Amar Nath Sehgal v. Union of India
2005 (30) PTC 253 (Del)
Moral rights under Section 57 survive assignment and protect against destruction of artwork
Read case brief45 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Intellectual Property Law notes.
2005 (30) PTC 253 (Del)
Moral rights under Section 57 survive assignment and protect against destruction of artwork
Read case briefAIR 1963 Supreme Court 449
Test for deceptive similarity: overall impression on average consumer with imperfect recollection; marks compared as whole, not dissected
Read case brief2002 (25) PTC 1 (Del)
A detailed, developed concept shared in confidence can be protected even though a bare idea cannot.
Read case brief[1976] Chancery 55
Court may grant an ex parte order permitting the plaintiff to enter the defendant's premises to inspect and remove documents/articles that constitute evidence of infringement, where there is a real risk of destruction of evidence. This is the "Anton Piller Order" (now called a "search order").
Read case brief2009 (40) PTC 589 (Mad)
In patent infringement suits, the doctrine of equivalents applies in India. A product infringes if it performs substantially the same function in substantially the same way to achieve substantially the same result. Injunction granted against TVS Flame for infringing Bajaj's DTS-i technology patent.
Read case brief2010 (42) PTC 361 (Del)
Mere accessibility of a website does not confer jurisdiction; court must apply 'purposeful availment' or 'targeting' test for internet jurisdiction
Read case briefORA/35/2012/PT/MUM, IPAB Order dated 4 March 2013
IPAB upheld India's first compulsory licence; affordability and local working are valid grounds under S.84; reduced royalty from 6% to 7%
Read case briefW.P.(C) 1323/2013, Delhi High Court (2014)
Compulsory licence under S.84 upheld on appeal; IPAB and Controller's order granting CL to Natco affirmed
Read case brief2008 (37) PTC 1 (SC)
An industrial design must be novel and original at the date of registration; prior publication anywhere in the world defeats novelty
Read case briefAIR 1979 Supreme Court 1444
Workshop improvement obvious to person skilled in art lacks inventive step; routine trade variation not patentable
Read case briefCase C-482/09
Honest concurrent use over a long period can defeat a claim to cancel a later identical mark.
Read case brief61 (1995) DLT 6; 1995 (35) DRJ 335
Compilations such as customer databases are protected as literary works.
Read case brief(2001) 5 Supreme Court Cases 73
In pharmaceutical cases, the test of deceptive similarity is stricter because confusion between medicines can have life-threatening consequences
Read case briefCS(COMM) 690/2018, Delhi High Court
Design piracy: overall visual impression test; minor differences do not negate piracy if essential features are reproduced
Read case briefDelhi HC, 17 September 2008 (reporter citation not confirmed)
A work that transforms the original for a different purpose, such as worked solutions, may be fair dealing.
Read case briefDelhi HC, 20 March 2008 (reporter citation not confirmed)
A design registration for a shape common in the trade gives weak protection; infringement needs a distinctive registered feature to be copied.
Read case brief447 U.S. 303 (1980)
Man-made living micro-organisms are patentable subject matter; anything under the sun made by man qualifies
Read case brief(2002) IPLR 255 (Cal)
A process yielding a vendible product with living material can be patentable.
Read case brief(2008) 1 Supreme Court Cases 1
Copyright in India requires a modicum of creativity beyond mere labour; copy-edited judgments with headnotes, paragraph numbering, and cross-references involve sufficient creativity to attract copyright; raw judicial texts do not
Read case briefFAO(OS) 188/2008 (interim injunction, decided 24 Apr 2009, reported (2009) 40 PTC 125 Del); RFA(OS) 92/2012 & 103/2012 (merits, decided 27 Nov 2015)
Public interest in access to life-saving drugs may limit patent injunction; damages can be adequate alternative remedy
Read case brief2020 Supreme Court Cases OnLine Delhi 835
Computer-related inventions are patentable if they demonstrate a "technical effect" or "technical contribution" beyond the mere program itself; Section 3(k) excludes only computer programs "per se
Read case briefAIR 1979 Bom 17
Before the 1994 amendment, Indian law gave performers no copyright in their performances; performers' rights were added later.
