Law of Taxation case briefs

39 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Law of Taxation notes.

39 briefs in Law of Taxation
Supreme Court of India1958

Badridas Daga v CIT

(1958) 34 Income Tax Reports 10 (SC)

Losses arising from embezzlement by an employee or agent are deductible under s. 10(1) as a loss incidental to the carrying on of the business, provided no prohibition in the Act.

taxation-lawtrading-lossembezzlementsection-10incidental-to-business
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1981

Bhagwan Dass Jain v Union of India

AIR 1981 Supreme Court 1364

The power to tax is subject to constitutional limitations; a tax must be authorized by law and cannot be levied arbitrarily.

taxation-lawconstitutional-basisarticle-265no-tax-without-authority
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1959

Calcutta Co. Ltd v. CIT, West Bengal

AIR 1959 SC 1165; (1960) 1 SCR 185; 37 ITR 1 (SC)

Under the mercantile system of accounting, a liability the assessee has contractually undertaken (e.g. to develop land sold, at its own future cost) is an accrued liability deductible under S.10(1) in the year of sale, even though the money has not yet been spent — provided the estimate accords with accepted commercial/accounting practice.

taxationPGBPmercantile-accountingaccrued-liabilitysection-10-1deduction
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1975

CIT (Central), Delhi v. Harprasad and Co Pvt Ltd

AIR 1975 SC 1282; (1975) 3 SCR 696; 99 ITR 118

A capital loss arising in a year when capital gains were not chargeable to tax at all (S.12B was withdrawn for gains between 1-4-1948 and 31-3-1956) cannot be carried forward and set off under S.24(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922 — such a loss falls outside \"total income\" and the carry-forward machinery, which exists solely to set a loss off against future chargeable profits.

taxation-lawcapital-losscarry-forwardsection-24section-12Bchargeability
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2017

CIT v Balbir Singh Maini

(2017) 8 Supreme Court Cases 522

A 'Joint Development Agreement' does not amount to 'transfer' under S.2(47) unless possession is handed over under S.53A of the TPA.

taxation-lawcapital-gainstransferjoint-development-agreement
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2009

CIT v Eli Lilly and Co

(2009) 15 Supreme Court Cases 1

Employer's contribution to an overseas social security scheme for expatriate employees is allowable as business expenditure.

taxation-lawbusiness-expendituresocial-securityallowable-deduction
Read case brief
Privy Council1932

CIT v Shaw Wallace and Co

AIR 1932 PC 138; (1932) 59 IA 206; (1932) 6 ITC 178

Compensation received for the loss/termination of a managing agency (loss of the business/office itself) is a capital receipt, not taxable income, even though the agency commission itself would have been income; income bears its ordinary commercial meaning — a periodic return from a definite, continuing source.

taxation-lawcapital-vs-incomemanaging-agencycompensationdefinition-of-income
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1980

CIT v Smt. P.K. Kochammu Amma

AIR 1980 Supreme Court 2124; (1981) 1 SCC 241

Income of a spouse or minor child includible under s.64(1) is part of the assessee's income to be returned under s.139; but omitting it was not concealment under s.271(1)(c) where the prescribed return form before 31 March 1972 had no column for it.

taxation-lawclubbingsection-64penaltyconcealmentsection-271
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1981

CIT v. BC Srinivasa Setty

(1981) 128 Income Tax Reports 294 (SC)

Where cost of acquisition of a capital asset is indeterminate, the computation machinery fails and capital gains cannot be charged.

taxationcapital-gainscost-of-acquisitionself-generated-goodwillcomputation-failure
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

CIT v. Raja Benoy Kumar Sahas Roy

AIR 1957 Supreme Court 768

Agriculture requires basic operations (tilling, sowing, planting) on land; spontaneous growth without human effort is not agriculture.

taxationagricultural-incomebasic-operationsdefinition-of-agriculture
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1973

CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd

(1973) 88 Income Tax Reports 192 (SC)

In cases of ambiguity in a taxing statute, the interpretation favourable to the assessee must be adopted.

taxationinterpretationambiguityassessee-favourable-constructionstrict-interpretation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1960

CIT, Bombay City v. Nandlal Gandalal

AIR 1960 SC 1147; (1960) 3 SCR 620; 40 ITR 1

For an HUF's residence under S.4A(b) of the 1922 Act, \"control and management\" means de facto control and management, not merely the right or power to control; a business a coparcener runs in partnership with strangers is not necessarily an \"affair\" of the family merely because family funds financed it, even if the income from it belongs to the family.

taxation-lawhuf-residencesection-4Acontrol-and-managementcoparcener
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2009

CIT, Delhi v. Atul Mohan Bindal

(2009) 9 SCC 589; 317 ITR 1 (SC)

Penalty under S.271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act is a civil liability, not criminal or quasi-criminal — albeit a strict one — so mens rea / willful concealment is not an essential ingredient for imposing it (following Dharamendra Textile Processors, and holding Dilip N. Shroff no longer good law). The conditions stated in S.271(1)(c) must still, as a matter of fact, exist before the penalty can be imposed.

taxation-lawpenaltysection-271-1-cmens-rea-not-requiredcivil-liabilitystrict-liability
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1970

CIT, Punjab v. Kulu Valley Transport Co (P) Ltd

AIR 1970 SC 1734; (1971) 1 SCR 452; (1970) 2 SCC 192; 77 ITR 518

A loss return filed voluntarily under S.22(3) of the 1922 Act, after the general S.22(1) notice period has expired but before assessment, is nonetheless a valid return; the Income-tax Officer must determine the loss shown and it is eligible for carry-forward under S.24(2) — a return is valid \"at any time before the assessment is made.\"

taxation-lawloss-returncarry-forwardsection-22section-24filing-of-returns
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1950

