Allen v Gold Reefs of West Africa Ltd
[1900] 1 Chancery 656
The power to alter articles must be exercised bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole
Read case brief59 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Company Law notes.
[1900] 1 Chancery 656
The power to alter articles must be exercised bona fide for the benefit of the company as a whole
Read case briefAIR 1946 Oudh 408
The Turquand rule does not protect a person who has knowledge of the irregularity or where circumstances are suspicious enough to put a reasonable person on inquiry
Read case brief(1875) LR 7 House of Lords 653
An act beyond the objects clause of the memorandum is ultra vires the company, void ab initio, and incapable of ratification even by unanimous shareholders
Read case brief(1880) 5 Appeal Cases 473
A company has implied power to do everything fairly incidental to or consequential upon its expressly stated objects; the doctrine of ultra vires should not be applied unreasonably to destroy the useful transactions of a company.
Read case briefAIR 1970 Gujarat 90
Non-registration of charge renders it void against liquidator and other creditors; the debt survives but the security is lost
Read case briefAIR 1971 Supreme Court 321
The Board of Directors' refusal to register a transfer of shares must be exercised bona fide, in the interest of the company, and within a reasonable time; arbitrary or mala fide refusal is invalid.
Read case brief[1893] Appeal Cases 396
A company that issues a share certificate is estopped from denying the truth of statements therein against persons who acted on the faith of the certificate
Read case briefAIR 1966 Supreme Court 1648
The Central Government's power to order investigation of a company must be exercised on a reasonable basis; the satisfaction of the government must be objective and not based on mere suspicion.
Read case brief[1901] 1 Chancery 279
A share is not a sum of money but an interest measured by a sum of money: a bundle of rights including the right to dividend, vote, and surplus assets on winding up
Read case brief(1742) 2 Atk 400
Directors are in the nature of trustees for the company; they are liable for breach of trust if they misapply or negligently handle corporate property
Read case brief[1937] Appeal Cases 26
The value of shares for estate duty purposes includes all rights attached to them under the Articles of Association, including restrictions on transfer; shares represent a bundle of rights.
Read case briefAIR 1983 Supreme Court 1272
Ultra vires acts of a company are void and the doctrine of constructive notice applies to the memorandum of association
Read case brief(1860) 8 House of Lords Cases 268
Sharing of profits is not conclusive evidence of partnership; the true test is whether there is mutual agency between the parties
Read case brief[1916] 2 Appeal Cases 307
The corporate veil may be lifted to determine the enemy character of a company during wartime by examining who controls it
Read case brief1996 INSC 619
The corporate form cannot be used as a cloak for fraud; courts will look behind it to the persons in control.
Read case brief(1996) 4 Supreme Court Cases 622
The corporate veil may be lifted where the corporate form is used to obtain benefits that the controller would not be entitled to in his individual capacity
Read case brief(1889) 14 Appeal Cases 337
Fraud requires knowledge of falsehood or recklessness; honest belief in truth, even if unreasonable, negates fraud.
Read case briefAIR 1954 Supreme Court 564
Adequate notice and a reasonable opportunity of being heard must be given before an adverse order is passed; the principles of natural justice apply to quasi-judicial proceedings affecting corporate entities.
Read case brief[1900] 1 Chancery 833
A company is estopped from making calls on shares that have been certified as fully paid; the share certificate operates as a representation upon which holders are entitled to rely
Read case briefAIR 1963 Supreme Court 1185
An act of a company beyond the objects stated in its Memorandum of Association is ultra vires the COMPANY: void ab initio, and incapable of ratification even by unanimous shareholder resolution. A benefit only indirectly or remotely connected to the company's stated objects does not count as incidental to those objects. Directors (or others) responsible for causing such a void payment to be made are personally liable to restore it.
Read case brief[1973] Appeal Cases 360
In quasi-partnership companies, the court may order winding up on the 'just and equitable' ground where there has been a breach of the equitable considerations (legitimate expectations) superimposed upon the strict legal rights.
Read case brief[1950] 2 All ER 1064
Four exceptions to the rule in Foss v Harbottle: (1) ultra vires or illegal acts; (2) acts requiring special majority passed by simple majority; (3) fraud on the minority where wrongdoers control the company; (4) infringement of individual membership rights.
Read case brief(1876) 1 Exchequer D 88
The articles of association do not confer enforceable rights on outsiders or on members in a non-member capacity
Read case brief(1878) 3 Appeal Cases 1218
A promoter stands in fiduciary relation to the company and must disclose all material facts including personal profit to an independent board
Read case brief(1866) LR 2 Chancery App 77
Directors are agents of the company and stand in a fiduciary relationship to it; they must act within their authority and in the company's interest.
Read case brief(1843) 2 Hare 461
The proper plaintiff for wrongs done to a company is the company itself (acting through its majority); individual members cannot sue for corporate wrongs
Read case brief[1933] Chancery 935
The corporate veil will be lifted where a company is formed as a mere cloak or sham to evade a contractual obligation such as a non-compete covenant
Read case brief[1900] Appeal Cases 240
Promoters must disclose ALL profits connected with the company's formation; partial disclosure is insufficient; duty extends to every profit, not just the final sale
Read case brief(1890) 45 Chancery D 330
A defective notice of a general meeting vitiates any resolution passed thereat; procedural compliance with notice requirements is essential for the validity of corporate acts.
