Law of Contract I case briefs

62 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Law of Contract I notes.

62 briefs in Law of Contract I
Court of King's Bench (England)1818

Adams v. Lindsell

(1818) 1 B & Ald 681

A contract is complete the moment a letter of acceptance is posted, not when it is received (the postal rule).

postal-rulecommunication-of-acceptanceoffer-and-acceptance
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1887

Allcard v. Skinner

(1887) 36 Chancery D 145

A transaction procured through undue influence arising from a relationship of trust and confidence may nonetheless stand if the party seeking to set it aside delayed unreasonably in doing so after the influence ceased.

undue-influencedelaylachesrelationship-of-confidence
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1919

Balfour v. Balfour

[1919] 2 King's Bench 571

Domestic agreements between spouses are presumed not to create legally enforceable contracts; the onus is on the party alleging a contract to rebut this presumption.

intention-to-create-legal-relationsdomestic-agreementpresumptioncontract-formation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2003

Bank of India v. O.P. Swarnakar

(2003) 2 Supreme Court Cases 721

An offer accepted under a voluntary retirement scheme cannot be unilaterally withdrawn by the offeree employee once communicated and acted upon by the employer within the scheme's terms.

revocation-of-acceptancevoluntary-retirement-schemebanking
Read case brief
House of Lords (UK)1932

Bell v. Lever Bros Ltd

[1932] Appeal Cases 161

A common mistake as to a quality of the subject matter of a contract renders the contract void only if the mistake is so fundamental as to make the subject matter essentially different from what the parties believed it to be.

common-mistakefundamental-mistakequality-of-subject-matter
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from New Zealand)1927

Bisset v. Wilkinson

[1927] Appeal Cases 177

A statement of opinion or belief, as distinct from a statement of fact, does not amount to actionable misrepresentation, even if it turns out to be incorrect, provided it was honestly made.

misrepresentationopinion-vs-facthonest-beliefnon-actionablerescission
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1893

Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company

[1893] 1 Queen's Bench 256

An advertisement can constitute a binding unilateral offer to the world at large, accepted by performance of its stated conditions; consideration exists in the inconvenience of performance.

unilateral-contractoffer-to-worldacceptance-by-performanceconsiderationadvertisementcontract-formation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1986

Central Inland Water Transport Corp v. Brojo Nath Ganguly

AIR 1986 Supreme Court 1571

Standard form contract terms that are unconscionable, unreasonable, and the product of grossly unequal bargaining power may be struck down as opposed to public policy, even absent traditional vitiating factors like fraud or coercion.

standard-form-contractunconscionabilityunequal-bargaining-powerpublic-policy
Read case brief
Madras High Court1917

Chikham Amiraju v. Chikham Seshamma

(1917) Indian Law Reports 41 Madras 33

A threat to commit suicide amounts to coercion under Section 15 of the Indian Contract Act, as suicide (attempt) is an act forbidden by the Indian Penal Code; consent obtained through such threat is not free.

coercionSection-15suicide-threatIPCfree-consentvoidable
Read case brief
Madras High Court1882

Chinnaya v. Ramayya

Indian Law Reports (1882) 4 Madras 137

Under Indian law (Section 2(d) ICA), consideration may proceed from the promisee or 'any other person'; a stranger to consideration (but not to the contract) can enforce the agreement.

considerationstranger-to-considerationSection-2dprivitythird-partyIndian-Contract-Act
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1936

Craven-Ellis v. Canons Ltd

[1936] 2 King's Bench 403

Where services are rendered under a contract that turns out to be void (for want of legal formality), the party who rendered the services is entitled to recover reasonable remuneration on a quantum meruit basis: the obligation arises from unjust enrichment, not from contract.

quantum-meruitvoid-contractrestitutionunjust-enrichmentreasonable-remunerationquasi-contract
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer, affirmed by the Exchequer Chamber, affirmed by the House of Lords (England)1875

Currie v. Misa

(1875) LR 10 Exchequer 153 (Court of Exchequer); (1875-76) LR 1 Appeal Cases 554 (the classic dictum is from the Court of Exchequer Chamber's affirmance, not the first-instance Court of Exchequer)

