Public International Law case briefs

42 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Public International Law notes.

42 briefs in Public International Law
Judicial Committee of the Privy Council1937

AG Canada v. AG Ontario (Labour Conventions Case)

[1937] Appeal Cases 326

The power to implement treaties in domestic law follows the division of legislative powers in the constitution. In a federal state, the central government cannot legislate on matters within provincial/state competence merely because it has entered a treaty on that subject.

treaty-implementationfederal-statedualismlegislative-competenceILO-conventions
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1951

Anglo-Norwegian Fisheries Case (UK v. Norway)

ICJ Reports 1951, p. 116

(1) The baseline for measuring territorial waters may follow the general direction of the coast using straight baselines where the coastline is deeply indented. (2) The 10-mile rule for bays is not a rule of general international law. (3) Economic interests of the coastal population may be considered in delimitation.

law-of-seastraight-baselinesterritorial-watersindented-coastlinefisheries
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1950

Asylum Case (Colombia v Peru)

ICJ Reports 1950, p 266

Regional custom requires constant and uniform usage accepted as law by the states concerned; the burden of proof lies on the state invoking the custom.

PILregional-customdiplomatic-asylumopinio-jurisburden-of-proof
Read case brief
House of Lords1967

Carl Zeiss Stiftung v. Rayner and Keeler Ltd

[1967] 1 Appeal Cases 853

Courts may recognise the acts of an unrecognised government as valid if that government acts as a subordinate or agent of a recognised sovereign state. The "agency theory" allows circumventing non-recognition where practical necessity demands.

recognitionagency-theoryunrecognised-governmenteast-germanypractical-necessity
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1962

Certain Expenses of the United Nations (Advisory Opinion)

ICJ Advisory Opinion [1962] ICJ Rep 151

The General Assembly has competence to authorise peacekeeping operations; their costs are expenses of the Organisation binding on all member states under Article 17(2) of the United Nations Charter.

PILunited-nationspeacekeepinggeneral-assemblyarticle-17
Read case brief
Permanent Court of International Justice1928

Chorzow Factory Case (Germany v. Poland)

PCIJ Series A, No. 17 (1928)

(1) Reparation must wipe out all consequences of the illegal act and restore the status quo ante. (2) The essential principle is that reparation must, as far as possible, put the injured party in the position it would have been in had the wrongful act not occurred.

state-responsibilityreparationrestitutiondamagesstatus-quo-ante
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1949

Corfu Channel Case (UK v. Albania)

ICJ Reports 1949, p. 4

(1) Every state has an obligation not to knowingly allow its territory to be used for acts contrary to the rights of other states. (2) Right of innocent passage through international straits cannot be denied. (3) Circumstantial evidence is admissible in international adjudication.

state-responsibilityinnocent-passageinternational-straitscircumstantial-evidenceterritorial-sovereignty
Read case brief
Diplomatic Settlement (Liability Convention 1972)1978

Cosmos 954 Incident (Canada v Union of Soviet Socialist Republics)

Protocol between Canada and the USSR on Settlement of Canada's Claim for Damages Caused by Cosmos 954, 2 April 1981, CTS 1981 No. 8

Absolute liability under Article II of the Convention on International Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects (1972) applies without proof of fault for damage caused by a space object on the earth's surface. The 1981 Canada-USSR settlement itself did not concede or make any finding on liability — it is evidence of a negotiated compensation payment, not a legal admission.

PILspace-lawabsolute-liabilityliability-conventionnuclear
Read case brief
German-Polish Mixed Arbitral Tribunal1929

Deutsche Continental Gas-Gesellschaft v. Polish State

(1929) 5 Annual Digest 11

A state exists in international law when it possesses: (1) a defined territory, (2) a permanent population, (3) an effective government, and (4) capacity to enter into relations with other states. These four criteria constitute the declaratory test of statehood.

statehoodfour-criteriadeclaratory-theoryterritorypopulationgovernmentcapacity
Read case brief
House of Lords1924

Duff Development Co v Government of Kelantan

[1924] Appeal Cases 797

A certificate from the Crown as to the status of a foreign sovereign is conclusive evidence binding on English courts; courts cannot go behind the executive's position on recognition.

PILrecognitionsovereign-immunityexecutive-certificate
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1997

Gabcikovo-Nagymaros Project (Hungary v Slovakia)

ICJ Reports 1997, p 7

A party cannot unilaterally terminate a treaty on grounds of necessity or fundamental change of circumstances unless strict customary law conditions are met; the treaty continues unless lawfully terminated.

PILtreatiesterminationnecessityrebus-sic-stantibusenvironment
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division1891

In re Castioni

[1891] 1 Queen's Bench 149

A "political offence" for purposes of extradition exemption requires that the act was incidental to and formed part of a political disturbance. Not every crime with a political motive qualifies; there must be a direct nexus between the crime and a genuine political uprising.

extraditionpolitical-offence-exceptionpolitical-disturbancenexus-test
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division1894

In re Meunier

[1894] 2 Queen's Bench 415

Indiscriminate anarchist violence directed against society as a whole does not qualify as a political offence; the exception requires two contending parties struggling for political power.

PILextraditionpolitical-offence-exceptionanarchismterrorism
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1980

Jolly George Verghese v. Bank of Cochin

AIR 1980 Supreme Court 470

Civil imprisonment for non-payment of a decree debt must be reconciled with Article 21 and Article 11 of the ICCPR. Mere inability to pay is not dishonest avoidance; arrest is permissible only where the judgment-debtor has the means to pay but wilfully refuses or has acted in bad faith.

CPCexecutioncivil-imprisonmentarrestarticle-21ICCPRsection-51order-XXI
Read case brief
Permanent Court of International Justice1933

Legal Status of Eastern Greenland (Denmark v Norway)

PCIJ Series A/B No 53 (1933)

A claim to sovereignty requires intention and will to act as sovereign together with actual exercise of authority; in thinly populated or uninhabited territories, modest acts of administration suffice.

