Alternate Dispute Resolution case briefs

31 briefs, A to Z. Each has the facts, issue, held and principle. Open the Alternate Dispute Resolution notes.

31 briefs in Alternate Dispute Resolution
Supreme Court of India2018

Board of Control for Cricket in India v Kochi Cricket Pvt. Ltd.

(2018) 6 Supreme Court Cases 287

2015 Amendment (removal of automatic stay under S.36) applies retrospectively to all S.34 applications pending as on 23.10.2015; the 2019 Amendment's S.87 tried to reverse this to prospective-only, but the Supreme Court struck down S.87 itself in Hindustan Construction Co. v Union of India (2019) as manifestly arbitrary under Art.14, reinstating this very ruling

ADRsection-36automatic-stay2015-amendmentretrospective
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1981

Guru Nanak Foundation v Rattan Singh & Sons

AIR 1981 Supreme Court 2075; (1981) 4 Supreme Court Cases 634

The Arbitration Act, 1940 had become a source of delay rather than remedy; highlighted need for reform leading to the 1996 Act

ADRarbitrationreform1940-Actlandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2000

Haresh Dayaram Thakur v State of Maharashtra

(2000) 6 Supreme Court Cases 179

A settlement reached in conciliation under Part III of the 1996 Act becomes 'final and binding' only when the parties themselves draw up and sign a settlement agreement under S.73(3); it then has the status of an arbitral award on agreed terms under S.74. A conciliator cannot impose or finalise a settlement by drafting it alone and sending it to the court in a sealed cover without the parties' signatures — doing so bypasses the statutory procedure and is not a valid conciliated settlement, whatever the parties' prior consent to conciliate.

ADRconciliationsection-73section-74Part-IIIsigned-settlement-agreement
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2018

HRD Corporation v GAIL (India) Limited

(2018) 12 Supreme Court Cases 471

An arbitrator held 'ineligible' under S.12(5) read with the Seventh Schedule (e.g. for a disqualifying relationship/conduct) becomes de jure unable to perform their functions under S.14(1)(a), and an application may be filed under S.14(2) to terminate the mandate on that ground. By contrast, a 'justifiable doubts' challenge under the Fifth Schedule goes to the Tribunal itself under S.13 and can only be raised under S.34 after an award — it cannot be adjudicated at the S.14 stage. CAUTION: this is not a limitation/time-bar case at all — see Note on correction.

ADRsection-12section-14arbitrator-ineligibilityseventh-schedulebias
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2013

K. Srinivas Rao v D.A. Deepa

(2013) 5 Supreme Court Cases 226

Courts must explore mediation/conciliation in matrimonial disputes before granting divorce; Family Courts should actively refer to mediation centres

ADRmediationfamily-courtsmatrimonialreconciliation
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India (Seven-judge bench)1997

L. Chandra Kumar v Union of India

AIR 1997 Supreme Court 1125; (1997) 3 Supreme Court Cases 261

Power of judicial review under Art. 226/227 is a basic feature of the Constitution; tribunal orders are subject to High Court review; tribunals cannot exclude HC jurisdiction.

ADRtribunalsjudicial-reviewbasic-structureArt-226landmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2014

Madras Bar Association v Union of India

(2014) 10 Supreme Court Cases 1

Tribunals must have judicial members with qualifications comparable to HC judges for deciding questions of law; technical members cannot decide pure legal questions alone

ADRtribunalsNCLTjudicial-independencecomposition
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2003

Mysore Cements Ltd. v Svedala Barmac Ltd.

(2003) 10 Supreme Court Cases 375

A conciliation settlement agreement under S.73 cannot be set aside merely because one party later regrets the terms; it is final and binding like an arbitral award

ADRconciliationsettlementsection-73finality
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2005

P.T. Thomas v Thomas Job

(2005) 6 Supreme Court Cases 478

A Lok Adalat award passed without genuine consent of both parties is a nullity; consent must be real, not merely formal

ADRlok-adalatconsentnullity
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2019

Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v HSCC (India) Ltd.

(2020) 20 Supreme Court Cases 760

Unilateral appointment clauses where one party alone appoints the sole arbitrator are invalid; violates equality between parties in arbitral process

ADRunilateral-appointmentsection-12party-equalityPSU-contractslandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India1980

Rukmanibai Gupta v Collector, Jabalpur

AIR 1981 Supreme Court 479

An arbitration agreement needs no particular form; a contract clause referring disputes under it to a named person (here the lessor) whose decision is final is an arbitration agreement, and the decision is an award (Arbitration Act, 1940)

ADRsection-7arbitration-agreementform-of-agreementarbitration-act-1940
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2005

Salem Advocate Bar Association v Union of India

AIR 2005 Supreme Court 3353; (2005) 6 Supreme Court Cases 344

S.89 CPC is constitutionally valid; directed framing of mediation rules for civil courts; courts must actively explore ADR in suitable cases

ADRsection-89CPCconstitutional-validitymediation-ruleslandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2014

Shri Lal Mahal Ltd. v Progetto Grano Spa

(2014) 2 Supreme Court Cases 433

For enforcement of foreign awards under S.48, 'public policy' does not include 'patent illegality'; scope is narrower than S.34 for domestic awards

ADRsection-48foreign-awardspublic-policyno-patent-illegalityNew-York-Convention
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2011

SMS Tea Estates Pvt. Ltd. v Chandmari Tea Co. Pvt. Ltd.

(2011) 14 Supreme Court Cases 66

An arbitration clause in an unregistered but compulsorily registrable document is a collateral, separable agreement that can be acted upon; but if the document is not duly stamped, the court must impound it and have the duty and penalty paid before acting on the clause (the stamping part was overruled by In re Interplay, 2023)

ADRsection-7section-11arbitration-agreementseparabilitystamp-actregistration-actoverruled
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2008

State of Punjab v Jalour Singh

(2008) 2 Supreme Court Cases 660

A regular Lok Adalat cannot decide cases on merits; it can only record settlements arrived at by consensus between parties

ADRlok-adalatconsentsettlementno-adjudicationlandmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2014

Subramanian Swamy v Director, CBI

(2014) 8 Supreme Court Cases 682

Access to justice cannot be blocked by procedural requirements protecting corrupt officials; reinforced need for independent anti-corruption mechanisms

ADRlokpalanti-corruptionsanctionaccess-to-justice
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2018

Sundaram Finance Ltd. v. Abdul Samad

(2018) 3 Supreme Court Cases 622; AIR 2018 SC 965; Civil Appeal No. 1650 of 2018

An arbitral award, once it attains finality, may be executed directly in any court in the country where the judgment-debtor's assets are located; there is no requirement to first obtain a transfer of the decree from the court that had supervisory jurisdiction over the arbitration proceedings.

ADRsection-36executionjurisdictionenforcement
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2021

Vidya Drolia v Durga Trading Corporation

(2021) 2 Supreme Court Cases 1

Four-fold test for non-arbitrability; at S.8/S.11 stage, court applies prima facie test; detailed validity examination left to tribunal

ADRnon-arbitrabilityprima-facie-testsection-8landmark
Read case brief
Supreme Court of India2020

Vijay Karia v Prysmian Cavi E Sistemi SRL

(2020) 11 Supreme Court Cases 1

For foreign awards under S.48, 'public policy' is narrower than for domestic awards; patent illegality is NOT a ground; Indian courts must adopt pro-enforcement approach

ADRsection-48foreign-awardspublic-policypro-enforcementNew-York-Conventionlandmark
Read case brief