Court of Appeal (England)1891
[1891] 2 Chancery 244
A partner must account only for profits derived from a transaction within the scope of the firm's business, or from the use of the firm's property, name or business connection in that business. Information acquired as a partner may be used freely in a wholly different line of business.
partnershipsection-16duty-to-accountsecret-profitscope-of-businessfiduciary-duty
Read case brief →Court of Common Pleas1827
(1827) 4 Bing 66; 130 English Reports 693
A person who acts at the request of another in a transaction which turns out to be wrongful, in good faith and without knowledge of the wrong, is entitled to be indemnified by the person who requested the act.
indemnityagencyimplied-indemnitysection-222section-223good-faith
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1968
AIR 1968 Supreme Court 1432
Under Section 141 a surety is entitled to the benefit of every security the creditor holds against the principal debtor, whether or not the surety knew of it. If the creditor loses or parts with such security without the surety's consent, the surety is discharged to the extent of the value of that security.
guaranteesuretysection-141dischargeloss-of-securitypro-tanto
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1925
[1925] 1 King's Bench 260
Fitness for a purpose made known by the buyer is a condition, not a warranty. A clause excluding liability for warranties does not exclude liability for breach of condition, exclusion clauses being construed strictly.
sale-of-goodsconditionswarrantiessection-12exclusion-clausestrict-construction
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1969
AIR 1969 Supreme Court 297
The liability of a surety under Section 128 is immediate and co-extensive with that of the principal debtor. A creditor is not bound to exhaust his remedies against the principal debtor, or to realise any security, before proceeding against the surety.
guaranteesuretysection-128co-extensive-liabilityimmediacy
Read case brief →King's Bench Division (England)1920
[1920] 3 King's Bench 530
Unless otherwise agreed, the buyer is not bound to accept delivery by instalments. Where only part is delivered and the balance follows after a substantial interval, the buyer may keep and pay for the part delivered and reject the remainder, recovering the price paid for it.
sale-of-goodssection-37section-38deliveryinstalmentsshort-deliverypart-acceptance
Read case brief →Court of Chancery (Rolls Court)1853
(1853) 18 Beavan 75; 52 English Reports 29
A partner who sells his own goods to the firm at a profit without disclosing that he is the seller must account to the firm for that profit. A partner cannot make a secret gain out of a dealing with his own firm.
partnershipsection-16secret-profitduty-to-accountself-dealinggood-faith
Read case brief →Court of King's Bench1704
(1704) 1 Salk 27; 91 English Reports 27
A guarantee is collateral: the third party remains liable and the promisor's liability is secondary. Where the promisor assumes primary liability so that the third party is not liable at all, the promise is an original undertaking and not a guarantee.
guaranteeindemnitysection-126collateral-promiseoriginal-promise
Read case brief →Court of King's Bench1825
(1825) 4 Barnewall and Cresswell 941; 107 English Reports 1309
The passing of property does not carry with it a right to immediate possession. Where the price is unpaid and no credit has been given, the seller may retain the goods until payment or tender, and the buyer cannot sue for them though he is the owner.
sale-of-goodssection-46section-47unpaid-sellerlienpossessionpassing-of-property
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1999
(1999) 7 Supreme Court Cases 359; All India Reporter 1999 Supreme Court 2947
A port trust holding goods as a bailee has a general lien over them for its dues, arising from its statutory powers and the running account character of its business, and may refuse delivery until those dues are paid.
bailmentliengeneral-liensection-171port-truststatutory-lien
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1931
(1931) 145 Law Times 51
There is no privity of contract between a principal and a sub-agent. A sub-agent is answerable to the agent who employed him, and the principal's remedy for the sub-agent's default lies against his own agent.
agencysub-agentsection-192privitydelegationbanking
Read case brief →Chancery Division (England)1904
[1904] 1 Chancery 486
Where the partnership deed confers a power of expulsion for conduct detrimental to the business, a conviction for dishonesty is such conduct and expulsion is valid. The power must be exercised in good faith and strictly within the terms conferred.
