Interpretation of Statutes case briefs

44 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Interpretation of Statutes notes.

44 briefs in Interpretation of Statutes
Queen's Bench Divisional Court1964

Adler v. George

[1964] 2 Queen's Bench 7

Golden Rule applied to extend "in the vicinity of" to include within a prohibited place, avoiding the absurdity of punishing lesser interference while ignoring greater interference inside.

golden-rulein-the-vicinity-ofprohibited-placeofficial-secretsabsurd-result
Read case brief
House of Lords1957

Attorney-General v. Prince Ernest Augustus of Hanover

[1957] Appeal Cases 436

The long title of an Act is part of the Act and may be used as an aid to interpretation. However, where the enacting words are clear and unambiguous, neither the long title nor the preamble can restrict or qualify them.

long-titleinternal-aidspreambleclear-wordslegislative-intent
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1959

Bhinka and Others v. Charan Singh

AIR 1959 Supreme Court 960; 1959 SCR Supl. (2) 798

The case's primary holding is that a provisional possession order under S.145 CrPC confers no title and cannot be used to resist an ejectment suit under S.180 of the U.P. Tenancy Act, 1939 grounded on title. In the course of that reasoning the Court also held, as a secondary point, that a section heading is a legitimate internal aid that may dispel ambiguity (though the Court found none here) -- it cannot control plain words, but may explain ambiguous ones (quoting Maxwell, Interpretation of Statutes, 10th ed., p.50).

headingschapter-titlesinternal-aidsgeneral-driftambiguitysection-145-crpcsection-180-ut-act
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1961

Burrakur Coal Co. v. Union of India

AIR 1961 SC 954

The Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957, applies to unworked land, including dormant collieries. The restrictions in ss.4 and 5 are not unreasonable and do not contravene Art. 19(1)(g).

coal-bearing-areasunworked-landdormant-minesart-19preamble
Read case brief
King's Bench Division1921

Cape Brandy Syndicate v. IRC

[1921] 1 King's Bench 64

Courts must interpret statutes according to the intent of Parliament as expressed in the words used. If the words are clear, no external purpose can override them.

literal-ruleintent-of-parliamentplain-meaningtaxation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2003

CIT v. Hindustan Bulk Carriers

(2003) 3 Supreme Court Cases 57

Harmonious construction applied to resolve conflict between two provisions of the Income Tax Act. Neither provision should be rendered redundant; both must be given effect.

harmonious-constructionconflict-between-provisionsincome-taxboth-given-effect
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1966

CIT v. Shahzada Nand and Sons

AIR 1966 Supreme Court 1342

In a taxing statute, the court cannot supply casus omissus (a case omitted). If the Legislature has failed to cover a particular case, the court cannot extend the charging provision by implication to cover it. The subject is free of tax unless clearly within the letter of the law.

taxing-statutecasus-omissusstrict-constructionno-implicationcharging-section
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1973

CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd

(1973) 88 Income Tax Reports 192 (SC)

In cases of ambiguity in a taxing statute, the interpretation favourable to the assessee must be adopted.

taxationinterpretationambiguityassessee-favourable-constructionstrict-interpretation
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1888

Colquhoun v. Brooks

(1888) 21 Queen's Bench Division 52

The ejusdem generis rule requires that the specific words forming the genus must constitute a distinct category or class. If the specific words do not share a common genus, the general words following them receive their full natural meaning without restriction.

ejusdem-generisgenusspecific-wordsgeneral-wordsno-common-category
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1983

D.S. Nakara v. Union of India

AIR 1983 Supreme Court 130

Beneficial construction combined with Article 14 prohibits arbitrary exclusion of persons clearly within the protected class of a welfare scheme

beneficial-constructionarticle-14pensionwelfare-legislationarbitrary-classification
Read case brief
House of Lords1980