Valuable consideration consists either in some right, interest, profit, or benefit accruing to the one party, or some forbearance, detriment, loss, or responsibility given, suffered, or undertaken by the other.

considerationdefinitionbenefit-detrimentvaluable-considerationEnglish-law
Read case brief
Court of King's Bench (England)1795

Cutter v Powell

(1795) 6 TR 320; 101 English Reports 573

Where a contract is entire (indivisible), no payment is due for partial performance unless the entire obligation has been completed.

entire-contractquantum-meruitsubstantial-performancedischarge-by-performance
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1992

Dalpat Kumar v. Prahlad Singh

AIR 1993 Supreme Court 276; (1992) 1 Supreme Court Cases 719

Three conditions must be satisfied for grant of temporary injunction under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2: (1) prima facie case, (2) balance of convenience in favour of the applicant, and (3) irreparable injury if injunction is not granted. All three must coexist.

CPCtemporary-injunctionorder-XXXIXprima-facie-casebalance-of-convenienceirreparable-injurythree-conditions
Read case brief
House of Lords1889

Derry v Peek

(1889) 14 Appeal Cases 337

Fraud requires knowledge of falsehood or recklessness; honest belief in truth, even if unreasonable, negates fraud.

fraudmisrepresentationhonest-beliefmens-reaprospectus
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1876

Dickinson v. Dodds

(1876) 2 Chancery D 463

An offer may be revoked at any time before acceptance, even without formal communication, if the offeree learns through reliable means that the offeror has acted inconsistently with the offer.

revocation-of-offercommunication-of-revocationindirect-knowledge
Read case brief
House of Lords (England)1915

Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v. Selfridge & Co Ltd

[1915] Appeal Cases 847

Only a party to a contract can sue upon it (privity); a person who has provided no consideration to the defendant cannot enforce the defendant's promise, even if the promise was made for their benefit.

privity-of-contractconsiderationthird-partymanufacturerresale-priceEnglish-law
Read case brief
Allahabad High Court1880

Durga Prasad v. Baldeo

(1880) Indian Law Reports 3 Allahabad 221

A promise made in consideration of an act done at the promisor's own desire, but not at the request of the promisee, does not constitute valid consideration.

considerationdesire-of-promisorpast-consideration
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1963

Fateh Chand v Balkishan Dass

AIR 1963 Supreme Court 1405

Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act abolishes the English law distinction between penalty and liquidated damages; a party can recover only reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount named in the contract, and must show loss unless it is impossible to prove.

section-74liquidated-damagespenaltyforfeitureearnest-money
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1862

Felthouse v. Bindley

(1862) 11 CBNS 869; 142 English Reports 1037

Silence or inaction cannot constitute acceptance of an offer; an offeror cannot impose acceptance by stipulating that silence shall amount to consent.

silenceacceptancecommunication-of-acceptanceofferor-cannot-imposecontract-formation
Read case brief
Queen's Bench Division1961

Fisher v. Bell

[1961] 1 Queen's Bench 394

Literal Rule applied strictly. Display of goods in a shop window is an invitation to treat, not an "offer for sale." Shopkeeper acquitted of offering a flick-knife for sale.

literal-ruleoffer-for-saleinvitation-to-treatflick-knifestrict-construction
Read case brief
House of Lords (England)1884

Foakes v. Beer

[1884] UKHL 1; (1884) 9 Appeal Cases 605

Part payment of a debt is not good consideration for a promise to forgo the balance; the rule in Pinnel's Case is affirmed by the House of Lords.

considerationpart-paymentdebtPinnels-Casepre-existing-dutyEnglish-law
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1872

Frost v. Knight

(1872) LR 7 Exchequer 111

Where a party repudiates a contingent contract before the contingency occurs, the innocent party may immediately treat the repudiation as an anticipatory breach and sue for damages without waiting for the contingency to happen.

anticipatory-breachcontingent-contractrepudiationbreach-of-promisemarriageSection-39
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1959

Gherulal Parakh v. Mahadeodas Maiya

AIR 1959 Supreme Court 781

A wagering agreement under Section 30 ICA is void but not illegal; collateral transactions to a wager are therefore enforceable. A partnership formed for the purpose of wagering is valid because the object of the partnership (wagering) is not 'forbidden by law' under Section 23.