partnershipsection-33expulsiongood-faithscandalous-conductreconstitution
Read case brief →Exchequer Chamber1857
(1857) 8 El and Bl 647; 120 English Reports 241
A person who professes to contract as agent impliedly warrants that he has the authority he claims. Breach of that implied warranty makes him liable in damages to the other party even though he acted honestly and without fraud.
agencybreach-of-warranty-of-authoritysection-235strict-liabilitygood-faith
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1961
All India Reporter 1961 Supreme Court 680; [1961] 2 Supreme Court Reports 821
A minor cannot be admitted as a full partner. Section 30 permits only admission to the benefits of partnership, and a deed which makes a minor a full partner with rights of management is invalid to that extent and cannot be read down.
partnershipsection-30minorcapacitybenefits-of-partnershipregistration
Read case brief →House of Lords1878
(1878) 3 Appeal Cases 459
Where a seller dealing at a distance intends to contract only with the person impersonated, there is no consensus with the rogue and the contract is void. No title passes to the rogue, so an honest purchaser from him acquires nothing.
sale-of-goodsnemo-datsection-27void-contractmistaken-identitybona-fide-purchaser
Read case brief →Queen's Bench Division (England)1960
[1960] 1 Queen's Bench 159; [1959] 3 All England Law Reports 307
Where a buyer in possession of goods or documents of title with the seller's consent transfers the document to a person who takes it in good faith and for value, that transferee obtains a good title. The unpaid seller's lien and right of stoppage in transit are defeated as against him.
sale-of-goodssection-30section-53unpaid-sellerstoppage-in-transitdocuments-of-titlenemo-datdelivery-order
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1878
(1878) 8 Chancery Division 286
Where an agent authorised to appoint another to act for the principal does so, that person may stand in a direct fiduciary relationship with the principal and must account to him for any secret profit.
agencysubstituted-agentsection-194secret-profitfiduciary-dutydelegation
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1923
[1923] 1 King's Bench 282
A sale by a mercantile agent binds the owner where the agent was in possession with the owner's consent and sold in the ordinary course of business to a good faith buyer. The agent's fraudulent intention in obtaining possession, and his breach of a price limitation, do not defeat the buyer.
sale-of-goodsmercantile-agentsection-27nemo-datconsent-to-possessiongood-faith
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1964
[1964] 2 Queen's Bench 480
Ostensible authority requires four conditions: a representation that the agent had authority, made by a person with actual authority to manage the business, on which the contractor relied, and in a transaction the principal had capacity to enter into.
agencyostensible-authorityapparent-authoritysection-237estoppelmanaging-director
Read case brief →Bombay High Court1942
AIR 1942 Bombay 302
An indemnity holder need not wait until he has actually paid the loss; once his liability has become absolute he may compel the indemnifier to place him in a position to meet it. Sections 124 and 125 are not exhaustive of the law of indemnity in India.
indemnitysection-124section-125accrual-of-liabilityabsolute-liability
Read case brief →Delhi High Court1976
AIR 1976 Delhi 115
A bailee in possession must account for the goods. Where goods are lost or damaged in the bailee's custody, the onus lies on the bailee to prove that he exercised the care required by Section 151.
bailmentsection-151section-152burden-of-proofpledgeduty-of-care
Read case brief →Privy Council1936
[1936] Appeal Cases 85
A latent defect in goods breaches both the implied condition of fitness for purpose and the implied condition of merchantable quality. Where goods have an obvious use, disclosure of purpose is implied and reliance on the seller is inferred.
sale-of-goodsmerchantable-qualityfitness-for-purposesection-16latent-defectnegligence
Read case brief →Exchequer Chamber1874
(1874) LR 9 Exchequer 132
A person in an existing relationship such as a carrier, who is faced with a genuine emergency and cannot obtain the owner's instructions, may act as an agent of necessity and recover reasonable expenses incurred bona fide in the owner's interest.