Duport Steels Ltd. v. Sirs

[1980] 1 Weekly Law Reports 142

The role of the judiciary is to interpret and apply the law as enacted by Parliament, not to legislate. Where Parliament has spoken clearly, the court must give effect to the words used even if the result appears unjust or unwise. Judicial activism cannot substitute for Parliamentary amendment.

judicial-restraintseparation-of-powersparliamentary-sovereigntyclear-wordsrole-of-judiciary
Read case brief
House of Lords1952

East End Dwellings Co. Ltd. v. Finsbury Borough Council

[1952] Appeal Cases 109

When a statute creates a legal fiction (by use of words "shall be deemed"), the court must carry the fiction to its logical conclusion but not beyond the purpose for which the fiction was created.

legal-fictiondeemedlogical-conclusionscope-limitationstatutory-construction
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division1961

Fisher v. Bell

[1961] 1 Queen's Bench 394

Literal Rule applied strictly. Display of goods in a shop window is an invitation to treat, not an "offer for sale." Shopkeeper acquitted of offering a flick-knife for sale.

literal-ruleoffer-for-saleinvitation-to-treatflick-knifestrict-construction
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1957

Garikapati Veeraya v. N. Subbiah Choudhry

AIR 1957 Supreme Court 540

The right of appeal is a substantive right, not merely a procedural one. It vests in a litigant on the date the suit is instituted. A subsequent amendment taking away the right cannot operate retrospectively unless expressly provided.

right-of-appealvested-rightsubstantive-rightretrospectiveno-retrospective-deprivation
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer1874

Gorris v. Scott

(1874) LR 9 Exchequer 125

Where a statute is enacted for a specific purpose (preventing spread of disease), breach of that statute does not give a cause of action for a loss (sheep washed overboard) unrelated to the mischief the statute was designed to prevent.

mischief-rulestatutory-purposecausationcontagious-diseasessheep
Read case brief
House of Lords1857

Grey v. Pearson

(1857) 6 House of Lords Cases 61

Origin of the Golden Rule. Lord Wensleydale's formulation: ordinary meaning prevails unless it leads to absurdity, repugnance, or inconsistency, in which case the grammatical meaning may be modified to avoid such result.

golden-ruleoriginlord-wensleydaleabsurdityrepugnancemodification
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1971

Harihar Prasad v. State of Bihar

(1972) 3 SCC 89

The Court held that the accused had conspired to misappropriate government money by giving contracts and making advances without following the financial rules and without proper approvals.

criminal-conspiracycriminal-breach-of-trustpublic-servantunauthorised-contracts
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1584

Heydon's Case

(1584) 76 English Reports 637

The Mischief Rule requires courts to consider what defect the statute was enacted to remedy, and interpret the statute to suppress that mischief and advance the remedy

mischief-rulepurposive-interpretationfour-questionsstatutory-interpretation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1972

Hukam Chand v. Union of India

AIR 1972 Supreme Court 2427

Delegated legislation (rules made under a statute) cannot go beyond the scope of the enabling Act. A power to make procedural rules does not include the power to alter substantive rights created by the parent Act. Subordinate legislation ultra vires the parent statute is void.

delegated-legislationultra-viresprocedural-rulessubstantive-rightsenabling-act
Read case brief
House of Lords1965

Inland Revenue Commissioners v. Frere

[1965] Appeal Cases 402

Where a word appears in different sections of the same statute, there is a presumption of uniform meaning (same word, same meaning throughout). However, this presumption yields where the context clearly requires a different meaning in different sections.

uniform-meaningsame-wordcontextinternal-aidspresumption
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2000

Kolhapur Canesugar Works Ltd. v. Union of India

(2000) 2 Supreme Court Cases 536

A repeal of a statute does not revive the statute that was repealed by the repealed statute (no revival by implication). Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 preserves rights accrued and liabilities incurred under the repealed statute.

repealsection-6-GCAno-revivalpending-proceedingsvested-rightssavings-clause
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division1898

Kruse v. Johnson

[1898] 2 Queen's Bench 91

Bye-laws and subordinate legislation are presumed valid and will not be struck down unless they are manifestly unreasonable, partial or unequal in operation, repugnant to the general law, or ultra vires the parent statute.