wageringvoid-not-illegalSection-30Section-23collateral-transactionspartnershipIndian-law
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1854

Hadley v. Baxendale

(1854) 9 Exch 341; 156 English Reports 145

Damages for breach of contract are limited to those: (1) arising naturally from the breach in the usual course of things (first limb), or (2) those which were in the reasonable contemplation of both parties at the time of contracting as the probable result of breach (second limb, special damages requiring notice).

damagesremotenesscontemplationtwo-limbsconsequential-lossforeseeabilitySection-73
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from Jamaica)1893

Harvey v. Facey

[1893] Appeal Cases 552

A mere statement of the lowest price at which a party would sell does not constitute an offer; it is merely a supply of information in response to an inquiry.

offerinvitation-to-treatsupply-of-informationprice-quotationdistinctioncontract-formation
Read case brief
Court of Queen's Bench (England)1853

Hochster v. De La Tour

(1853) 2 El & Bl 678; 118 English Reports 922

Where a party to an executory contract repudiates it before the date of performance, the innocent party may sue immediately for anticipatory breach without waiting for the date of performance to arrive.

anticipatory-breachrepudiationexecutory-contractimmediate-actionSection-39
Read case brief
Court of Chancery (Rolls Court)1840

Hyde v. Wrench

(1840) 3 Beav 334; 49 English Reports 132

A counter-offer terminates (destroys) the original offer; the original offer cannot thereafter be accepted.

counter-offeroriginal-offertermination-of-offeracceptancemirror-image-rule
Read case brief
Patna High Court1957

Inder Singh v. Parmeshwardhari Singh

AIR 1957 Patna 491

A person is of unsound mind for contractual purposes if, at the time of contracting, they are incapable of understanding the contract and forming a rational judgment of its effect on their interests.

unsound-mindcapacity-to-contractmental-capacity
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2015

Kailash Nath Associates v Delhi Development Authority

(2015) 4 Supreme Court Cases 136

Forfeiture of earnest money under Section 74 is permissible only where the forfeiting party proves loss, or where the amount is a genuine pre-estimate of damage; unconscionable forfeiture without proof of loss is not sustainable.

section-74earnest-moneyforfeitureliquidated-damagesDDA
Read case brief
Calcutta High Court1886

Kedar Nath Bhattacharji v. Gorie Mahomed

(1886) Indian Law Reports 14 Calcutta 64

A promise to subscribe to a charitable or public fund becomes enforceable when the promisee, acting on the promise, incurs liability or changes position; the promisee's act constitutes consideration for the subscription.

considerationsubscriptioncharitable-promisepromissory-liabilitySection-2dIndian-law
Read case brief
Privy Council1910

Khwaja Muhammad Khan v. Husaini Begum

(1910) 37 Indian Appeals 152

Where a contract, though made between other parties, creates a specific charge or trust in favour of a third party who is a natural object of the promisor's bounty, that third party may enforce the provision, an exception to the privity rule.

privity-of-contractexceptionstrust-exceptionfamily-arrangement
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1903

Krell v. Henry

[1903] 2 King's Bench 740

A contract is frustrated where the fundamental purpose for which both parties entered the contract ceases to exist due to a supervening event, even though literal performance remains physically possible: the doctrine of frustration of purpose.

frustrationfrustration-of-purposecoronation-casesfoundation-of-contractsupervening-eventdischarge
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1934

L'Estrange v. Graucob

[1934] 2 King's Bench 394

A person who signs a contractual document is bound by its terms, whether or not they have read or understood them, absent fraud or misrepresentation.

standard-form-contractsignature-ruleexemption-clauses
Read case brief
Allahabad High Court1913

Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt

(1913) 11 ALJ 489; 1913 Supreme Court Cases OnLine Allahabad 242

An offer must be communicated to the offeree before it can be accepted; performance of the act without knowledge of the offer does not constitute acceptance and gives no right to the reward.

communication-of-offerknowledge-of-offeracceptancerewardSection-2aIndian-Contract-Act
Read case brief
Madras High Court1966

Lily White v. R. Munuswami

AIR 1966 Madras 13

An exemption clause limiting liability must be brought to the customer's reasonable notice at or before the time of contracting to be binding; a clause on a receipt handed over after the contract is concluded does not bind the customer.