agencyagency-of-necessitysection-189carrieremergencyreimbursement
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India2000
(2000) 3 Supreme Court Cases 250; All India Reporter 2000 Supreme Court 1287
Section 69(2) bars only a suit to enforce a right arising from a contract entered into by the unregistered firm in the course of its business. A suit to enforce a statutory or common law right, such as an action for trademark infringement or passing off, is not barred.
partnershipsection-69registrationunregistered-firmstatutory-righttrademarkpassing-off
Read case brief →Court of Appeal (England)1923
[1923] 2 King's Bench 490
A buyer who resells and despatches goods to sub-buyers does an act inconsistent with the ownership of the seller. That constitutes acceptance, and the right to reject for breach of condition is lost even if a reasonable opportunity of examination has not been exhausted. The buyer is confined to damages.
sale-of-goodssection-41section-42acceptanceright-to-rejectinconsistent-actexamination
Read case brief →House of Lords1895
[1895] Appeal Cases 471
Where a person in possession under a hire agreement has a genuine option to return the goods and end future liability, he has not agreed to buy them. He is a bailee with no title and can pass none to a transferee.
hire-purchasesale-of-goodsoption-to-purchasenemo-datsection-30agreed-to-buy
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1876
(1876) 1 Queen's Bench Division 258
A contract for the sale of goods to be produced from a specified source is subject to an implied condition that the goods come into existence. Failure of the crop without the seller's fault excuses performance to that extent.
sale-of-goodscontingent-goodssection-6future-goodscrop-failureimplied-condition
Read case brief →Chancery Division1915
[1915] 1 Chancery 621
A particular lien requires the exercise of labour or skill which improves the goods. A bailee who merely maintains or preserves goods in the condition in which he received them acquires no lien for his charges.
bailmentlienparticular-liensection-170improvementmaintenance
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1964
All India Reporter 1964 Supreme Court 1882; (1964) 8 Supreme Court Reports 50
The words 'other proceedings' in Section 69(3) of the Indian Partnership Act 1932 are of the widest import and include an application to appoint an arbitrator. An unregistered firm cannot make such an application to enforce a right arising from a contract.
partnershipsection-69registrationunregistered-firmarbitrationother-proceedings
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1971
(1971) 2 Supreme Court Cases 873
The two essential conditions of partnership are an agreement to share the profits of a business and the business being carried on by all or any of the partners acting for all. Concentration of management and control in one partner does not destroy the partnership.
partnershipsection-4mutual-agencytrue-testprofit-sharingcontrol-and-management
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1965
All India Reporter 1965 Supreme Court 1082; (1965) 2 Supreme Court Reports 112
A hire purchase agreement has a dual character. It is a bailment coupled with an option to purchase, and the sale takes effect only when the option is exercised. Tax on the sale can therefore be levied only at that point and on the value of the goods at that time.
sale-of-goodshire-purchasebailmentoption-to-purchasedual-characterpassing-of-property
Read case brief →Madras High Court1938
AIR 1938 Madras 32
Delivery of possession is essential to a bailment. Where the owner resumes possession of the goods, no bailment subsists and the bailee's duty of care under Section 151 does not attach, even though the goods remain physically on his premises.
bailmentsection-148delivery-of-possessionsection-151goldsmith
Read case brief →House of Lords1901
[1901] Appeal Cases 240
Ratification is possible only where the person doing the act professed at the time to act on behalf of the principal. An undisclosed intention to act for another cannot be converted into agency by subsequent ratification.
agencyratificationsection-196undisclosed-intentionprofessed-agency
Read case brief →Court of Common Pleas1866
(1866) LR 2 Common Pleas 174
A principal must be in existence at the time of the act for ratification to be possible. Promoters who contract on behalf of a company not yet incorporated are personally liable, and the company cannot ratify the contract after incorporation.