subordinate-legislationbye-lawsreasonablenessultra-viresvalidity-test
Read case brief
House of Lords1946

London and North Eastern Railway Co. v. Berriman

[1946] Appeal Cases 278

"Relaying or repairing" the permanent way does not include routine maintenance (oiling points). Literal Rule applied strictly to deny compensation for a worker killed during maintenance work.

literal-rulerelaying-repairingmaintenancerailwaycompensation-denied
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division (England)1875

Muir v Keay

(1875) LR 10 QB 594

Noscitur a sociis: a word takes its meaning from the words around it.

Read case brief
House of Lords1993

Pepper v. Hart

[1993] Appeal Cases 593

Courts may refer to Hansard (Parliamentary debates) as an aid to statutory interpretation where legislation is ambiguous, the material relied on consists of clear ministerial statements, and it would prevent injustice.

external-aidshansardparliamentary-debatesambiguityministerial-statement
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1953

Poppatlal Shah v. State of Madras

AIR 1953 SC 274

A sale is taxable under the Madras General Sales Tax Act only if the property in the goods passes within the Province. A contract concluded in Madras does not, by itself, make a sale completed outside the Province a sale 'in the Province of Madras'. The title and preamble of the Act may be used as aids to ascertain that territorial design.

sales-taxsitus-of-saleterritorial-nexustitlepreambleinternal-aids
Read case brief
House of Lords1899

Powell v. Kempton Park

[1899] Appeal Cases 143

Ejusdem generis applied. "Other place" restricted to indoor locations when preceded by "house, office, room" (all indoor spaces). An outdoor enclosure was not ejusdem generis.

ejusdem-generisliteral-ruleplaceoutdoorbetting
Read case brief
Court for Crown Cases Reserved1872

R v. Allen

(1872) LR 1 CCR 367

Golden Rule applied to narrow "marry" to mean "going through a ceremony of marriage" rather than "contract a valid marriage," avoiding the absurdity of making bigamy impossible to commit.

golden-rulebigamynarrow-constructionabsurd-resultmarry
Read case brief
Chancery Division1935

Re Sigsworth

[1935] Chancery 89

Golden Rule applied to read in words not present in the statute, preventing a murderer from inheriting on intestacy from the person he killed.

golden-rulereading-in-wordsrepugnant-resultinheritancemurderer
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division1960

Smith v. Hughes

[1960] 1 Weekly Law Reports 830

Mischief Rule applied. Prostitutes soliciting from balconies and windows held to be soliciting "in a street" because the mischief was harassment of passersby, regardless of physical location.

mischief-rulesolicitingstreetpurposiveharassment
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1958

Sri Venkataramana Devaru v. State of Mysore

AIR 1958 Supreme Court 255

Harmonious construction of constitutional provisions requires the specific provision to qualify the general; both continue to operate in their respective spheres

harmonious-constructionconstitutional-interpretationarticle-25article-26article-17temple-entryspecific-vs-general
Read case brief
House of Lords1844

Sussex Peerage Case

(1844) 11 Cl & Fin 85; 8 English Reports 1034

Literal Rule: clear and unambiguous words must be given their plain grammatical meaning regardless of consequences.

literal-ruleplain-meaningroyal-marriages-actclear-words
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1887

Tuck & Sons v. Priester

(1887) 19 Queen's Bench Division 629

Penal provisions are construed strictly: if there is a reasonable interpretation of a penal section which will avoid the penalty in a particular case, the court must adopt it.

strict-constructionpenal-statutespenaltycopyright
Read case brief
Queen's Bench1868

Whiteley v. Chappell

(1868) LR 4 Queen's Bench 147

Literal Rule applied strictly. Impersonating a dead person to vote was not "personating any person entitled to vote" because a dead person is not "entitled to vote.

literal-ruleabsurd-resultvoting-frauddead-personstrict-construction
Read case brief