read case brief
House of Lords1967

Regal (Hastings) Ltd v Gulliver

[1967] 2 Appeal Cases 134

Directors must account for any profit made by virtue of their position; the no-profit rule is strict and applies irrespective of whether the company could have obtained the profit itself or suffered any loss.

directorsfiduciary-dutyno-profit-ruleaccountabilitycorporate-opportunity
Read case brief
Court of Criminal Appeal1932

Rex v Kylsant

[1932] 1 King's Bench 442

A half-truth that creates a false impression is as much an untrue statement as a direct lie; misleading omission in a prospectus amounts to misstatement

prospectusmisstatementhalf-truthmisleading-omissioncriminal-liability
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer Chamber1856

Royal British Bank v Turquand

(1856) 6 E&B 327; 119 English Reports 886

Persons dealing with a company are entitled to presume that its internal regulations have been duly observed (Doctrine of Indoor Management)

indoor-managementconstructive-noticeturquand-rulethird-party-protection
Read case brief
House of Lords1897

Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd

[1897] Appeal Cases 22

Upon valid incorporation, a company is a separate legal person distinct from its members, even if one person holds virtually all shares

separate-legal-entitycorporate-personalityone-man-companylimited-liabilityfoundational
Read case brief
House of Lords1959

Scottish Cooperative Wholesale Society v Meyer

[1959] Appeal Cases 324

Conduct that is burdensome, harsh, and wrongful to minority shareholders, using majority power to benefit the majority at minority's expense, constitutes oppression

oppressionminority-protectiondiversion-of-businesssubsidiarybuyout
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

Shanti Prasad Jain v Kalinga Tubes Ltd

AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1535

Oppression requires a continuous course of oppressive conduct; isolated acts are insufficient unless of sufficient gravity; test is whether conduct is 'burdensome, harsh, and wrongful'

oppressioncontinuous-conductminority-protectionS241threshold
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1983

Shree Shakti Mills Ltd v CIT

AIR 1983 Supreme Court 1039

Transfer of shares is complete only upon registration: entry of transferee's name in the register of members; mere execution of transfer deed is insufficient

share-transferregistrationcompletionregister-of-memberstitle
Read case brief
Court of King's Bench1612

Sutton's Hospital Case

(1612) 10 Co Rep 1a; 77 English Reports 960

A corporation is an invisible, immortal, and artificial person created by charter, possessing legal personality distinct from its members

corporate-personalitycharterincorporationhistorical
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2019

Swiss Ribbons Pvt Ltd v Union of India

(2019) 4 Supreme Court Cases 17

IBC is constitutionally valid; distinction between financial and operational creditors is rational; financial creditor dominance in CoC is justified

IBCconstitutional-validityfinancial-creditoroperational-creditorCoCinsolvency
Read case brief