Commissioner of Agricultural Income-tax, Bengal v. Keshab Chandra Mandal

AIR 1950 SC 265; 1950 SCR 435

A statutory return requiring an individual's signature cannot validly be signed by an agent on his behalf (the common-law agency maxim qui facit per alium facit per se is excluded) — signature or a mark must involve physical contact between the person and the mark affixed; a return signed by the assessee's son in the assessee's name, with no such contact, is not properly signed.

taxation-lawagricultural-income-taxvalid-signatureagency-excludedbengal-act
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2007

DIT v Morgan Stanley and Co

(2007) 7 Supreme Court Cases 1

Transfer pricing: a foreign enterprise is not liable to tax in India if the Indian subsidiary has been adequately compensated at arm's length.

taxation-lawtransfer-pricingarms-lengthpermanent-establishment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1979

Gestetner Duplicators v CIT

(1979) 117 ITR 1 (Supreme Court)

For depreciation, the asset must be 'used' for the purpose of business; passive ownership without actual use does not qualify.

taxation-lawprovident-fundmeaning-of-salarysection-36-1-ivfourth-schedulecommission
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2003

GKN Driveshafts (India) Ltd v. ITO

(2003) 259 Income Tax Reports 19 (SC)

When S.148 notice is issued, the assessee must file return, raise objections, and AO must pass a speaking order on objections before proceeding with reassessment.

taxationreassessmentsection-148natural-justiceobjectionsspeaking-order
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2006

Goetze India v CIT

(2006) 284 ITR 323 (Supreme Court)

A claim not made in the return cannot be entertained by the AO during assessment proceedings; it must be made by filing a revised return.

taxation-lawrevised-returnclaimassessment-proceedings
Read case brief
Privy Council1935

Gopal Saran Narain Singh v CIT

AIR 1935 Privy Council 159

Income from letting of property is taxable under 'Income from House Property' and not as 'Business Income' even if the owner is in the business of letting.

taxation-lawlettinghouse-propertyhead-of-income
Read case brief
Andhra Pradesh High Court2011

GVK Industries v. ITO

(2011) 332 Income Tax Reports 130 (AP)

Retrospective tax legislation must satisfy the test of reasonableness under Art.14 and Art.265; confiscatory or impossible-compliance retrospective taxation may be struck down.

taxationconstitutional-lawarticle-265retrospective-taxationreasonableness
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2007

Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages v. CIT

(2007) 293 Income Tax Reports 226 (SC)

If the deductee has paid tax on the income, the deductor cannot be treated as assessee in default for non-deduction of TDS.

taxationTDSassessee-in-defaultsection-201deductor-liability
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1972

Hindustan Steel Ltd v. State of Orissa

(1972) 83 Income Tax Reports 26 (SC)

Penalty should not be imposed merely because it is lawful to do so; where breach is technical or bona fide, penalty may be declined.

taxationpenaltydiscretionbona-fidetechnical-breachdeterrent
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2000

Kunhayammed v State of Kerala

(2000) 6 Supreme Court Cases 359

An SLP does not automatically stay the operation of the High Court order; the interim order continues unless specifically stayed.

taxation-lawslpstayinterim-orderappellate-procedure
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2022

Mohit Minerals Pvt Ltd v. Union of India

(2022) 2 Supreme Court Cases 1

GST Council recommendations are not binding on Parliament/State Legislatures but have persuasive value; IGST on ocean freight in CIF imports amounts to double taxation.

taxationGSTcooperative-federalismGST-councilIGSTocean-freightdouble-taxation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

Navnit Lal Javeri v K.K. Sen

AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1375

The deemed dividend provision (S.2(22)(e)) applies only to shareholders; a non-shareholder receiving a loan from a company is not covered.

taxation-lawdeemed-dividendsection-2-22-eshareholder
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1965

Parimisetti Seetharamamma v CIT

(1965) 57 ITR 532 (Supreme Court)

Residential status under S.6 is determined for each assessment year independently; previous years' status is irrelevant.

taxation-lawresidential-statussection-6assessment-year
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2007

Rajesh Jhaveri Stock Brokers v CIT

(2007) 5 Supreme Court Cases 785

For reopening assessment under S.147, the AO needs only 'reason to believe'; at the stage of issuing notice, the sufficiency of reasons is not to be tested.

taxation-lawreopeningsection-147reason-to-believe
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1972

Ram Prashad v CIT

(1972) 86 ITR 122 (Supreme Court)

Remuneration received by a director from a company in which substantial shares are held is taxable under 'Salary' if there is an employer-employee relationship.

taxation-lawdirectorsalaryemployer-employee
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1964

Sultan Brothers v CIT

(1964) 51 ITR 353 (Supreme Court)

Whether income from letting out property is 'Income from House Property' or 'Business Income' depends on the intention: if letting is the business, it may still be House Property income.

taxation-lawletting-as-businesshead-of-incomehouse-property
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1997

Tuticorin Alkali Chemicals v CIT

(1997) 227 ITR 172 (Supreme Court)

Interest earned on surplus funds deposited for a short period during setting up of business is assessable as 'Income from Other Sources' and not as a capital receipt.

taxation-lawinterestsurplus-fundspre-commencementother-sources
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2003

Union of India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan

(2003) 263 Income Tax Reports 706 (SC)

Treaty shopping through Mauritius is legitimate; a valid Tax Residency Certificate issued by Mauritius government is conclusive proof of residence for DTAA benefits.

taxationDTAAtreaty-shoppingMauritiusTRCdouble-taxation-reliefsection-90
Read case brief