Read case briefCase C-375/97
A reputed mark is protected against unfair use on dissimilar goods where it is known to a significant part of the relevant public.
Read case briefWT/DS79/R (1998); see also WT/DS50
Transitional TRIPS obligations must be met by legally secure measures, not administrative practice.
Read case briefAIR 1977 Supreme Court 1443
Once copyright in musical/literary work assigned to film producer, author cannot independently claim performing rights through IPRS (reversed by 2012 Amendment)
Read case briefCase C-5/08
Even short extracts are protected if they express the author's own intellectual creation.
Read case brief(2002) 3 Supreme Court Cases 65
Passing off requires proof of goodwill, misrepresentation, and damage; goodwill extends to areas where trader has reputation even without physical presence
Read case briefAIR 1987 Delhi 13
Moral right of integrity violated when film adaptation distorts literary work to the prejudice of author's honour/reputation
Read case brief(2019) 3 Supreme Court Cases 381
The question of whether patents on transgenic plant varieties and seeds are excluded under Section 3(j) requires trial; patent rights cannot be negated at interlocutory stage
Read case brief1996 (16) PTC 583 (SC)
Transborder reputation/goodwill of a foreign trademark is protectable in India even without use or registration in India. A mark that has acquired reputation through international media, advertising spillover, and foreign sales is entitled to passing off protection in India.
Read case briefAIR 1989 Del 63
Where two people contribute intellectually to a work under a common design they are joint authors.
Read case briefCompulsory Licence Application No. 1/2011, Controller of Patents (2012)
India's first compulsory licence was granted under Section 84 where the patented drug was not available at a reasonably affordable price and the patent was not worked in India
Read case briefT 0416/01
Traditional knowledge in public use can be prior art that defeats a patent.
Read case brief(2013) 6 Supreme Court Cases 1
S.3(d): 'efficacy' means therapeutic efficacy for pharmaceuticals; new form of known substance must show significantly enhanced therapeutic efficacy to be patentable
Read case briefAIR 1978 Supreme Court 1613
No copyright in ideas, themes, or subject matter; seven-point test for infringement; only particular form of expression is protected
Read case brief2008 (38) PTC 435 (Del)
Patent infringement is determined by comparing the claims of the patent specification with the alleged infringing product/process; the claims define the monopoly
Read case brief(2004) 6 Supreme Court Cases 145
Domain names are entitled to protection equivalent to trademarks; passing off applies to domain name disputes in India
Read case brief2006 (32) PTC 656 (Del)
Geographical indications are collective rights that protect the reputation of a region's products; unauthorized use of a GI amounts to passing off and misrepresentation
Read case brief2003 (2) Bom CR 655; 2003 (27) PTC 81 (Bom)
A film that merely resembles an earlier film, without actual duplication, is not a \"copy\" under S.14(d)(i) of the Copyright Act; copyright in a cinematograph film does not extend to a separately-made work that is merely similar, and substantiality is tested by comparing the two works as wholes, not by isolating specific scenes.
Read case brief2012 INSC 200
A compulsory licence under S.31 needs a full inquiry; no interim licence can be granted.
Read case brief[2021] EWCA Civ 1374
Under UK law only a natural person can be an inventor.
Read case briefCS(OS) 2439/2012, Delhi High Court
Photocopying portions of textbooks for educational instruction falls within the fair dealing exception under S.52(1)(i) of the Copyright Act, even when done through a commercial intermediary
Read case briefWT/DS176/AB/R (adopted 1 February 2002)
TRIPS requires equal treatment of foreign and national right holders and covers trade names.
Read case brief[1916] 2 Ch 601
Originality in copyright means origination from the author, not novelty.
Read case brief1999 PTC (19) 201 (Del)
Domain names are entitled to trademark-level protection; first Indian case recognising domain name as business identifier
Read case briefTry another term, or search all cases.