PILterritorial-sovereigntyeffective-occupationunilateral-declarationIhlen-Declaration
Read case brief
Permanent Court of Arbitration1956

Lighthouse Case (France v Greece)

23 Indian Law Reports 81 (1956)

Localised treaty obligations attached to specific territory pass automatically to the successor state, regardless of the clean slate principle applicable to other treaties.

PILstate-successionlocalised-obligationsclean-slateVCST
Read case brief
Court of Appeal1921

Luther v. Sagor

[1921] 3 King's Bench 532

Once a government is recognised by the executive (Crown), the courts must accept its acts as valid sovereign acts. Recognition is conclusive and courts cannot go behind it. Acts of an unrecognised government have no legal effect in domestic courts.

recognitionsovereign-actsexecutive-certificateunrecognised-governmentact-of-state
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1987

MC Mehta v. Union of India (Oleum Gas Leak)

AIR 1987 Supreme Court 1086

An enterprise engaged in inherently dangerous activity is absolutely liable for harm caused, with no exceptions (no act of God, no third-party defence, no consent). Compensation must be proportionate to the magnitude and financial capacity of the enterprise.

absolute-liabilityoleum-gasshriram-industrieshazardous-activityart-21compensation
Read case brief
Italian-United States Conciliation Commission1955

Merge Claim (United States of America v Italy)

(1955) 14 RIAA 236

Where a person holds dual nationality, the state of dominant and effective nationality prevails for diplomatic protection purposes; the other state of nationality cannot be the respondent.

PILdual-nationalitydiplomatic-protectioneffective-nationalitygenuine-link
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1953

Minquiers and Ecrehos Case (France v United Kingdom)

ICJ Reports 1953, p 47

When both parties rely on ancient historical title, the court prefers the party demonstrating actual exercise of effective sovereignty in modern times through administrative and judicial acts.

PILterritorial-sovereigntyeffective-administrationhistorical-title
Read case brief
US-Mexico General Claims Commission1926

Neer Claim (USA v. Mexico)

4 RIAA 60 (1926)

Established the "international minimum standard" for treatment of aliens. A state is responsible for injury to an alien only if the treatment amounts to an "outrage, bad faith, wilful neglect of duty, or insufficiency of governmental action so far short of international standards.

state-responsibilitytreatment-of-aliensinternational-minimum-standarddenial-of-justice
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1955

Nottebohm Case (Liechtenstein v Guatemala)

ICJ Reports 1955, p 4

For diplomatic protection, there must be a genuine and effective link between the national and the protecting state; nationality of convenience acquired without real connection cannot be opposed to third states.

PILnationalitygenuine-linkdiplomatic-protectionnationality-of-convenience
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1997

People's Union for Civil Liberties v Union of India

(1997) 3 Supreme Court Cases 433

Unratified international human rights instruments (such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights) can serve as interpretive aids for construing fundamental rights under the Indian Constitution.

PILtransformationICCPRinterpretive-aidArticle-21privacy
Read case brief
International Criminal Court (Trial Chamber I)2012

Prosecutor v. Thomas Lubanga Dyilo

ICC-01/04-01/06 (2012)

Conscripting and enlisting children under 15 and using them in hostilities is a war crime under Article 8(2)(e)(vii) of the Rome Statute; first ICC conviction

ICCrome-statutechild-soldierswar-crimesindividual-criminal-responsibilityfirst-conviction
Read case brief
Court for Crown Cases Reserved1876

R v Keyn (The Franconia)

(1876) 2 Exchequer D 63

International law does not automatically form part of English domestic law; customary international law requires adoption or incorporation by Parliament or judicial decision before it is enforceable domestically.

PILincorporationtransformationterritorial-seadomestic-application
Read case brief
International Court of Justice1951

Reservations to the Genocide Convention (Advisory Opinion)

ICJ Reports 1951, p. 15

A state may make a reservation to a multilateral treaty provided the reservation is compatible with the object and purpose of the treaty. Incompatible reservations render the reserving state not a party vis-a-vis objecting states.

reservationstreatiesobject-and-purpose-testgenocide-conventionadvisory-opinion
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1982

S.P. Gupta v. Union of India

AIR 1982 Supreme Court 149

Right to know is part of Art.19(1)(a); open government is the norm; locus standi liberalized for PIL

administrative-lawright-to-informationPILlocus-standiart-19transparency
Read case brief
Permanent Court of International Justice1927

The SS Lotus Case (France v Turkey)

PCIJ Series A No 10 (1927)

In international law, whatever is not expressly prohibited is permitted; states retain sovereign freedom of action unless a specific rule of international law restricts it.

PILsovereigntyjurisdictionlotus-principlepermissive-rule
Read case brief
Court of King's Bench1764

Triquet v Bath

(1764) 3 Burr 1478

Customary international law is part of the common law of England and is directly enforceable in domestic courts without the need for specific legislation (incorporation doctrine/Blackstone's doctrine).

PILincorporationBlackstonediplomatic-immunitycommon-law
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1997

Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan

AIR 1997 Supreme Court 3011

Unratified international conventions can be used as interpretive aids to fill gaps in domestic law where no contrary legislation exists

international-law-municipal-lawCEDAWsexual-harassmentunratified-treatiesvishaka-guidelinesPILgap-filling
Read case brief
King's Bench Division1905

West Rand Central Gold Mining Co v R

[1905] 2 King's Bench 391

International law forms part of English law only insofar as it has been recognised and adopted by English courts; unincorporated international obligations do not automatically bind the Crown.

PILincorporationtransformationadoptiondomestic-application
Read case brief