standard-form-contractreasonable-noticeexemption-clausetiming
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1970

M.C. Chacko v. State Bank of Travancore

AIR 1970 Supreme Court 504

A person who is not a party to a contract cannot sue upon it, even where the contract purports to confer a benefit or impose an obligation affecting them, reaffirming the general privity rule.

privity-of-contractstranger-to-contractindian-application
Read case brief
Privy Council (Judicial Committee)1903

Mohori Bibee v. Dharmodas Ghose

(1903) 30 Indian Appeals 114; [1903] UKPC 12

A contract entered into by a minor is void ab initio under Indian law, not merely voidable; a minor has no capacity to contract under Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

minorcapacityvoid-ab-initioSection-11mortgageIndian-Contract-Act
Read case brief
Court of King's Bench (UK)1760

Moses v. Macferlan

(1760) 2 Burr 1005

Quasi-contractual obligation arises to prevent unjust enrichment; the law implies a promise to return money received without consideration or unjustly.

quasi-contractunjust-enrichmentobligationimplied-promise
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1908

Nash v. Inman

[1908] 2 King's Bench 1

A minor is only liable for 'necessaries' under the Sale of Goods Act; necessaries must be (1) suitable to the condition in life of the minor AND (2) at his actual requirements at the time of sale, if the minor is already adequately supplied, the goods are not necessaries.

minornecessariescapacitySection-68-ICAadequate-supplycondition-in-life
Read case brief
Privy Council (on appeal from Oudh)1928

Nawab Sadiq Ali Khan v Jai Kishori

[1928] UKPC 27; (1928) 30 Bom LR 1346

A mortgage executed by minors is void under Indian law, and a deed executed by a minor cannot found an estoppel against him.

contract-lawminorvoid-agreementmortgageestoppelprivy-council
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2002

Nirmala Anand v Sri Advent Corporation Pvt Ltd

(2002) 8 Supreme Court Cases 146

A rise in the price of property between the date of agreement and the date of decree is not, by itself, a ground to refuse specific performance; courts may mould relief by directing additional compensation to offset price escalation.

specific-performanceprice-escalationdiscretion-of-courtspecific-relief-act
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1949

Olley v. Marlborough Court Ltd

[1949] 1 King's Bench 532

An exclusion clause displayed after the contract is formed (e.g., a notice inside a hotel room seen only after check-in at reception) cannot be incorporated into the contract; terms must be brought to notice before or at the time of contracting.

exclusion-clauseincorporationnoticetimingstandard-formhotelcontract-formation
Read case brief
House of Lords1873

Peek v Gurney

(1873) LR 6 House of Lords 377

Only persons who subscribed DIRECTLY on the faith of the prospectus can sue for misstatement; subsequent market purchasers cannot.

prospectusmisstatementreliancesecondary-marketprivity
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1602

Pinnel's Case

(1602) 5 Co Rep 117a; 77 English Reports 237

Payment of a lesser sum on the day it is due cannot be satisfaction for a greater sum; but payment of a lesser sum before the day, or at a different place, or with a chattel (horse, hawk, robe) may discharge the whole.

part-paymentconsiderationdebtaccord-and-satisfactionEnglish-lawhistorical
Read case brief
Court of Common Pleas (England)1831

Planché v. Colburn

(1831) 8 Bing 14; 131 English Reports 305

Where one party has partially performed a contract which is then wrongfully terminated by the other party, the performer may claim quantum meruit for the work done, abandoning the contractual rate and claiming reasonable value instead.

quantum-meruitpartial-performancewrongful-terminationbreachreasonable-remuneration
Read case brief
Court of Exchequer (England)1864

Raffles v. Wichelhaus

(1864) 2 H&C 906; 159 English Reports 375

Where a key term of the contract is ambiguous and the parties attach different meanings to it (mutual/bilateral mistake), there is no consensus ad idem and the contract is void.

mutual-mistakeambiguityconsensus-ad-idemPeerlesslatent-ambiguityvoid
Read case brief
Privy Council1924