agencypre-incorporation-contractratificationsection-230personal-liabilitypromoters
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1967
AIR 1967 Supreme Court 1322
A pawnee's right to recover the debt is correlative to his ability to redeliver the pledged goods on payment. A pawnee who has parted with or cannot produce the goods cannot enforce the debt, because that would defeat the pawnor's right of redemption under Section 177.
pledgepawneesection-176section-177redemptioncorrelative-obligation
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1893
[1893] 2 Queen's Bench 318
Where a person in possession under an agreement is bound to pay the whole price by instalments and has no right to return the goods, the agreement is in substance an agreement to buy, and he may pass a good title to a bona fide purchaser.
hire-purchasesale-of-goodsagreed-to-buysection-30nemo-datinstalment-sale
Read case brief →House of Lords1912
[1912] Appeal Cases 716
A principal is liable for the fraud of an agent committed within the apparent scope of his authority, even where the fraud was for the agent's own benefit and the principal neither knew of nor benefited from it.
agencyfraud-of-agentsection-238apparent-authorityvicarious-liability
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1963
AIR 1963 Supreme Court 746
Section 133 discharges a surety only where the variance in the terms of the principal contract is material and not beneficial to him. An alteration which reduces the surety's liability, or is otherwise immaterial, does not discharge him.
guaranteesuretysection-133variancedischargematerial-alteration
Read case brief →Queen's Bench Division (England)1962
[1962] 3 All England Law Reports 1103
A partner's implied authority is measured by what is usual in a business of that kind as it appears to outsiders. A restriction contained in the partnership agreement but unknown to the third party does not limit the firm's liability.
partnershipsection-19implied-authorityapparent-authoritysleeping-partnerthird-parties
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1965
AIR 1965 Supreme Court 1954
Delivery of a document of title to goods, such as a railway receipt, operates as constructive delivery of the goods themselves and creates a valid pledge, entitling the pledgee to recover the full value of the goods from a carrier who loses them.
pledgesection-172constructive-deliverydocuments-of-titlerailway-receipttrade-finance
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1921
[1921] 3 King's Bench 387
A seller does not have a right to sell within the meaning of Section 14(a) where he cannot sell without exposing the buyer to restraint by a third party, such as an injunction for infringement of a trade mark.
sale-of-goodsright-to-sellsection-14merchantable-qualitytrade-markthird-party-rights
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1951
AIR 1951 Supreme Court 144
An agent who fails to carry out an express instruction, such as an instruction to insure goods, is liable for the direct consequences of that neglect under Section 212. Compensation received by the principal from an independent source does not reduce the agent's liability.
agencysection-211section-212skill-and-diligencefailure-to-insuredirect-consequences
Read case brief →King's Bench Division1919
[1919] 2 King's Bench 243
A seller dealing face to face intends to contract with the person physically present, so a false claim of identity renders the contract voidable for fraud and not void. Title passes to the rogue, and a good faith transferee who takes before rescission acquires good title.
sale-of-goodsnemo-datsection-29voidable-titleface-to-facebona-fide-purchaser
Read case brief →King's Bench Division1919
[1919] 1 King's Bench 459
Appropriation of unascertained goods to the contract with the other party's assent passes property, and assent may be implied from silence and failure to object. Risk then follows property, so the buyer bears a subsequent loss.
sale-of-goodspassing-of-propertysection-23appropriationimplied-assentrisk
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1903
[1903] 2 King's Bench 148
Where goods have one obvious use, the buyer makes known the particular purpose merely by asking for the article by name, and the implied condition of fitness for purpose applies.
sale-of-goodsfitness-for-purposesection-16implied-conditionhot-water-bottle
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1935
[1935] 1 King's Bench 579
Where the substance of a contract is the exercise of skill and labour, with the supply of materials being merely ancillary, the contract is one for work and labour and not for the sale of goods.