Read case brief[1915] 1 Chancery 881
The articles of association constitute a contract between the company and its members, and between the members inter se, binding them in their capacity as members
Read case briefSAT Appeal No.15/2001 (originally 1998 SEBI order)
A company can be an 'insider' if its officers possess UPSI; company's trade is attributed to those officers' knowledge; merger information is classic UPSI
Read case brief(2006) 8 SCC 677
An award under the Interest on Delayed Payments to Small Scale and Ancillary Industrial Undertakings Act, 1993 cannot be executed against a sick company without BIFR consent where the debt falls within a sanctioned scheme; S.22 SICA bars enforcement, though adjudication may proceed.
Read case brief[1962] 1 Weekly Law Reports 832
The corporate veil will be lifted to grant specific performance where a person transfers property to a company he controls in order to defeat the purchaser's equitable interest
Read case brief[1924] Appeal Cases 958
The Certificate of Incorporation is conclusive evidence that all requirements of the Act have been complied with; cannot be challenged on procedural grounds after issue
Read case brief[1940] Appeal Cases 613
The equitable doctrine of clog on the equity of redemption does not apply to company debentures; a 40-year repayment term in a company mortgage is valid
Read case brief[1961] Appeal Cases 12
A person who is the controlling shareholder and governing director of a company can also be an employee of that company
Read case briefAIR 1986 Supreme Court 1370
The corporate veil may be lifted where the corporate entity is used as a device for fraud, improper conduct, or to defeat public interest
Read case brief[1925] Appeal Cases 619
A shareholder, even a sole shareholder, has no insurable interest in the company's property because company property belongs to the company, not to shareholders
Read case briefAIR 1997 Supreme Court 506
The court's role in sanctioning a scheme of arrangement is limited to ensuring fairness, lawfulness, and that the class was fairly represented; commercial wisdom of the majority prevails over judicial second-guessing
Read case brief[1904] Appeal Cases 120
A company cannot ratify a pre-incorporation contract because no principal existed at the time the contract was made; ratification requires a principal in existence at the time of the agent's act
Read case briefAIR 1981 Supreme Court 1298
A private company which is a subsidiary of a public company is deemed to be a public company under the Companies Act and its articles restricting transfer of shares are overridden
Read case brief[1954] 1 Queen's Bench 45
A contract signed by a promoter solely as 'agent' of a non-existent company is a nullity; no principal exists, so no agency exists, and no one is bound
Read case brief[1892] Appeal Cases 125
Shares cannot be issued at a discount to their nominal (par) value; the capital represented by shares must be maintained intact for the protection of creditors
Read case brief(1873) LR 6 House of Lords 377
Only persons who subscribed DIRECTLY on the faith of the prospectus can sue for misstatement; subsequent market purchasers cannot.
Read case briefAIR 1953 Supreme Court 365
An undischarged insolvent is automatically disqualified from holding office as director; the office is vacated by operation of law without requiring any formal removal.
Read case brief[1925] Chancery 407
Directors are required to show a degree of skill reasonably expected from persons of their knowledge and experience; they are entitled to trust officers and delegate unless grounds for suspicion exist.
Read case brief[1896] 2 Chancery 279
An auditor is a watchdog, not a bloodhound; he is not bound to approach his work with suspicion or to be a detective unless the circumstances are such as to arouse suspicion.
Read case brief[1895] 2 Chancery 673
An auditor's duty is to report to shareholders, not merely to directors; the auditor must form an independent opinion and report any matter that shareholders ought to know.
Read case brief[1967] 2 Appeal Cases 134
Directors must account for any profit made by virtue of their position; the no-profit rule is strict and applies irrespective of whether the company could have obtained the profit itself or suffered any loss.
Read case brief[1932] 1 King's Bench 442
A half-truth that creates a false impression is as much an untrue statement as a direct lie; misleading omission in a prospectus amounts to misstatement
Read case brief(1856) 6 E&B 327; 119 English Reports 886
Persons dealing with a company are entitled to presume that its internal regulations have been duly observed (Doctrine of Indoor Management)
Read case brief[1897] Appeal Cases 22
Upon valid incorporation, a company is a separate legal person distinct from its members, even if one person holds virtually all shares
Read case brief[1959] Appeal Cases 324
Conduct that is burdensome, harsh, and wrongful to minority shareholders, using majority power to benefit the majority at minority's expense, constitutes oppression
Read case briefAIR 1965 Supreme Court 1535
Oppression requires a continuous course of oppressive conduct; isolated acts are insufficient unless of sufficient gravity; test is whether conduct is 'burdensome, harsh, and wrongful'
Read case briefAIR 1983 Supreme Court 1039
Transfer of shares is complete only upon registration: entry of transferee's name in the register of members; mere execution of transfer deed is insufficient
Read case brief(1612) 10 Co Rep 1a; 77 English Reports 960
A corporation is an invisible, immortal, and artificial person created by charter, possessing legal personality distinct from its members
Read case brief(2019) 4 Supreme Court Cases 17
IBC is constitutionally valid; distinction between financial and operational creditors is rational; financial creditor dominance in CoC is justified
Read case briefAIR 1965 Supreme Court 40
A company, being a juristic person and citizen under certain provisions, can invoke fundamental rights under Articles 14, 19(1)(f) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution
Read case brief(1880) 5 Queen's Bench Division 109
A promoter occupies a fiduciary position towards the company and is accountable for any secret profit made
Read case briefTry another term, or search all cases.