Raghunath Prasad v. Sarju Prasad

(1924) Allahabad India Reporter, Privy Council 60; (1923) 51 Indian Appeals 101

To establish undue influence under Section 16 ICA, three steps must be proved: (1) the parties are in a relationship where one can dominate the other's will; (2) the dominant party used that position to obtain an unfair advantage; (3) the transaction is unconscionable on its face.

undue-influenceSection-16domination-of-willunconscionableburden-of-proofPrivy-Council
Read case brief
Calcutta High Court1900

Rajlukhy Dabee v. Bhootnath Mookerjee

(1900) 4 CWN 488

For an agreement without consideration to be valid under Section 25(1) ICA, there must be genuine natural love and affection between parties standing in near relation; a promise made merely to get rid of a wife does not qualify.

considerationexceptionSection-25natural-love-and-affectionnear-relationvoid-agreement
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2004

Rame Gowda (dead) by LRs v M Varadappa Naidu (dead) by LRs

(2004) 1 Supreme Court Cases 769

A person in settled possession of property, even without title, is entitled to protect that possession against everyone, including the true owner, unless the owner recovers possession through due process of law.

settled-possessionspecific-relief-actsection-6forcible-dispossession
Read case brief
Madras High Court1889

Ranganayakamma v. Alwar Setti

(1889) Indian Law Reports 13 Madras 214

Threatening to withhold a dead body from cremation unless a person consents to an adoption amounts to coercion under Section 15 of the Indian Contract Act; the resulting consent is not free and the agreement is voidable.

coercionSection-15free-consentdead-bodyadoptionvoidableIPCunlawful-detention
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1954

Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co

AIR 1954 Supreme Court 44

Section 56 of the Indian Contract Act exhaustively governs frustration in India; 'impossibility' under Section 56 is used in a practical sense (impracticability), not literally; English doctrines of frustration cannot be imported beyond the statutory framework.

frustrationSection-56impossibilityimpracticabilitysupervening-eventIndian-lawrequisition
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1962

State of West Bengal v. B.K. Mondal & Sons

AIR 1962 Supreme Court 779

Section 70 of the Indian Contract Act applies even against the government; where a person lawfully performs work for another (including the State) who enjoys the benefit, the beneficiary must compensate regardless of the absence of a valid contract.

quasi-contractSection-70government-liabilitynon-gratuitous-actunjust-enrichmentIndian-law
Read case brief
Court of Queen's Bench (England)1863

Taylor v. Caldwell

(1863) 3 B&S 826; 122 English Reports 309

Where the performance of a contract depends on the continued existence of a specific thing, destruction of that thing without fault of either party discharges both parties from their obligations (doctrine of frustration).

frustrationimpossibilitydestruction-of-subject-matterdischargeimplied-conditionsupervening-event
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1971

Thornton v. Shoe Lane Parking Ltd

[1971] 2 Queen's Bench 163

Where a contract is formed at an automatic machine, terms printed on a ticket issued by the machine come too late to be incorporated; the more unusual or onerous a clause, the greater the notice required to incorporate it.

exclusion-clauseincorporationautomatic-machinereasonable-noticeonerous-termsstandard-form
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2010

Trimex International FZE Ltd v. Vedanta Aluminium Ltd

(2010) 3 Supreme Court Cases 1

A contract concluded by offer and unconditional acceptance exchanged by e-mail is binding; that a formal contract was to be signed later does not affect it (SC 2010, under ss.4 and 7 Contract Act)

e-contractemail-contractarbitration-agreementconcluded-contractS4-contract-act
Read case brief
Court of Queen's Bench (England)1861

Tweddle v. Atkinson

[1861] 1 B&S 393; 121 English Reports 762

Under English law, consideration must move from the promisee; a person who is a stranger to the consideration cannot sue on the contract even if it was made for their benefit.

privity-of-contractconsideration-must-move-from-promiseestranger-to-considerationEnglish-lawthird-party
Read case brief
Court of Appeal (England)1949

Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v. Newman Industries Ltd

[1949] 2 King's Bench 528

Damages are recoverable if the loss was reasonably foreseeable as a 'serious possibility' or 'real danger' at the time of contracting; imputed knowledge (what a reasonable person in defendant's position would know) suffices where actual knowledge is absent.

damagesremotenessforeseeabilityreasonable-contemplationHadley-v-Baxendaleimputed-knowledgespecial-loss
Read case brief