sale-of-goodswork-and-laboursubstance-testsection-4portraitskill
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1923
[1923] 2 King's Bench 500
Breach of the implied condition as to the seller's right to sell produces a total failure of consideration. The buyer may recover the entire price with no deduction for the period during which he used the goods, because he never obtained ownership.
sale-of-goodsright-to-sellsection-14total-failure-of-considerationrecovery-of-price
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1993
(1993) 1 Supreme Court Cases 589
All property brought into the stock of the firm or acquired for it becomes the property of the firm. During subsistence no partner can claim any earmarked portion of it; his interest is undefined and fluctuating. On dissolution the whole must be converted into money under Section 48 and the residue divided, so a partner's share is movable property and its distribution needs no registration.
partnershipsection-14section-48dissolutionfirm-propertysettlement-of-accountsregistration
Read case brief →Court of Common Pleas1848
(1848) 5 Common Bench 895; 136 English Reports 1132
An agency is coupled with an interest only where the authority was conferred for the purpose of securing that interest. An interest acquired after the authority was given does not make the authority irrevocable.
agencyterminationrevocationsection-202agency-coupled-with-interestfactors
Read case brief →Supreme Court of India1992
(1992) 3 Supreme Court Cases 159; All India Reporter 1992 Supreme Court 1740
Where a composite decree is passed against the principal debtor and the guarantor, the decree-holder may execute it against the guarantor without first exhausting execution against the mortgaged property of the principal debtor.
guaranteesuretysection-128executioncomposite-decreemortgaged-property
Read case brief →Court of Queen's Bench1840
(1840) 11 Ad and El 589; 113 English Reports 539
Termination of an agent's authority does not take effect against third persons until it becomes known to them. A principal remains bound to those who continue to deal with the former agent in ignorance of the revocation.
agencyterminationrevocationsection-208notice-to-third-partiesapparent-authority
Read case brief →Queen's Bench Division1894
[1894] 1 Queen's Bench 92
A bailment may arise by conduct without any request from the owner. Where a person voluntarily assumes possession and control of another's goods, he becomes a bailee and owes the duty of care of a bailee.
bailmentgratuitous-bailmentsection-148section-151implied-bailment
Read case brief →Court of Appeal1922
[1922] 1 King's Bench 343
Where the seller is bound to do something to put the goods into a deliverable state, property does not pass until that thing is done and the buyer has notice of it. Goods requiring detachment and loading are not in a deliverable state.
sale-of-goodspassing-of-propertysection-21deliverable-staterisksection-26
Read case brief →House of Lords1911
[1911] Appeal Cases 394
Correspondence with description is a condition and not a warranty. A contractual clause excluding warranties does not protect a seller against breach of the condition as to description.
sale-of-goodssale-by-descriptionsection-15conditionswarrantiesexclusion-clause
Read case brief →House of Lords1878
(1878) 4 Appeal Cases 13
There is no implied warranty of soundness on a sale of goods, and mere non-disclosure of a known defect does not amount to fraud. A sale expressly with all faults places the risk of quality on the buyer.
sale-of-goodscaveat-emptorsection-16non-disclosurewith-all-faultsfraud
Read case brief →Queen's Bench Division1893
[1893] 1 Queen's Bench 346
Where a person is placed in a position which ordinarily carries authority to do acts of a particular kind, the principal is bound by such acts even if he has privately restricted the authority, as against a third party who did not know of the restriction.
agencyusual-authorityapparent-authoritysection-237section-20undisclosed-principal
Read case brief →Court of Appeal (England)1913
[1913] 3 King's Bench 743
The seller's duty to give the buyer notice enabling him to insure goods sent by a route involving sea transit is purposive. Where the buyer already possesses the information necessary to effect insurance, the absence of a formal notice does not put the goods at the seller's risk.
sale-of-goodssection-39sea-transitnotice-to-insureriskfob
Read case brief →